8 ms·
Is Angel Investing Out of Hand? Joshua Schachter Thinks So
- chrisaycock 16y agoHe brings-up a good point that most start-ups don't raise enough capital: “If you raise [$500,000 to $700,000], you can pay the two founders decent salaries, you’re able to hire one or two other people, and that gets you maybe eight months, almost a year, except you have to start fundraising again three or four months beforehand."
- pedalpete 16y agoBut isn't it true that most start-ups can't raise more than $1 million without a proven track record or traction? Doesn't the angel round buy the company time to get either a higher fidelity prototype or actually launch the business and get some traction before going for the bigger Series A?
- joshu 16y agoThe context is more generally that a lot of companies are doing the 500-750 now and will all be raising again at the same time mid next-year. Which means many of them are going to fail to raise simply because of the timing.
- pedalpete 16y agocan you elaborate on the 'fail because of timing'?? Do you mean a VC funding cycle where most funds are distributed in one quarter over another (or time of year)? Maybe I continue to miss something. Thanks
- joshu 16y agoI mean more the fact that other startups will be raising at the same time, and you will be competing for attention and money. Consider: Does an angel want take some dollars and a) invest in a new hot startup that he just got introduced to or b) double down in a startup that hasn't seen traction yet and is going back for another year's worth of runway? Using story-based reasoning, the investor is able to convince himself that A is a much better opportunity.
- pedalpete 16y agoThanks for clarifying your thoughts on that. Though I would have thought most start-ups are not returning to Angels for a follow-on round, but rather progressing to VCs for a seed round. I see your logic as the business is probably relying on the initial angel to lead a Series A.
- joshu 16y agoIf you have raised 500k, and have been working for a year and have not shown any traction, you are going to get punished if you try for a series A. You'll do better going back to your angels -- but the current crop of angels may react differently than you expect/hope. That's my overall point.
- Andrewski 16y agoI think a smart "founder" saves his Porsche buying until after the company is actually profitable. A $50k salary for a founder is about the limit until the company is actually raking in some dough, unless the goal is to feel important and drive that sucker into the ground.
- joshu 16y ago50k is often not survivable. Especially in SV, where everything is expensive. I agree that if it is possible you should do that. I'm drawing zero salary right now myself. But more importantly - strong talent is expensive.
- btmorex 16y ago50k is easily survivable in SV as long as you don't have a spouse and kids to support. I'm really having trouble understanding how you need more. Are you doing all your shopping at Whole Foods or something? Eating out 2 times a day? Where does all that money go?
- klbarry 16y agoMy girlfriend and I are surviving easily in NY on about 24,000 a month total, and the valley probably isn't too much more expensive. I also eat delivery fairly often and am not particularly careful with money.
- tptacek 16y agoPresumably, you meant $2,400/month. The average studio apartment in Manhattan is $1900, leaving you with $500 at the end of each month to cover every conceivable expense. MTA to-from work alone ate $180 of that between the two of you.
- joshu 16y agoWhen I lived in NYC you could have a nice, inexpensive apartment in Astoria or Williamsburg for much less than that. When I did delicious, one of my employees could get to our office in manhattan from wburg faster than I could from the Upper West Side, too...
- gyardley 16y agoNothing in this article is wrong -- but raising that healthy Series A at the prototype stage requires a track record most of us don't have. Any first-time entrepreneur who reads this and decides to forego today's very-entrepreneur-friendly angel environment to try and raise a Series A instead is doing themselves a disservice.
- joshu 16y agoYou can raise a priced seed round with a lead investor without going to an A. You can raise a convertible note with a lead investor as well. The article is a BIT confusing.
- gyardley 16y agoYes, I think the "it's important to have a lead that'll help get the Series A done" advice got overshadowed by the "angel-backed companies don't raise enough cash" comment. Having a strong lead in my own (priced) seed round proved very, very, very helpful later on - but I still wasn't able to raise much more than $500K on the first go-round.
- joshu 16y agoI really think 500k is the bare minimum, and 750k is better. But it's very short with no runway... I see way too many startups raise 100-300k or whatever and simply die.
- frederickcook 16y agoRegarding convertible notes: "“You’re putting in money now and getting a valuation later, whether the company is a failure or a success. If it’s a success, you get the valuation after it’s a success, but you really want the valuation of the company to be lower,” he says. “As an investor, that’s the wrong alignment with a start-up.”" I didn't think sophisticated investors were doing convertible notes without valuation caps - something this article makes no mention of. cdixon: "I believe that pretty much every other seed investor who advocates converts also assumes they have a cap. So any discussion of convertibles without caps seems to me a red herring." [1] Clarification please? (Josh?) [1] http://cdixon.org/2010/08/31/converts-versus-equity-deals/ http://cdixon.org/2010/08/31/converts-versus-equity-deals/ EDIT: Congrats on the recent funding and founding!
- joshu 16y agoSome strong deals have no cap. More importantly, angels behind a note want your valuation to be as low as possible (so they get the most value) - it's the misalignment that's most toxic. Also, I'm seeing lots of sky-high caps, too.
- frederickcook 16y agoI don't understand. My company recently raised using convertible notes with a cap right around where an appropriate valuation might have been. Now my investors are all interested in seeing the company valuation at the next funding round be a multiple on the cap. Where are the misaligned interests? Additionally, it seems as though high caps are a separate argument from the "conv. with cap vs. priced round" argument. With either, the market decides what an appropriate valuation, cap, or terms (no cap) a company is able to raise at. Therefore, it is simply the mechanics of the market that lead to no cap notes and sky-high caps, not the fact that the deals are done with convertible notes. Not trying to be argumentative; I'm really interested in learning why you've taken a strong stance on this.
- joshu 16y agoCaps keep the situation from getting totally out of hand. Not everyone is able to get a capped deal done. It's not a stance, it's just an opinion. I was doing converts when I was forced to, or if the caps were reasonable. I just didn't love them.
- erik_landerholm 16y agoGlad we got to him before he decided this...
- joshu 16y agoYeah, well, you also were in my sweet spot for investing. There's a huge class of startups that are just so... played out that I can't even bear to hear the pitches anymore.
- erik_landerholm 16y agoYeah, I hear that. It was/is awesome for us to have you as an investor. Good luck with your new venture. It sounds interesting. You should stop by the office some time. Get a hold of Tommy or me and swing by.
- joshu 16y agoI am still here for you!
- ashot 16y agowhich ones?
- joshu 16y agoHard to say without calling somebody's baby ugly.
- joshu 16y agobtw note that this article came out of a conversation about my motives from switching from angel back to entrepreneur. a better title would have been "it's a tough time to be an angel" or even "now is an awesome time to be a founder"
- zaidf 16y agoJust shows the importance of context. Knowing this, it makes you sound like a smart guy picking founding over angel investing for now. The title makes you sound like some sour angel investor. Of course both things could be equally true in real-life. But not equally communicated by a title or an article.
- joshu 16y agoI think I have been pretty lucky as an angel investor. I think right now a lot of not-great stuff is getting funded, and it's very hard to figure out who is good with all the noise. I do think social signal is valuable and important, and that information is gone now. I just think it's a MUCH better time to be an entrepreneur - there's a lot of easy angel money out there!
- joshu 16y agoHuh -- they changed the title!
- zaidf 16y agoThe writer must be a grade A lurker :) Props to them. Alas, they can't "fool" the URL: /is-angel-investing-out-of-hand-joshua-schachter-thinks-so/