5 ms·
Wait, so if I sell widgets to people in 50 states from my little website, I might have to file and submit collected taxes for 50 states? That seems like a mount
by Waterluvian 8y ago
Wait, so if I sell widgets to people in 50 states from my little website, I might have to file and submit collected taxes for 50 states? That seems like a mountain of work for selling my crappy little widgets.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tyingq 8y agoPredictably, there are several startups in this space.
- eli 8y agoAnd big companies too. Avalara is, I think, the market leader.
- MaureenS 8y agoThanks for the mention, Eli. I work for Avalara on their social media team. We are staying on top of these changes and I wanted to share this clarification. More than a dozen states impose a sales tax collection obligation on marketplace facilitators (Amazon, Etsy, eBay, etc.). In addition to collecting and remitting tax on their own sales into the state, if they have any, marketplace facilitators will soon be responsible for collecting and remitting sales tax on all sales made through the marketplace in even more states. Most recently, Wyoming and California have joined the ranks; Virginia is close, which we expect to be on the books by the middle of this year. We anticipate every state to have a law like this on the books by Q1 of 2020. Where I see a lot of confusion is from sellers who are struggling to understand economic nexus regulations that are based on reaching sales thresholds. Adding to the confusion, these thresholds vary from state-to-state. If you'd like to learn more, our recent blog "How marketplace facilitator sales tax laws in different states affect marketplace sellers" covers this in depth. https://avlr.co/2VFKvCa https://avlr.co/2VFKvCa Here’s an excerpt: "Now that states are no longer prohibited from taxing remote sales, they’re looking for the most efficient ways to bring in remote sales tax revenue. Approximately 35 states have adopted economic nexus laws, which impose a sales tax collection obligation on businesses with significant economic activity in the state. Such economic nexus laws generally provide an exception for small sellers (defined differently in different states). Many marketplace sellers qualify for these small seller exceptions, meaning they’re safe from the long arms of the tax authorities. But states that require marketplace facilitators to collect and remit sales tax on behalf of their sellers still reap revenue from those transactions. It’s a win-win for states, which is why we can expect to see marketplace facilitator sales tax laws proliferate. It’s important to note that marketplace sellers aren’t necessarily freed from all responsibilities under these laws. In fact, these laws can complicate matters a bit because they change the rules. Ordinarily, businesses that don’t have nexus with a state (an obligation to collect sales tax) don’t have reporting requirements. That’s not the case with all marketplace facilitator sales tax laws, as you’ll see below."
- RRWagner 8y agoAs a seller of little widgets that just started on Amazon a few months ago, that's exactly what I have just discovered this past week as Q1 2019 ended. I sell one widget for $25 and I have to file, and I sell $0 in another state where Amazon has a warehouse, and I still have to file. TaxJar will do everything for me, but it's $20 per filing period per state. If you have a monthly filing period in 50 states that will be $1000/month, $12000 year, just to file. Actually paying the taxes, that must also be calculated town-by-town, is on top of the $12000/yr. Note: TaxJar offers a 20% discount for annual and lots of filings, and is a great company and service, but the foregoing illustrates the problems for small companies going forward.
- toss1 8y agoPerhaps I'm missing something, but what is not clear here is whether, going forward, Amazon collects the taxes on Fulfilled-By-Amazon products, and whether that eliminates the need for each small vendor to file separately. If Amazon does not collect the tax, and every small vendor needs to file for every micro-sale, this could have a massive negative effect on online commerce in general and particularly for Amazon, likely to see it's small vendors dropping like flies and undermining it's Get-Anything-On-Amazon approach
- dhimes 8y agoMy hunch is that if this is a problem then Amazon will soon provide a turnkey solution for its vendors. It would be a great competitive advantage to prevent the tax headaches.
- toss1 8y agoSeems like a good hunch. They've certainly got the capital, bandwidth and experience to do this, and id would be a HUGE competitive advantage. If the states get really aggressive going after the small vendors selling from their own websites, it'll even drive them to work through Amazon... Great for the AMZN stockholders, but not so great for the ecosystem...
- rgbrenner 8y ago
- meritt 8y agoJust 50 states would be easy. You're forgetting county and municipal/locality taxes. Or the varying due dates for each of those jurisdictions. Or whether or not your widget business creates a nexus in those states and requires you to register as a foreign entity. Or whether or not your specific widgets trigger a higher or lower taxation rate. Or that whether or not shipping should be taxed also varies state to state. Or... It's a whole lot of work to be legally compliant.
- zaroth 8y agoIt’s impossible for a small business to be entirely compliant. The best you can hope for is to be invisible. IMO it’s encumbent on the Fed to sweep all this away under interstate commerce and make compliance as close to a fully automated process as possible.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gamblor956 8y agoIt's actually quite easy for a small business to be entirely compliant. Step 1: use a SALT SaaS provider that handles your sales tax collection at point-of-sale. Step 2: there is no Step 2. Seriously, there are a dozen providers that handle SALT POS taxes, including Amazon FBA and Shopify.
- compsciphd 8y agoits more complicated than that. such as sales tax holidays and classifying stuff you sell correctly. i.e. packaged food might have no sales in some states but what qualifies as tax free food can vary from state to state. to get this right, you have to make sure you are classifying everything in a very verbose manner that covers every single state.
- ikeboy 8y agoWell a dozen states so far have passed legislation requiring Amazon to collect it instead of you, and the others all have thresholds. California just passed the bill putting the onus on Amazon and more states will probably follow.
- gamblor956 8y agoNo, you're still subject to nexus thresholds (though note: using Amazon FBA will generally trigger this threshold in any state where Amazon maintains distribution facilities and warehouses...which is most of them.) Generally, most states require you to have more than de minimis sales into a state to be subject to sales tax collection (again, unless you use something like Amazon FBA). Amazon and Shopify will handle sales tax for you (now), but they won't handle the threshold determination for you--it's an on-or-off proposition. However, what's happening here is that Amazon is deemed to have created sufficient nexus for the sellers using FBA. Because Amazon is acting as an agent of the seller, and is storing the seller's goods in California, the seller is deemed to have nexus through their agent, Amazon. This is a long-standing interpretation of the law that has been upheld many times. Generally, Amazon should have handled the collection of sales taxes for the sellers, but since it did not, the principal (the seller) is legally responsible for paying them.
- ikeboy 8y agoYou're incorrect about the inventory issue. That was the argument California used, but it was never tested in court and there were strong arguments against it. You're basically repeating California's legal opinion as fact. Then, the Supreme Court ruled last year that nexus doesn't matter, states can tax outside retailers regardless. So many states passed new laws doing just that. The question of whether inventory in FBA creates nexus is still relevant for back taxes, and it's possible that will go to court at some point, although it seems likely California will end up waiving back taxes.
- gamblor956 8y agoNo, you're misunderstanding the SCOTUS ruling in Wayfair. The Supreme Court didn't rule that nexus doesn't matter. They simply eliminated the physical nexus requirement of Quill. There are still (undefined) economic thresholds required for nexus for taxing out-of-state retailers. If you sell $5 of stuff into a state, you aren't subject to sales tax collection in that state. If you sell $100,000 of stuff into a state, you are. Unfortunately, the exact threshold where you have economic nexus varies from state-to-state and not every state has yet updated their laws for Wayfair. However, physical nexus still exists (it's "stronger" than economic nexus), and that is why California treats Amazon FBA inventory as giving rising to nexus. It doesn't matter that it has never been tested in court--it's been generally accepted law in the US for decades (predating Quill) and it would take a court ruling for it to be otherwise. (In fact, part of the Quill decision was premised on the fact the seller did not maintain an office, employees...or inventory...in South Dakota and thus had no physical connection to the state.)