3 ms·
This is a totally broken framework, because while a few things are clearly "innate" (eg skin color), mostly it will just end up functioning as a cover for polit
by mindslight 8y ago
This is a totally broken framework, because while a few things are clearly "innate" (eg skin color), mostly it will just end up functioning as a cover for politicization. For example even if we agree that gay desires are an innate quality, men who have sex with men are still choosing to do that behavior. So then is it okay to discriminate if it is framed in terms of the latter?
This is a direct implication of what you have said. And many of the things you've declared as "innate" aren't even obviously such, so at best we end up with a politicization/corruption of science trying to claim theories as indisputable facts. Couching an argument in progressive-sounding terms may make it sound like a good idea, when it is actually a naive setup for the pendulum to swing hard the other way.
The general principle is live and let live. The whole "protected classes" thing was really just an imperfect approach to pushing back against the glaring worst of identity politics that was causing ongoing direct harm, because the general principle is impossible to codify just like Free speech itself.
But please Mastercard and shareholders, go ahead and cut off your own leg. The more demand created for Free payments, the better.
- sneak 8y ago> And many of the things you've declared as "innate" aren't even obviously such I think your argument against my claim hinges on this belief, and I think it is pretty plainly incorrect. If you have specific arguments against any of the things I have listed being innate, let’s have them. Otherwise, without that lynchpin, the argument against the discrimination boundary of innate/chosen falls apart.
- mindslight 8y agoMy argument hinges on the belief that people in general are going to hold on to a plurality of opinions, and tend to backfit facts based on those opinions. What you are attempting to do is tie the definition of acceptable to "impartial" science. This is tempting because it's authoritative and currently lines up with what you want. But it is a dangerous path because while the scientific process itself is impartial, the focus and interpretation of it is certainly not! Much oppression has been justified by pointing to some groups "innate qualities" and then asserting they need to be "helped". It's also insulting the various struggles that have gotten us to this point, and shirking the current struggles. Did slavery end because some scientist finally got around to discovering that by-gosh Black people are actually the same species, and then everything just fell out? Or was it generations of iterated struggle to both self-organize and wrest acceptance from wider society, which is still going on? I did state something very plainly that is not innate - men having sex with men. The desire may be innate, but the action is not. And sure, you can respond well that's just a proxy for an innate quality of gayness. But I'm not asking you to address this argument as if I'm making it right here, but rather to think about it if it was being made by someone in power to justify ongoing persecution of gays. "Being (innately) gay is fine, just don't put it in our faces". If you think society only moves forward, I'd call that a massive blindspot. Even if something is not innate, path dependence can make it effectively so (eg living in a trailer). Ultimately, the scourge of identity politics doesn't care whether something is innate or not, but whether it can be used to sow divisions and divide people into ingroups and outgroups. And that's the real root of hate.