3 ms·
I don't think building purchasing should even be allowed, remove all of the slippery slope and put students on equal footing.
by munk-a 8y ago
I don't think building purchasing should even be allowed, remove all of the slippery slope and put students on equal footing.
- mc32 8y agoWhy not, it benefits the whole student body and is above board, everyone knows. These people were bribing people who were not in school governance, people in athletics for example, to get their kid in, denying another deserving kid. Neither the school or other students benefitted, only the people partaking in the bribery scheme.
- olliej 8y agoYou still get the wondrous private institution problem of hereditary entry (which is a great example of something that isn't explicitly racist still resulting in a fundamentally and uncorrectable racist result)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ummonk 8y agoYup and while they continue to practice legacy admissions they claim they’ve tried everything to achieve diversity and just have to do affirmative action.
- munk-a 8y agoI agree, and I wish this came up more in discussions around this scandal.
- mochomocha 8y agoUnless you change your admission process to be based on competitive entrance exams everyone has to take, with an anonymous review process. This is mostly the norm in France.
- throwawaymath 8y agoDoes that system come with any notable drawbacks of its own?
- acct1771 8y agoWhat kind of issues usually arise with choosing based on merit?
- throwawaymath 8y agoOff the top of my head I’m not sure, but my question isn’t asking about merit-based selection in the abstract. I’m asking if there are drawbacks to the specific system mentioned; that is, competitive entrance exams with anonymous review.
- kortilla 8y agoChoosing based on merit is viewed as both racist and sexist in the US. For example, check out the controversy over the “meritocracy” rug at github.
- ZeikJT 8y agoBased on being able to do well on a test. Very different kind of merit than I think is actually useful in a lot of real life.
- jonhohle 8y agoPaying for a building, at least, has some public benefit. Direct bribes to individuals only benefits the student and conspirator. (not saying I agree, just that there is more utility)
- NotSammyHagar 8y agoYou are bribing the institution when you buy a building. It could be useful or wasted, just like giving money to a person.
- manfredo 8y agoOne one hand, donating to improve the chances of one's kid getting admitted is kind of scummy. On the other hand, the immense amount of money that gets donated is why elite schools are able to give very generous financial aid. Stanford doesn't even charge tuition if parents make less than $125,000 per year. On principle I'm adverse to wealthy people buying opportunities, but if buying opportunities creates more of them for other people then I think that may be a net good.
- munk-a 8y agoIf the school would benefit from that building why should it be dependent on a rich kid needing to get in to secure that funding? If that rich family didn't end up having a kid that needed to get into that school then the building would never be built - but the family is certainly able to afford funding the construction of that building. I think that's unfair in it's own way on all parties involved.
- manfredo 8y agoPeople rarely give stuff away for free. Philanthropy often serves as a political tool, and a means to increase one's social status. University donations are no different. Families are more willing to donate if they believe that it improves the chances of their kids getting admitted to university.
- asdff 8y agoIn most cases philanthropy is for the tax benefit, everything else is just dressing.
- rurp 8y agoIs there some tax benefit beyond the deduction, or do these people not understand how marginal tax brackets work?
- lawnchair_larry 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]