4 ms·
I feel like the solution here is to not bribe your children's way into school. If your children aren't academically talented and you don't have the money to pu
by olliej 8y ago
I feel like the solution here is to not bribe your children's way into school.
If your children aren't academically talented and you don't have the money to publicly buy a building for the school you should accept that and just let them live off your money and power as is traditional.
- darpa_escapee 8y ago> If your children aren't academically talented and you don't have the money to publicly buy a building for the school you should accept that and just let them live off your money and power as is traditional. The tradition is nepotism and bribes. It's a relatively recent thing for the state to go after the moderately wealthy for doing what they've done for millennia.
- olliej 8y agoThat was a joke targeting the tradition of the rich and powerful using said riches and power to get in, but at least it was obvious and in the public eye - it doesn't take a huge amount of deductive reasoning to see the connection between the new "Mark McMarksFace" Building and little jimmy mcmarksface gets into school). Similarly seeing friends and family of the school board getting in shouldn't be shocking.
- frankchn 8y agoI think a key difference here is that the McMarksFace building is given to the university, while the bribery scandal involves giving money to individuals. An analogy would be "buying" a car by giving $5k to the salesperson to get the keys rather than $50k to the dealership to actually buy it.
- munk-a 8y agoI don't think building purchasing should even be allowed, remove all of the slippery slope and put students on equal footing.
- mc32 8y agoWhy not, it benefits the whole student body and is above board, everyone knows. These people were bribing people who were not in school governance, people in athletics for example, to get their kid in, denying another deserving kid. Neither the school or other students benefitted, only the people partaking in the bribery scheme.
- olliej 8y agoYou still get the wondrous private institution problem of hereditary entry (which is a great example of something that isn't explicitly racist still resulting in a fundamentally and uncorrectable racist result)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ummonk 8y agoYup and while they continue to practice legacy admissions they claim they’ve tried everything to achieve diversity and just have to do affirmative action.
- munk-a 8y agoI agree, and I wish this came up more in discussions around this scandal.
- mochomocha 8y agoUnless you change your admission process to be based on competitive entrance exams everyone has to take, with an anonymous review process. This is mostly the norm in France.
- throwawaymath 8y agoDoes that system come with any notable drawbacks of its own?
- 8y ago
- slg 8y ago>I feel like the solution here is to not bribe your children's way into school. Or maybe the solution should be to stop accepting bribes. I really am surprised that almost all of the public outrage is being directed at the parents and more of it isn't being directed at the people who actually received the cash. I think lots of parents are willing to stretch their morals in order to give their kid every possible advantage in life. That isn't exactly noble behavior, but it is more forgivable to me than the old-fashioned financially motivated corruption of the people who accepted the bribes. And even the school agreeing to the "buying a building" style bribe has some type of altruistic motive to improve the welfare of the school. The people accepting these bribes were just trying to get rich.
- pasquinelli 8y agoWhat if the people accepting bribes have mouths to feed at home? They're just stretching their morals for their kids too.
- slg 8y agoCoaches and administrators of D1 sports programs are already well compensated. Plus no one needs $400k payments to feed their kids unless they have made some horrible financial mistakes.
- CydeWeys 8y agoReally? You think that the coach of, say, a D1 rowing team is going to be well-compensated? I doubt it. They'll certainly be less well-compensated than all of the FAANG engineers they're competing against in the housing market.
- slg 8y agoFirst result on Google[1] says the median salary for a Pac-12 rowing coach is $132,500 and I would bet Stanford is paying more than the median. That also doesn't include bonuses, other non-salary compensation from the school, or money from other non-school specific sources (it is relatively common for coaches to get compensated by vendors, run instructional camps, or have other auxiliary sources of income). So they might not match the arbitrary comparison of FAANG engineers, but they are a far cry from claiming they can't feed their kids without resulting to bribes. [1] - http://collegerowcoach.org/crca-salary-survey-results-2/ http://collegerowcoach.org/crca-salary-survey-results-2/
- sgustard 8y agoStanford has explicitly said they do not accept donations in return for admission, for what that's worth. Source: https://news.stanford.edu/2019/03/14/admission-case-info/ https://news.stanford.edu/2019/03/14/admission-case-info/ "A donation does not purchase a place at Stanford, and we work very hard to ensure that prospective donors understand this. Stanford does not accept gifts if it knows a gift is being made with the intention of influencing the admission process."
- cycrutchfield 8y agoThat's a hilarious joke!
- twinkletwinkle_ 8y agoI would love to meet the author of that line. I have a bridge to donate to them!
- asdff 8y agoReading between the lines: donate the building while your kid is in diapers and get that dividend 18 years later.
- naveen99 8y agoBy definition a donation cannot come with strings attached. but it will influence their admissions process, because they don’t want to discourage future no strings attached donations...
- whyenot 8y agoLikely true, at least in a direct sense, but Stanford does give a nearly three-fold preference to legacy applicants. Alumni are more likely to donate to Stanford than non-alumni. https://stanfordmag.org/contents/what-it-takes https://stanfordmag.org/contents/what-it-takes
- pauljurczak 8y agoOf course! Just like a political campaign contribution in no way affects the future voting pattern of a candidate.
- barry-cotter 8y agoApparently academic talent is not reliably enough to get into a UC anymore, due to the vagaries of yield management and going to a school full of high achievers making it difficult to stand out when you’d walk it if you went to a school with less gifted average students. This is obviously only a problem for a very small segment of the population but if getting an academic publication in high school is not enough to get into an elite college the system is broken. > In my local public schools, the average SAT is 1470, higher than half of the Ivy League (this pretty much tells you where I live). A lot of that is due to selection of middle class Bay Area professionals, but much of it is due to focussed test prep. Local test prep (which is ridiculously intense) can add 200 points, if you commit to doing it. As a result, all those people who have near straight As can increase their score until their SATs (or ACTs) are near perfect. This leaves a huge pool. ... > Can you get into one of these schools by being academically brilliant? Essentially no. The professors have no power to help a student get accepted. There is just no way for them to intervene. People joke saying a first author paper in Nature would do the job, but as no teen has published a paper in Nature as first author in time for admissions (the paper needs to be accepted by November of your senior year, 6 months of review time would be fast, a high schooler is unlikely to get a straight accept, so most likely will need to revise and resubmit. Realistically, submitting your ground breaking research by the end of your sophmore year would be in time. This does not happen.) I know of cases where students have had published papers by admission time. Harvard, Yale and MIT have a way to upload published papers in the admission process, but in the case I am familiar with, the papers were not reviewed by professors. How do I know this? The student was in email contact with the relevant professors (in all three colleges), as about 80% of college professors will get back to high school students who send them papers, with marked up comments (professors are wonderful). They told the child the admission committee did not contact them, and said they would admit the child to graduate school, but had no power over undergraduate admissions. At least one child with one publication in Analytic Philosophy do not get admitted to these schools. https://www.reddit.com/r/slatestarcodex/comments/bdpv1f/comment/el3b0hm https://www.reddit.com/r/slatestarcodex/comments/bdpv1f/comm...
- saagarjha 8y ago> the whole math competition system is incredibly valuable because it's the last bastion of truly meritocratic examination systems in the country. (The other Olympiads are as well, but they're not even 10% as large.) Test prep services for it barely do anything. This is false, speaking from my experience at a top high school in the Bay Area (I was never +4 standard deviations, but did come close in some isolated cases). 90+% of the people who did well in math competitions were on Art of Problem Solving at some point. It's entirely possible to coach for these, it just requires coaching from people who are extremely talented (and expensive!)