51 ms·
I reject this - if we want admission in the US to be entirely wealth based and Oligarchic we should just buy that concept whole-hog. Many of us (I hope?) belie
by munk-a 8y ago
I reject this - if we want admission in the US to be entirely wealth based and Oligarchic we should just buy that concept whole-hog. Many of us (I hope?) believe that scholarships that allow smart people coming from bad backgrounds to succeed are worth their cost[1] so clearly the ability to make use of your education is part of our general societal motivation to give someone one.
[1] There are lots of scholarships, grants and other things out there, many go to people who don't need them and there are issues with the system both on that end and with regards to the cost for an education - please ignore those and just focus on the concept of financial aide to an intelligent driven student who genuinely needs it to pay fair value to get an education in terms of reimbursing all expenses given to give this student an education and nothing else.
- phil21 8y agoDon't you need the funding of the super rich guy with the dumb kid who takes up a single student slot in order to offer free school to the dozen kids who "deserve" it academically? Without the first (in aggregate, over generations), the others don't even have the option.
- darpa_escapee 8y agoPlenty of people make donations for reasons of prestige, legacy and even genuine care, which have nothing to do with making sure their kid gets into a certain school.
- stale2002 8y agoBut there would still be less of those donations. There would be some, yes. But significantly less. And less money means that these school are unable to let in as many poor people as they did before.
- munk-a 8y agoIn general terms regarding systems in our society - If the system is dependent on charity to support it... it isn't supported, if the system is valued by society then society should support it up to the cost of it's value. Education is absolutely worth the cost and the need to charity is highlighting the underfunding here[1]. [1] Also, the inefficient use of money, higher education is absolutely guilty of inefficient operation with lots of cushy bureaucrat jobs, but imagine we could make higher education efficient and it still required an additional injection of cash via charitable donations.
- stale2002 8y ago> If the system is dependent on charity to support it... it isn't supported This could apply to literally everything in the world, forever. Unless 1,000 trillion dollars per year is being spent on education, then that educational system would benefit from more charity. More charity is basically always good. Nobody at all loses from this. More money gets spent on the university, and this money more than pays for the cost of the student. This allows even more students to benefit from this. Why should we sacrifice the education of 10 kids, just to stop 1 rich kid from going to a top college?
- kortilla 8y ago>In general terms regarding systems in our society - If the system is dependent on charity to support it... it isn't supported Whoops, you got that backwards. If a system is dependent on compulsory taxes, it isn’t supported. If nobody cares to voluntarily donate to it or pay for services on their own, then it’s not something really valued by society.
- beenBoutIT 8y agoIn the US the public universities are the only schools that can't be bought into at any cost.
- azeotropic 8y agoHuh? UCLA is a public university. Or am I missing the joke?
- defen 8y agoIt’s USC, not UCLA, unless I missed something.
- azeotropic 8y agoYou did miss something. The first guilty plea was from a couple who paid to get their eldest daughter into UCLA and their next daughter into USC. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-05-01/first-parents-plead-guilty-in-college-admissions-scandal https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-05-01/first-par...
- defen 8y agoNoted, thanks
- chris11 8y agoDr. Dre's daughter got into USC after Dr Dre co-founded a school there. Sure, the donation was made in 2013, but I'm sure the 70 million dollar donation impacted their decision. https://iovine-young.usc.edu/about/index.html https://iovine-young.usc.edu/about/index.html https://variety.com/2019/music/news/dr-dre-usc-daughters-tweet-deleted-felicity-huffman-usc-1203171304/ https://variety.com/2019/music/news/dr-dre-usc-daughters-twe...
- mgfist 8y agoI'm not really sure what you're trying to say here.
- munk-a 8y agoColleges are an educational resource, that we currently conceive of as limited - this resource should be distributed primarily to the students who benefit from it the most. Other factors like legacy, donations, bribes, and athletic ability should all be removed from the equation.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 8y agoThere's a massive amount of daylight between wanting admissions to be completely oligarchic and recognizing that at some point a seat should have a price. For example, suppose it was worth it to Bezos to fund the entire Harvard class of '23, and the price is that his child ought to be a member of that class. It would be absurd for Harvard to turn this down. There is no victim of this trade, except perhaps Bezos' heirs -- Harvard can use a small fraction of the money to create an extra seat for the would be freshman. That does not mean admissions would be oligarchic in its entirety. It would not have to affect the "meritocracy" by which the remaining seats are won. Being willing to accept profoundly large donations in exchange for a seat is not the same as turning the whole admissions process into an auction. There are not enough people willing to give such donations for a seat. Or, maybe a slightly more cynical take? Look at the parental wealth distribution of private colleges, and you'll notice that it already is "oligarchic." I mean in the sense that children of relatively wealthy parents are by far more likely to make the cut to get in in the first place.
- munk-a 8y agoWhy should Bezos, poor billionaire that he is, need to pay such a ridiculous price for his child's education. Wouldn't it make more sense to just publicly fund the creation of these seats and have people pay their fair share? I think the scenario you set up for Bezos is actually unjust against him - maybe people should pay admission costs to support the education of society's children in a manner that fairly spreads that cost across those who benefit from that education.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 8y agoIt's not up to me, or any of us. It's up to Harvard, and specifically its board of trustees. Presumably Harvard doesn't want just anyone to be able to donate the accounting cost of a seat, because the cost doesn't scale linearly. Just like with company culture, it's hard to scale up. And putting the machinery in place to facilitate such transactions would be difficult. It's much easier to say that they'll give a spot only when the donation far exceeds the cost of a seat. That way you don't need any complicated machinery. The exact limit may not even be written down anywhere. It might just be a sort of "I'll know it when I see it," sort of deal, since the number of seats given this way per year should be fairly small, even at a university as famed as Harvard. Of course, we don't actually know that any of this is happening at all. It's just a cynical presumption, as far as I can tell. All I'm saying is that it would be reasonable if it were done this way, at least from the perspective of all stakeholders who have a say in the matter.