3 ms·
> it's unacceptable for automation to produce a worse result than a human in the same situation, with the same information I don't think anyone disagrees on th
by lucb1e 8y ago
> it's unacceptable for automation to produce a worse result than a human in the same situation, with the same information
I don't think anyone disagrees on that. The question is: is the software worse than a human driver? Do we have enough data for a statistically significant judgement on that? Is it even autonomous enough to say anything either way, like, if the driver is required to be at attention anyway, can the software be blamed for anything in the first place? Those are the questions, I don't think there is a point saying "software must be good!"
- jessriedel 8y ago>> it's unacceptable for automation to produce a worse result than a human in the same situation, with the same information > I don't think anyone disagrees on that. I disagree on that. If there's an autonomous vehicle that is better than a human in most situations, and worse in a few situations, such that the overall accident/death rate is lower, and there is no reasonable away to identify the rare dangerous situations in time to disable the autopilot, I would want to drive that car and would advise others to do so. In fact, if there was an autonomous vehicle that was almost exactly as safe as a human but slightly more dangerous (say, a 10% higher death/accident rate), I would frequently use it because the large benefits outweigh the minor statistical costs. (Indeed, I use a car at all because of its benefits over walking, busing, or staying at home, despite the higher rate of death.) If other people understood the risks, I would also suggest that they to do likewise.