5 ms·
Interesting view. Near the end, it says: “The crux of today's cosmological paradigm is that in order to maintain a mathematically unified theory valid for the
by hhs 8y ago
Interesting view. Near the end, it says:
“The crux of today's cosmological paradigm is that in order to maintain a mathematically unified theory valid for the entire universe, we must accept that 95 percent of our cosmos is furnished by completely unknown elements and forces for which we have no empirical evidence whatsoever.”
Empiricism is based on sense observations. And a lot of science has been confined to human senses. I’m curious if tapping into more basic science research by analyzing different types of senses, for instance, available to animals, may offer breakthroughs down the line. For instance, fish employ the lateral line system to detect pressure gradients in the environment.
- wilg 8y agoWhat kind of senses available to animals are there that we should be using for science? Also I'm not entirely sure what you mean that we're confined to "the 5 senses". First, humans have way more senses. Second, I don't think it's confining ourself to build technology that converts something we can't sense (like gravitational waves) into something we can (like a spreadsheet).
- dfischer 8y agoWhat aren’t we using from the animal kingdom? We create sensors that are extra human. Infrared etc... Maybe this is an unknown unknown problem. We can’t develop technology for senses we do not know about and so on.
- chongli 8y agoWe have no better access to the sense data of the Ampullae of Lorenzini in a shark than we do to the signals recorded by a radio telescope. Arguably, our access is worse for the shark than for the telescope. Ultimately, no matter what we use to record the data (animal or instrument), we can only access the results through our 5 senses.
- gerbilly 8y agoOne way to think of scientific instruments: like telescopes, microscopes, voltmeters is that they are extensions of our senses.
- hhs 8y agoI agree, thanks for the note.
- JackFr 8y agoBut the reality of them is that they are not extensions of our senses, so much as compressors of experience. That is they map a broader reality into our limited sensate experience. When we use them we have to remember that the map is not the territory, and we have to be especially careful about artifacts they may introduce.
- jerf 8y agoWhen it comes to cosmology, our observations have been using light, because that's what has traveled in space. It is pretty obviously not that useful to ask a dog to sniff the sky or a homing pidgeon to navigate to Alpha Centauri, or something. We've obviously long since passed using only the visible spectrum. We also recently added gravitational wave detection to our repertoire. I seriously doubt any animals out there are detecting gravitational waves. I'm not sure how a science based on observing every wavelength of light we can get our hands on, the vast majority of which no animal on Earth can detect or use, and also gravitational waves, is "confined to human senses".
- hhs 8y agoMakes sense, and agree with the last point, “I'm not sure how a science based on observing every wavelength of light we can get our hands on, the vast majority of which no animal on Earth can detect or use, and also gravitational waves, is "confined to human senses"”. Thanks for the explanation.
- lkrubner 8y agoAbout this: "It is pretty obviously not that useful to ask a dog to sniff the sky or a homing pidgeon to navigate to Alpha Centauri, or something." That example might be bad, but there are others that are valid. For instance, in healthy human women, the menstruation cycle seems to be the exact length of the moon's orbit. Is that a coincidence, or do human bodies have a way of gaining data from the moon? If so, what is that data? Maybe the mechanism is as simple as a springy protein that can absorb tidal forces and convert it to an information signal. Or perhaps something novel is going on. There are potentially a lot we can learn about the universe by making simple observations here on Earth.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y ago> For instance, in healthy human women, the menstruation cycle seems to be the exact length of the moon's orbit. That seems to be absolute coincidence. If there was a value in syncing to the lunar cycle it would stand to reason there would be a synchronization with the characteristics of the lunar cycle - ie ovulation on the 14th day or something. As it is, there is no link between when a woman's cycle and the lunar cycle begin, they just happen to occur with the same (ugh) period. I don't know what tidal forces women could be keying into that would result in totally seperate start and end dates. It's also important to note the 28 days falls on the average, but the range is anywhere from 21 to 35 days for normal women. It's in no way the exact length of the moon's orbit.