3 ms·
> Do you not think there's a case to be made here for MUAs to implement e.g. ACME and make this seamless? Something like ACME for email certificates would be h
by jcranmer 8y ago
> Do you not think there's a case to be made here for MUAs to implement e.g. ACME and make this seamless?
Something like ACME for email certificates would be helpful, but I don't think that's anywhere near the major blocker for practical email encryption.
In addition to the difficulty of acquiring certificates, email is quite likely to be read from different devices (including webmail!). This makes key management more challenging compared to server SSL keys, especially because you also have a much, much longer tail of email applications trying to read email. Key discovery is a difficult topic, depending on how much you trust MTAs and how much you're willing to give up on decentralized email. Widespread email encryption would also probably destroy anti-spam solutions.
Of course, the most difficult problem of all is that the threat model for email is rather different than for SSL. The automatic provisioning of DV certificates effectively relies on the difficulty of spoofing and intercepting a connection on the wider internet and is less effective against nation-state-level threats (if the US government wanted to get a certificate for any domain, it probably could). But email is already naturally secured against those common threats, as your connection to the email servers are protected by SSL. Instead, the goal of email certificates is to protect against others who (might) have access to your email account... which means that automatic provisioning of certificates doesn't cut it.