3 ms·
The researchers found that analyzing the captured images from a bird’s-eye view, rather than the more traditional frontal view, more than tripled their accuracy
by gamblor956 8y ago
The researchers found that analyzing the captured images from a bird’s-eye view, rather than the more traditional frontal view, more than tripled their accuracy, making stereo camera a viable and low-cost alternative to LiDAR.
I look forward to the day when cars have giraffe-necks protruding from their roofs, mounted with stereo cameras...
But until then, the researchers actually just confirmed that front-mount cameras are only about a third as accurate as LIDAR.
- jjeaff 8y agoI'm imagining a Mario Kart style drone that floats above the vehicles with a camera. And as a bonus, if the car flies off the road into the river, it can use a fishing pole style winch to pull your vehicle out of the water and place it back on the road.
- WhatIsDukkha 8y agoI'm REALLY unclear how you decided to post this giraffe comment... The picture and the words in the article show cameras next to the rear view mirror. """ Using two inexpensive cameras on either side of a vehicle’s windshield, Cornell researchers have discovered they can detect objects with nearly LiDAR’s accuracy and at a fraction of the cost."""
- gamblor956 8y agoThat's not what the article originally said, so it appears that it's been updated since then. Good think I quoted the relevant section of the article in my comment... That being said, existing self-driving cars already have some cameras at that level without displaying the sort of accuracy the researchers found, which relates to the methodology issues other commenters have noted.
- DennisP 8y agoThe researchers described a new way of processing the data, claiming a dramatic improvement over previous methods.
- gamblor956 8y agoIn accuracy, over existing visual systems, but still worse than LIDAR and at the cost of several processing-intensive intermediate steps. In any conceivable situation where you'd use this, it would actually be better to just use LIDAR.
- WhatIsDukkha 8y agoThat quote I posted was the sentences just before the ones you selected. Why don't you read the paper a bit - https://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.07179.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1812.07179.pdf And then work out why they used the words "birds eye" that you found so upsetting.
- gamblor956 8y agoThanks for the paper. I actually agree with those complaining about the methodology of the paper and if anything, having read the article I agree it even more strongly states why LIDAR is essential for the foreseeable future. The research paper, in a nutshell, was about transforming stereovisual images to psuedo-birds eye data, like roof-mounted LIDAR. This, theoretically, would result in about a 350% improvement over current vision-based methods...but still only 50% of that of existing LIDAR systems. In exchange, you just have to 1) convert the stereovisual data to a 3d point cloud, 2) transform the point cloud to birds-eye perspective, and 3) run the LIDAR systems on the point cloud, and 4) do that all in milli-seconds.