4 ms·
> the people advocating that it is an emergency seem to implicitly accept that the cost of nuclear is even higher than the cost of AGW You're mixing two groups
by viraptor 8y ago
> the people advocating that it is an emergency seem to implicitly accept that the cost of nuclear is even higher than the cost of AGW
You're mixing two groups of people and presenting them together based on your idea of them. Opinions about the risk of nuclear power and the risk of agw are orthogonal.
- roenxi 8y agoI'm doing a lot of hand-waving but the two topics aren't orthogonal nor are opinions. I don't see how a person can be taken seriously if they are claiming there is an extreme risk from climate change and not fairly radically pro-nuclear. I've seen mass protests about climate change, they don't tend to be chanting "nuclear now". The times might be changing now, but for most of the environmental movement's history nuclear has remained by far the most cost-effective choice. If they were serious about the risk of climate change then there would be massive pushes for nuclear power coming out of the green factions. I havn't seen it; only in isolated cases (tending towards engineers and scientists who care about the environment). The mainstream environmentalists tend to be in favour solar and wind. If there is time to let perfect be the enemy of good enough then the threat can't be that urgent. The right wing is perfectly reasonable in dragging their heels. Look how successful that strategy has been so far; solar is almost economic on its own merits.
- viraptor 8y ago> but the two topics aren't orthogonal nor are opinions. The topics are orthogonal. You can have independent opinions about either of them. There's a group with common opinions on both, but that doesn't mean you can't place yourself in in another position. But you don't get all the choices you want. For some reason no party around me wants replacement with nuclear power as a policy, so the next best thing is voting for those who care about doing anything: green, or some independent. I know a green's councillor who's pro-nuclear, but runs with greens so she can make any difference at all. I'm not sure what realistic option for a common person are you proposing that are better than "vote green and say their nuclear policy is shit"?