4 ms·
And what's the root cause of this absurd arrangement that doesn't exist in unregulated markets?
by BurningFrog 8y ago
And what's the root cause of this absurd arrangement that doesn't exist in unregulated markets?
- thaumasiotes 8y agoAs I understand it, employer provision of health insurance originated as a way to sneak around legal maximum wages (during WWII?).
- EliRivers 8y agoSounds about right. Extending this, and considering employer-provided health insurance as effectivly a tax on your income, and suddenly the US is heavily taxed. I'm sure this analysis[0] has plenty of critique waiting to pounce, but it's something to consider. [0] https://www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2019/04/08/us-workers-are-highly-taxed-when-you-count-health-premiums/ https://www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2019/04/08/us-workers-a...
- colechristensen 8y agoMedicine and testing isn't available on an actual physical shelf and the prices aren't advertised. Send out a flier in the Sunday newspaper and the margins on medicine will reduce to as close to zero as possible just like food.
- gumby 8y agoFortunately there’s a natural experiment of precisely this: drug ads targeting consumers were illegal until 1985. The result has been an explosion in drug prices; the ads were used as a way to try to go around any pricing constraints. I worked for a time in pharma and believe me direct to consumer was seen as a boon to profit margins, not a constraint.
- BurningFrog 8y agoI see ads for drugs. But I never see ads for cheap drugs. So I think you're talking about different things.
- colechristensen 8y agoI'm talking about grocery store ads selling baby back ribs for 2.99/lb not "got milk?" ads by the milk board. Public transparent pricing that will drive consumers to pick and choose their health care providers would do great things for the ridiculous situation we are in.
- nybble41 8y agoThat is an entirely predictable result when you have direct-to-consumer advertising but not direct-to-consumer supply. You just get all the demand the pharmaceutical companies can manufacture without any competition on the supply side to drive down prices.
- danmaz74 8y agoThese things happen all the time in real world free unregulated markets. The seller looks at you, tries to understand how much you can afford and what are your alternatives right then, and to get the highest price possible. If you are desperate and your life is at risk, they can literally strip you naked - just see how many unscrupulous people become rich during wars. When you are in a medical emergency, and you need a treatment right there and right then - no time to shop around - why should an unregulated, shareholder value maximising business, not extract from you as much as you can afford?
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoFind me a loosely regulated market where prices fluctuate on the same order magnitude as they do in medical. Gouging related to temporary situations is a laughable comparison.
- danmaz74 8y agoFind me another market where people need to urgently make choices that affect their life and death, or that of their loved ones. The comparison isn't laughable at all.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoThat herring is so red it may as well be a cooked lobster. The overwhelming majority of medical care is not urgent care. The overwhelming majority of medical costs are costs that can be foreseen long enough in advance to shop around. Even if you think you might have skin cancer you're still in a position to choose where you go to get your tests.
- empath75 8y agoHospitals won’t tell you the costs of treatment ahead of time, even for easily predictable items like baby delivery. It’s impossible to shop around. https://youtu.be/Tct38KwROdw https://youtu.be/Tct38KwROdw
- philipps 8y agoThe evidence from health care systems in other countries suggests that this type of excessive rent seeking does not exist in regulated markets. It’s the lack of regulation in the US that is the problem, not the other way around.
- loudmax 8y agoI think a more nuanced explanation is that the problem isn't the amount of regulation but the nature of the regulation. If we simply add up all the rules, healthcare is probably more regulated in the US than anywhere else in the world. The difference is that in other countries the rules are designed with the intention of making healthcare accessible to everyone. In the US, the rules are designed to maximize profits. A less nuanced explanation is to agree that in an unregulated market, this type of excessive rent seeking would not exist. The old and sick would simply die in the streets. (Actually that's not quite fair since in an unregulated market we wouldn't have streets.)
- philipps 8y agoPolicies can always be improved but the relationship between stronger regulation in health care and more access (lower cost) is pretty robust across the world. Nobody openly argues for policies that will lead to higher cost and less access.
- BurningFrog 8y agoHealth care is an extremely regulated industry in the US. Possibly the most regulated one, though it's hard to come up with a way to measure that. Obamacare alone added 20,000 pages of regulations.
- conanbatt 8y agoUS healthcare lack of regulation? Good god.
- empath75 8y agoPrice insensitive customers. You can get away with a lot when the alternative to buying your product is pain, suffering and/or death.