16 ms·
Re: brokerages, no it doesn't say you can't open one, but good luck finding a foreign brokerage that'll open an account for you. I was denied by HSBC in Canada
by arcticbull 8y ago
Re: brokerages, no it doesn't say you can't open one, but good luck finding a foreign brokerage that'll open an account for you. I was denied by HSBC in Canada because while I'm a Canadian citizen I'm a US resident and that was the address they had on file. This is common corporate practice the world over. The letter of the law is irrelevant if nobody will play ball with you.
> So here's my question: wouldn't the right thing to do be to distribute all of the revenue equally to the whole world? Is that fine?
If you're still alive feel free to do so subject to the rules and regulations of your jurisdiction. If you die with an estate, it'll get handed out by the government of the place in which you were last resident. It's not that complicated, it's how it works right now, just with a higher rate and a lower exemption. I'm not exactly breaking ground here.
> In summary, what I can say is: all of your ideas and arguments are truly shallow, poorly thought-out, logically inconsistent, and incoherent. While leaning heavily towards communistic tendencies, and an utter destruction of personal freedom / individual liberty.
This entire block was logical fallacy, simply attacking me instead of the argument. This is a great way to lose a debate, so when you're having a consequential debate in your real life, I suggest you avoid this line of attack.
It's interesting that what I propose was the law of the land in the US for much of the 1900s. The US estate tax was between 70 and 80% from the early 1930s to the late 1980s. This included the entirety of the so-called "second red scare" (1947-1960). Clearly the neo-McCarthy-ites didn't consider this to be "communist" or an "utter destruction of freedom and liberty." During this same period the top marginal tax rate was between 80 and 95%. You'd think if it was classically "communist" leaning, that might have come up? This isn't meant to be an appeal to authority, nothing I've suggested furthers the Communist agenda of "advocating class war and leading to a society in which all property is publicly owned and each person works and is paid according to their abilities and needs." I'm pro- wealth inequality and pro- income inequality so long as it's coupled with social mobility and people start out more or less from the same place in each generation. [1]
To quote Wikipedia, "free market supporters of the tax, including Adam Smith and the founding fathers would argue that people should be able to get to the top of the market through earning wealth, based on meritocratic competition, not through unearned, inherited handouts, which were central to the aristocratic systems they were opposed to." [1]
I posit to you that having generations start off on even footing is the definition of meritocracy and the American Way, and you're representing the post-1990s modern neo-con mentality. That's fine, and I don't think your arguments are "poorly thought-out and inconsistent" -- I just disagree with you.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estate_tax_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estate_tax_in_the_United_State...