6 ms·
> Mr. Ephgrave, the assistant commissioner, acknowledged such concerns in his statement. > “We understand that how personal data is used can be a source of anx
by dgellow 8y ago
> Mr. Ephgrave, the assistant commissioner, acknowledged such concerns in his statement.
> “We understand that how personal data is used can be a source of anxiety,” he said. “We would never want victims to feel that they can’t report crimes because of ‘intrusion’ in their data.”
> “That’s why a new national form has been introduced,” replacing policies that varied from place to place, “to help police seek informed consent proportionately and consistently.”
I’m sorry for not having something smarter to say, but what the actual fuck? That sounds like what a tech company would say to try to justify their new data policy. That’s terrible coming from an institution that is supposed to protect people under its jurisdiction.
- huffmsa 8y agoIt's a non-sequiter. > We don't want you to be concerned > Now here's this new TOS which is what you're concerned about, but it is new, and shiny.
- collyw 8y ago>That’s terrible coming from an institution that is supposed to protect people under its jurisdiction. Nah, they are there to protect those in power. Been that way for a while in case you didn't notice.
- kyleblarson 8y agoDon't disagree with you at all but have noticed people using the phrase 'what the actual fuck' a lot lately. I can obviously infer that it's adding emphasis but it just doesn't make sense to me.
- aaomidi 8y agoThe fact that you can understand what it means indicates that it is a phrase that is entering our language.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 8y agoSo, you understand what it means, but you don't understand what it means?
- kyleblarson 8y agoIt sounds kludgy and incorrect.
- ionised 8y agoMost slang does until you hear it enough.
- jessriedel 8y agoNot sure about the UK, but in the US the police have no formal duty to protect you. No matter how much warning/info/evidence they have that someone will be victimized, and no matter how easy/reasonable it is for the police to prevent it, citizens are generically not entitled to compensation for failure to be protected. Rather, the police's mission (both formally and as a functional matter) is overwhelmingly about catching and punishing criminals after-the-fact, and they have wide discretion to choose which crimes to enforce on. So the only protection is in the form of criminal disincentives (which are extremely important, of course).
- SlowRobotAhead 8y agoThat’s correct. The extreme percentage of police duties are only to document crime.
- username223 8y agoWe can always vote and legislate for something better. From my experience in the US, police vary from decent people just trying to serve society, to up-armored mall cops on power trips. If you give them assault rifles, tanks, and unlimited surveillance, you encourage the worst among them. A guy wearing a uniform and trained in de-escalation instead of "verbal control" could do some good.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y ago> We can always vote and legislate for something better. How? Which political party or independents promote a policy to reduce police powers? And even if there were, or are, any politicians with such a policy we ought to be more suspicious of them!
- johnisgood 8y agoYeah, it is not going to happen through such ways. No way. Whoever would want to do it would be getting pressure from influential people on multiple fronts. Let us play with the thought though. Who would go through such risks? What would they gain from it?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- DanBC 8y agoI'm not sure I understand your point. In England we don't have a national police force; we have lots of local forces. There's wide variation in how they respond to crime. We noticed this variation was causing injustice: women (and men) who were raped were not having their crimes robustly investigated; men who were accused of rape were not having their defence robustly investigated. The new guidance is telling police precisely what they can (and thus can't) ask for, and when (and thus when not) they can ask for it. Fishing expeditions are not allowed.
- claudiawerner 8y agoThe point being made by GP is that the rules are already too broad; simply writing them down does very little (if anything) to address the worry about data intrusion. If I were to do something horrible to another person, they wouldn't have much reassurance if I said "here's a list of what I can (and thus can't) do to you, and when (and thus when not) I can do it to you". I'm a very data security conscious person. If something bad happened to me the last thing I'd want is for the police to say that they can't continue to work on my case unless I grant them access to my device(s) and then trust them to not be (deliberately or not) "incompetent" with what they're doing. If anything this should be part of a policy in which victims elect to volunteer information when asked if there's anything that could help the case. I can actually easily imagine a case in which I've been sexually assaulted (and this has happened to me) and I would not go to the police if they had a policy like this. If the police are searching on my phone, what if I have something illegal I don't want them to see? Something they might think is 'concerning' that they can write down and decide to pursue later? What if I'm a sex worker and they can find out through looking at my phone, and even gather proof that fact? And before we say that we can trust them to be competent, what about the other story here?[0] What about the myriad of horrible laws that are passed in England and Wales which restrain even private possession of comics? [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19785416 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19785416
- sjy 8y ago> the last thing I'd want is for the police to say that they can't continue to work on my case unless I grant them access to my device(s) ... If anything this should be part of a policy in which victims elect to volunteer information when asked if there's anything that could help the case My understanding is that the police in the UK have always been required to pursue reasonable lines of enquiry, including those that might contradict the complainant's evidence. That means when investigating a crime they must consider the possibility that the victim is not telling the whole story (where it is reasonable to do so, eg. there is no way to corroborate the victim's account). The new guidelines (which, unfortunately, I can't find the full text of) apparently tell the police when they should exercise the power they have always had: to tell victims "we don't have enough evidence to justify putting further effort into this investigation, unless you agree to hand over your phone to us, because that would increase our confidence that you are telling us the truth." Police have competing priorities and it is inevitable that some crimes go unpunished because the witnesses are not believed by police, or refuse to voluntarily provide information which could affect their credibility. I am sure I would agree with the police doing this in some extreme cases, but as another data security conscious person, it's unlikely I would fully agree with the police interpretation of "necessary and appropriate." [1] [1]: https://twitter.com/PoliceChiefs/status/1122757012859904002 https://twitter.com/PoliceChiefs/status/1122757012859904002
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sundvor 8y agoAs a victim you may be prosecuted if police discover something irrelevant to the case, yet still incriminating. This seems to have the potential of severe abuse, if a rapist is aware of such matters they would feel protected to carry out their travesties. What the actual f* indeed.
- londons_explore 8y agoThe rapist isn't guaranteed not to be prosecuted if the victim doesn't hand over data. But you're right that a rapist careful not to leave behind too much other evidence is likely protected.
- zhangeru 8y agoNot only that, but a rapist could use the threat of police investigation for something like recreational drug use to scare a victim into never going to the police in the first place.
- FerretFred 8y ago> an institution that is supposed to protect people under its jurisdiction Sadly, that was a long time ago. Now they're a massively-under-resourced, under-manned "service" (they used to be the Police Force). From many UK citizens' experience, all we can hope for as victims of crime is to record the crime, get a crime number and wait for something to happen. Very sad, and increasingly dangerous...
- philpem 8y agoI don't know why this has been downvoted, anyone who's had any contact with the UK police knows it's absolutely true. I was attacked and injured a few years ago, in an area with really good CCTV. The police spent six weeks claiming to be "picking up the evidence soon", all the while I have the CCTV operator calling me every fortnight asking when the police are going to pick up the tape. They never did. A few weeks later, the guy who attacked me turned up in the press. Arrested for robbing an old lady and leaving her in hospital. Called the police back, "Oh. There's nothing we can do. It's your word against his, there's no evidence, and we've closed the case." Called the CCTV operator. They still had the tape. "I can keep it for another week before I have to destroy it." Called the police back, told them to go pick up the tape. "No. The case is closed." All they had to do was tell a passing car to drop in with an evidence bag and even that was too much work for them. And this was long before the police cuts. It's only got worse since.
- jpovenden 8y agoYou are absolutely correct, cuts is just their goto excuse this time around.