3 ms·
The author makes several mistakes: 1. "I still read and read and listen and listen. And I have never found a more compelling story of our origins than the ones
by bediger4000 8y ago
The author makes several mistakes:
1. "I still read and read and listen and listen. And I have never found a more compelling story of our origins than the ones that involve God." This is an esthetic judgement, and is therefore beyond criticism. But it doesn't hold for everyone. You find creationism beautiful? Great. Teach it in an art elective.
2. " I guess I don’t “believe” that the world was created in a few days, but what do I know? Seems as plausible (to me) as theoretical astrophysics..." The author doesn't particularly understand a theory, therefore the author throws out the theory. I believe this is the famed "Argument from Ignorance". Please, please, please don't push your ignorance on me.
3. The author spends two paragraphs describing how science, after collecting more evidence, changes conclusions. Shocking, I know, that when you gain knowledge, your conclusions change. Creationism doesn't change, and can't change, and so eliminates the author's confusion. A fancier, longer way of saying "God did it, so I don't have to think". That's fine. I would be embarassed to admit in public that further evidence can't change my mind.
These kinds of articles about rejecting up-to-date conclusions in favor of some kind of homespun ignorance annoy me to no end. The subtext is that everyone should go on believing what they were taught as children by authorities. I suppose that's whay corporations like Yahoo run them: Yahoo is in the business of being an authority that tells you what to believe. If your belief changes with further evidence, Yahoo just might be out of a job.