5 ms·

Ask HN: Has anyone successfully relied on advertising for revenue?

7 points by _davebennett 7y ago

It seems like advertising might be the worst business model to have in 2019. Any success stories?

sgillen 7y ago
Maybe I’m confused by your question. I believe Google and Facebook rely on ads for most of their revenue.
- avichalp 7y ago
  I believe OP is talking about relying on ad for monetizing your content.
return1 7y ago
From my experience, eCPMs have not gone down in the past 10 years, at least for adsense . Which means that ads are not a worse monetization than it was in the past if that's what you are asking.
sharmi 7y ago
If you do not get approved by adsense, it is not an viable option. I have a site with views in the millions, but no adsense. Adding any other ad delivery service creates a lot of spam and makes the website yuck. And the payout is orders of magnitude less than adsense. So i have just foregone ads and host on my own cost. Getting into Adsense is becoming difficult and there are lots of horror stories of them randomly suspending accounts without payouts.
- mkbkn 7y ago
  Have you tried venturing into affiliate marketing?
  - sharmi 7y ago
    Unfortunately, my site is more like a dictionary and it does not lend itself much to affiliate marketing.
- elamje 7y ago
  What about Ads via Carbon? They are simple and elegant ads, albeit the target is basically tech people.
stevesearer 7y ago
Office Snapshots (https://officesnapshots.com https://officesnapshots.com) here. We switched away from ad networks ~5 years ago in favor of selling and hosting our own ads which are static jpg/pngs. Our ads are matched against the content (office furniture ads on office design content) which still targets the reader in a roundabout way in that they will likely be interested in the ads if they are interested in the content. There are several benefits including faster site, keeping 100% of the revenue, and getting to control the quality of ads to ensure a great experience for our readers. We have also been removing 3rd party scripts (share buttons, etc) over the last year or so and only have Google Analytics and a Google Font left. The site still works if you block them.

7 points by _davebennett 7y ago

It seems like advertising might be the worst business model to have in 2019. Any success stories?

sgillen 7y ago

Maybe I’m confused by your question. I believe Google and Facebook rely on ads for most of their revenue.

avichalp 7y ago
I believe OP is talking about relying on ad for monetizing your content.

return1 7y ago

From my experience, eCPMs have not gone down in the past 10 years, at least for adsense . Which means that ads are not a worse monetization than it was in the past if that's what you are asking.

sharmi 7y ago

If you do not get approved by adsense, it is not an viable option. I have a site with views in the millions, but no adsense. Adding any other ad delivery service creates a lot of spam and makes the website yuck. And the payout is orders of magnitude less than adsense. So i have just foregone ads and host on my own cost. Getting into Adsense is becoming difficult and there are lots of horror stories of them randomly suspending accounts without payouts.

mkbkn 7y ago
Have you tried venturing into affiliate marketing?
- sharmi 7y ago
  Unfortunately, my site is more like a dictionary and it does not lend itself much to affiliate marketing.
elamje 7y ago
What about Ads via Carbon? They are simple and elegant ads, albeit the target is basically tech people.

stevesearer 7y ago

Office Snapshots (https://officesnapshots.com https://officesnapshots.com) here. We switched away from ad networks ~5 years ago in favor of selling and hosting our own ads which are static jpg/pngs. Our ads are matched against the content (office furniture ads on office design content) which still targets the reader in a roundabout way in that they will likely be interested in the ads if they are interested in the content. There are several benefits including faster site, keeping 100% of the revenue, and getting to control the quality of ads to ensure a great experience for our readers. We have also been removing 3rd party scripts (share buttons, etc) over the last year or so and only have Google Analytics and a Google Font left. The site still works if you block them.