4 ms·
"Chinese influence, how politically corrupt they are, and the excessive violence and human rights violations exercised against minorities." I know your heart i
by BLKNSLVR 8y ago
"Chinese influence, how politically corrupt they are, and the excessive violence and human rights violations exercised against minorities."
I know your heart is in the right place, but you could replace China with "The US" or "Russia" or "North Korea" or "colonial Britain" or almost any other country and it would be true. Those who wouldn't be worthy of the list are those who've never had the resources or opportunity to make the list.
It's sad, but I believe it's pretty close to the truth.
In relation to China, "The West" gifted it the power it now wields by outsourcing manufacturing there because cheap labor meant much higher percentage profits for all the savvy business owners who didn't want to pay local rates. And didn't they do well over the last 40-odd years! Can't deny it being smart business back then. Also can't deny that China's current world power status wasn't predictable 40-odd years ago if businesses everywhere decided to follow suit. And they did, and here we are, and all the countries that host companies that contributed to this are now having a cry about the actions of the monster they profited from creating.
- threeseed 8y agoChina has millions of Uighur Muslims, journalists, dissidents etc in detention centres in the Western Xinjiang region. Some of whom were even fellow Australian citizens kidnapped that are still missing. China has a surveillance network and social credit system that is unparalleled by anything in the entire history of this planet. China is right now a Xi dictatorship that has no independent judiciary, no free press, no independent companies, censored internet and the most sophisticated and efficient crackdown mechanisms known to man. And you actually think that the US or Britain is equivalent ? Ridiculous.
- freeflight 8y agoMaybe your memory of history is very short, but the US pretty much championed a lot of the things you rail against China for in their "war on terror". Torture camps and abducting people into them included, just like Internet-censorship (to prevent the spread of "terrorist propaganda") and pretty much the biggest and most sophisticated global surveillance system in human history, facilitated through the FiveEyes cooperation. A lot of the things China does on a domestic basis, the US has been doing for decades on a global basis. The absurd thing about this all being: They all use the same reasoning to sell this authoritarian creep to the population, the "fight against terrorism". And people gobble it up like it's the most normal thing ever, regardless of them being Chinese, US American or British.
- tomp 8y agoAll that is true. Howver. Given the choice, I would much prefer to live in the US (or US-dominated/sponsored West) than in China, Russia, Middle East etc. US has better economic, legal and political systems. It doesn't discriminate against foreigners or religions, allows foreigner people and companies to compete in the markets and make enormous amounts of money, it has one of the most transparent and stable political systems in the world (which allows immigrants to participate in partially, and 2nd generation immigrants completely). Sure, the US is not perfect, but that's why I support the US and am in favor of boycotting China (and other less-free countries).
- BLKNSLVR 8y agoYour view of the US seems a bit filtered through rose-coloured glasses, but I agree with your fundamental point: If it came down to choosing sides, I wouldn't be defecting to China or Russia. But I won't, ever, outsource my critical thinking.
- civilitty 8y ago> And they did, and here we are, and all the countries that host companies that contributed to this are now having a cry about the actions of the monster they profited from creating. But did they really profit? Let's assume for a second that the media isn't one monolithic entity governed by suits in a smokey board room but by many competing entities with opposing and dynamic economic incentives, like the public's fatigue and need for novelty. Let's assume that these changing media narratives are purely a result of inter/intra-generational variance in upbringing and other effectively random factors (accumulation of wealth and social mobility among them). Has the general public truly profited from the movement of manufacturing over seas? I don't mean intangible improvements like higher resolution televisions and thinner smartphones and cheaper everything - just because they can be measured in SI units or dollars doesn't mean that they tangibly improve someone's life. I mean by the cold hard numbers. Is the average middle class family healthier than they were before? Are they spending less money to stay healthy? Are they more secure in their finances? Can they take longer vacations? Can they afford to send their kids to college without them having to balance study and worm time? Are they happier?
- BLKNSLVR 8y agoI intended my point to be that the individuals at the top profited (those making the decisions to take advantage of cheap overseas labor) in terms of money / wealth. No, happiness has not increased (maybe fairly-floss happiness has increased, that short term heavy-crash happiness that people get from new/shiny things - but I don't count that towards general societal happiness). Fear and paranoia has increased. (my opinion).
- jhanschoo 8y ago> you could replace China with "The US" or "Russia" or "North Korea" or "colonial Britain" or almost any other country and it would be true. Those who wouldn't be worthy of the list are those who've never had the resources or opportunity to make the list. Many Western countries have a checkered past, but it's not exactly as though present citizens of the West were directly involved in the atrocities committed in the past by the West. Every sufficiently long lived state has had its dishonorable days, but it's not like we can't criticize both the past and current behavior of these nations and the /current/ behavior of China. On the other hand, it is to the current Western climate's benefit that many dare make such criticism openly on the record and without fear of persecution (e.g. Gitmo). The same cannot be said of China. > And didn't they do well over the last 40-odd years! While your paragraph has the tone that the West is simply getting its just desserts, I find it unwarranted. This criticism, at its best, is criticism of past bad realpolitik policy by the West. People like the parent comment are only just learning of how woeful it is that Chinese influence is spreading, when Chinese influence is that unjust. It is useful to know that the West may have fed the beast. But the parent comment you are replying to was likely ignorant of the situation then and likely had no decision-making power then anyway. Thus adopting such a tone is in quite bad taste, since the parent comment is likely a victim of someone else's poor decisions and not their own.
- BLKNSLVR 8y ago"the tone that the West is simply getting its just desserts" That wasn't my intention, although it can easily be read like that. My intention is for the potentially "ignorant of some history" parent-poster to be provided with some context around the current situation, ie. it does not exist in a vacuum, and has been strongly influenced by the actions and policies of the leadership of non-Chinese countries and companies. The citizens of all countries are the victims in this. The significant majority (99+%) of the world population are caught in situations created or influenced by a very small minority of people (some of which were democratically voted for, but then that turns into a much more complex debate). I intentionally started my comment with "I know your heart is in the right place" to make it (hopefully) clear that I wasn't directing any accusations toward the parent poster.