3 ms·
I thought there was something odd about the article, then I found the explanation: "I'm Just A Recruiter With An Opinion" Sorry, in my experience the opinions
by arethuza 16y ago
I thought there was something odd about the article, then I found the explanation:
"I'm Just A Recruiter With An Opinion"
Sorry, in my experience the opinions of recruiters on anything like choice of programming languages is probably worse than useless.
- cookiecaper 16y agoI was going to mention this too. The blog is "Captain Recruiter". Seems recruiters and HR might be better off sticking to discussion about insurance paperwork. Really bad advice in the article here. There might be a few cases where the prevalence of a language/availability of help (assuming the language is non-proprietary and has more than a handful of users) might matter significantly (almost always to cater to the demands of individuals misinformed in a manner similar to the author of this article), but for a software project that you intend on maintaining, you should definitely pick a language on its technical and communal merits, and not the skills listed on LinkedIn.
- edanm 16y agoSo why not talk about what he's wrong about, instead of writing ad hominem attacks on him?
- cookiecaper 16y agoDoes everyone have to provide a unique in-depth analysis of the subject before they can make a comment? Maybe the rest of the thread adequately illustrates why advice from a recruiter is not necessarily credible and this comment is just made to tip people off before they get to the bottom of the article. I think that the guy can throw in an off-hand remark without having to provide boons of evidence. I don't see a problem with pointing out that this guy speaks from the outside looking in.
- arethuza 16y agoLargely because it regards developers as a commodity that can be summarized with a few keywords - which is something I have always hated. Incidentally, I did co-found a start-up in '94 where we chose Java as the platform because we wanted to to do shrink-wrapped server side applications. Java was probably a lot less popular then than Scala is now and that choice turned out to be a huge advantage for us technically. I don't think any of first round of developers we hired had any real Java experience - it really wasn't a problem.
- sgift 16y agoWhile ad hominem attacks are never good, I don't think this is an ad hominem, but rather an argument based on knowledge/professionalism: A recruiters opinion on programming languages is like the opinion of my baker on medicine: It's nice to hear it, but I don't need a long discussion to decide on their usefulness.