5 ms·
The bar chart in that article, where the y axis apparently starts at 14% and change - it's really hard to think of journalists as sources of truth when they use
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
The bar chart in that article, where the y axis apparently starts at 14% and change - it's really hard to think of journalists as sources of truth when they use such blatantly deceptive graphics.
- ilikehurdles 8y agoMaybe I'm an outlier, but I don't find properly labeled charts deceptive at all. There is no hard rule that all charts must have an axis at zero, and charts that fit this template are not necessarily more valuable or informative than those that don't.
- dymk 8y ago> There is no hard rule that all charts must have an axis at zero Starting at something other than zero is like, the #1 thing that cable news channels do to make charts flashed on the screen for a few seconds look exaggerated. And for a chart like the one shown in the article, there's no reason to not start at 0 unless you're trying to exaggerate the differences in values.
- mochomocha 8y ago... Or show the difference more clearly. It's about visual dynamic range. Nothing wrong with it. Maybe the problem is people assuming that every x and y axes always start at 0.
- endless1234 8y agoWhy should it start at specifically zero though? Growth can be, and often is, negative. Shouldn't it start at -50 to be sure? The point of the chart is exactly to show ("exaggerate") the difference in values!
- govg 8y ago0 is merely a convenient numerical value that also has business meaning - no growth. You can then contrast any numerical value with this, 10% meaning it grew by a fraction of .1, and so on. For most percentage quantities, it usually makes sense to start at 0 if that has some business meaning.
- ilikehurdles 8y ago0.1% has business meaning, as does -1000%, for what it's worth.
- inflatableDodo 8y ago>Starting at something other than zero is like, the #1 thing that cable news channels do to make charts flashed on the screen for a few seconds look exaggerated. In this case however it is not being flashed on the screen for a few seconds, so we have plenty of time to read it and notice the axis labels, then argue in the comments that the label that we read is deceptive because people might not read it. Also, if labelling the y axis on this graph as something other than zero is deceptive, should the x axis start at the beginning of time?
- ilikehurdles 8y agoCable news channels have a problem of not labeling their axes at all, or having proportions that don't match the labels that are there. Like pie charts that show <40% as being roughly half. And then not providing enough time for viewers to fully understand the data.
- ehsankia 8y ago> There is no hard rule that all charts must have an axis at zero Of course, but the charts are a vehicle to show casing data, and this specific one intentionally misleads viewers. I'm not sure if it was due to ill-intention or ignorance, but charts like that go against everything charts are for in the first place.
- xster 8y agoI'm just here waiting for them to finish writing the supermicro chip story.
- opportune 8y agoAlso, 14% YOY growth is still a great exponential growth rate for a maturing market
- reaperducer 8y agoReporters don't make the charts. It's the Wall Street Journal, not a blog. There's and entire art department for that sort of thing. Also, charts like that are very common in financial publications. The target audience knows how to read them. Edit: The original link was WSJ. It's since been changed to Bloomberg, presumably because of the Journal's paywall, but the point still stands.
- what_ever 8y agoSo you are saying reporters don't have any say in what images appear as part of their reports? Also, this arts department you talk of - is still part of the reputed publication? Or does arts mean they don't follow the basic paradigms?
- reaperducer 8y agoSo you are saying reporters don't have any say in what images appear as part of their reports? I'm not saying "any" say, but in my experience working for two major newspaper companies, it's not a given. There are other people who decide that. Again, it's not a blog.
- aikinai 8y agoSo we should have lower standards for “major newspaper companies” as opposed to blogs?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- product50 8y agoIt doesn't matter who does it. What matters is as the end user reading that article this is pretty misleading. So from that standpoint, the journalist writing the article is implicated by default since he/she literally writes their name on the article. And frankly they should feel responsible for it.
- massivecali 8y ago
- AznHisoka 8y agoThat chart is grossly misleading for a lot of reasons: - As you mentioned, axis starts at 14%. - The units is percentage change rather than actual revenue. - This is year over year percentage change! Which means it makes no sense having the x-axis be sequential quarters.
- crazygringo 8y agoSorry, but you (and parent) seem to be misinformed on all counts. This chart is both entirely normal and makes complete sense for anyone with a financial background, as can rightly be assumed for a Bloomberg or WSJ reader. - Financial charts commonly don't start at 0%, e.g. look at any stock chart ever. No one ever assumes it does. This is to maximize clarity of differences, otherwise a lot of financial charts would have very small differences on top of very long bars, which would be much harder to read - Percentage change is the correct metric when the title is "growth slows". If direct revenue were shown then readers would need to compare slopes rather than than heights, which is much harder, confusing, and less clear. (Direct revenue would be appropriate for a chart titled "revenue drops", but this story is about growth, not revenue, so that would be the wrong chart.) - YoY percentage change is a normal metric to use on a quarterly or monthly basis precisely because it removes seasonal effects, see [1]. There is nothing nonsensical about it whatsoever. This article and chart assumes a reader who is financially literate. It is not deceptive in any way, but rather follows best practices. [1] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/y/year-over-year.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/y/year-over-year.asp
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoDespite the dripping holier-than-thou tone of your post, I believe it is you who are misinformed: > Financial charts commonly don't start at 0%, e.g. look at any stock chart ever. Which is why those types of charts usually are line charts, or candlestick charts. The only reason to do a chart like this as a bar chart is to deliberately overemphasize the size of the difference between the quarters. A bar chart with a non-zero baseline is a horrible way to display this kind of data. > This is to maximize clarity of differences, otherwise a lot of financial charts would have very small differences on top of very long bars, which would be much harder to read Well, using a chart with a zeroed axis seems to work just fine for the very next chart in the article.