3 ms·
It also needs to be rad-hard for space. Terrestrial FPGAs are subject to occasional "SEU" (single event upsets)[1] which can arbitrarily affect behavior becaus
by loeg 8y ago
It also needs to be rad-hard for space. Terrestrial FPGAs are subject to occasional "SEU" (single event upsets)[1] which can arbitrarily affect behavior because gates can flip. Robust terrestrial FPGA systems have to handle SEUs; you have to imagine that these events are more frequent in space and need to at least be handled.
(This may something you already had in mind, summarized as "high-end FPGAs;" I just wanted to add some interesting color some folks might not be aware of.)
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_event_upset https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_event_upset
- mises 8y agoGood to know, thanks. I suppose at the scale of SpaceX, ASICs may be an option.
- loeg 8y agoI'm not sure 4000 is enough to break even on ASICs, but I'll admit I don't know much about the costs of either high end FPGAs nor ASIC production at quantity 4000.
- mises 8y agoFrom what I am reading here, a large part of the cost is up-front with chip design and setup. I suppose it depends on pricing. They also may wish to sell more after those four thousand units. http://blog.zorinaq.com/asic-development-costs-are-lower-than-you-think/ http://blog.zorinaq.com/asic-development-costs-are-lower-tha...
- azernik 8y agoGround station cost is actually more of a concern than satellite cost, from market analysis I've heard. Going to need more of them.
- fyfy18 8y agoIn LEO it doesn't need to be rad hardended, especially for something that isn't life critical (compared to say, the control system of a space shuttle). At this altitude, the atmosphere and magnetic field provides a lot of protection still. At the very least SpaceX would test the devices to see what effects the higher radiation would have. However it's not unreasonable to just have the software detect and reset itself, if a high energy event is detected. There are going to be a lot of these satellites and a lot of redundancy in coverage, so if one is down for a few minutes it's not that big of a deal.
- loeg 8y agoYes, as long as radiation only causes upsets and not permanent failures — satellites are somewhat expensive — and as long as software can detect faults and reset.
- wongarsu 8y ago4000 satellites is enough to hit economies of scale. Per piece they are probably among the cheapest satellites in orbit.
- loeg 8y agoSure, but that isn't saying an awful lot; most satellites are very expensive. SpaceX would want to weigh the cost of hardening the system against radiation versus the cost of another launch to replace failure(s). I'd guess radiation-hardening of some kind (at least sufficient to prevent most permanent damage) would win out in that calculation, but I'll happily admit I don't have any particular factual basis for that guess.