5 ms·
What? You get to imagine some bad argument that would make it most convenient for you, and then demand that I defend that argument, as if it were one that I wa
by colbyrussell 7y ago
What? You get to imagine some bad argument that would make it most convenient for you, and then demand that I defend that argument, as if it were one that I wanted to make? This is what I'm responsible for? Dealing with someone who resorts to strawmanning the person/idea at the other end when challenged?
- diminoten 7y agoI'm not imagining it, and that's the problem you're running into. It's a consequence of what you said.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dllthomas 7y agoIt's not a direct consequence of anything that was said. It's a possible implication - in the conversational sense of implication, not the logical sense - but those get to be disclaimed.
- diminoten 7y agoHis stance is literally that using a GUI is harder. That isn't a consequence, it's his core position.
- colbyrussell 7y agoIt's literally not my stance. And I've literally said that it's not my stance—in a comment (that should have never been necessary to begin with) meant to remove all doubt. And you know this. To continue saying otherwise (explicitly, even) is a case of outright intellectual dishonesty.
- diminoten 7y agoIt's you backing off of a claim you clearly now know is nonsense once someone challenged you on it.
- colbyrussell 7y agoMy phone number is listed on my home page. Please give me a call.
- diminoten 7y agoWhy on God's green earth would I ever give you a call???
- dllthomas 7y agoFWIW, I certainly didn't read his comment that way, and in light of his explicit denial that that's what he intended maybe you should reconsider whether there are alternate interpretations available.
- diminoten 7y agoAre you reading some of the other comment threads he's participating in? It seems like he's taking this whole thing very personally, and it's hard to pin down exactly what he's trying to say when he won't calm down. He wants me to call him, as if escalating this will be worth it... He didn't even answer your very reasonable question above. Don't you wonder why that is?
- dllthomas 7y ago> Are you reading some of the other comment threads he's participating in? It seems like he's taking this whole thing very personally, and it's hard to pin down exactly what he's trying to say when he won't calm down. Feeling misinterpreted can be very personal. That said, in both my initial reading and my re-reading you come off worse than he does. > He wants me to call him, as if escalating this will be worth it... Sometimes text-conversation-on-the-internet escalates when neither party intends it, and switching to other modalities can be valuable. That said, it's not at all clear to me that it's a good idea here compared to dropping it. > He didn't even answer your very reasonable question above. Don't you wonder why that is? I presume it's because it got lost in the noise.