2 ms·
>where the union itself is both independent of the employer but also has a significant power in promotion decisions I would really hate to deal with a second l
by duxup 8y ago
>where the union itself is both independent of the employer but also has a significant power in promotion decisions
I would really hate to deal with a second level of bureaucracy when it comes to promotions and such.... let alone employer's having to accept "this guy is a senior X now" and realize he is not as opposed someone else who wasn't given that chance. That still seems like a very track type of career path situation where the technology world is still fast changing and has huge amounts of variety.
- CharlesColeman 8y ago> I would really hate to deal with a second level of bureaucracy when it comes to promotions and such.... I was imagining it more as peer-accreditation and peer-participation, as the other union members would be your peers. Basically more democracy rather than bureaucracy.
- joshuamorton 8y agoSure, but in many ways Google's promo process is already this way. Its not perfect, but at least IME, my promotion/performance evaluation has been based significantly on feedback from my peers.
- CharlesColeman 8y ago> my promotion/performance evaluation has been based significantly on feedback from my peers "Based significantly on" is not the same as "made by" or "made in collaboration with." The problem here is an employer using their discretion as a hidden means of retaliation, and they can still do that with all the feedback in the world as long as the discretion is still all theirs.
- joshuamorton 8y agoRemoving employer discretion is not a solvable problem.
- CharlesColeman 8y agoI didn't say remove, I said spread it around so it's harder to use improperly.