4 ms·
One of the main factors behind the rise of capitalism and the ensuing era of industrialism and 30-fold increase of prosperity of ordinary people was breaking th
by BurningFrog 8y ago
One of the main factors behind the rise of capitalism and the ensuing era of industrialism and 30-fold increase of prosperity of ordinary people was breaking the suffocating power of the guilds.
"Free enterprise" was originally a call to revolt against the guilds.
- jetrink 8y agoIt's funny that the NYT headline is "As Rents Rise, Artists Are Reviving the Idea of the Medieval Guild," as one of the primary functions of the medieval guild was rent-seeking. The closest modern equivalent of the guild is probably the illegal cartel. The term has a lot of baggage and I would not like to associate myself with it.
- gridlockd 8y agoNo, the closest equivalent are certain unions. Wherever they get away with it, they limit supply of labor, they fix wages and they enact licensure.
- FranzFerdiNaN 8y agoGuilds at least paid taxes and provided not only for members and their families but also for the poor. Can’t say the same of capitalist firms.
- gridlockd 8y agoWhat a bargain, I keep you poor by locking you out of my occupation, then I'll give you bit of charity so that you must thank me for it as well.
- FranzFerdiNaN 8y agoWhat a bargain, I keep you poor by exploiting not only your labor but your country (and if you dare not be capitalistic I will invade you and install a dictatorship) but hey, a billionaire will create a philanthropic organization to help him dodge taxes so thank you capitalism!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gridlockd 8y agoSo, if only those poor exploited countries had a system of guilds that kept poor people from getting compensated for labor by for-profit enterprise, then... then what? Can you actually explain your theory there?
- harimau777 8y agoI think that the idea may be that guilds had a social/religious obligation to provide for the poor and generally be a positive force in the community. In addition, guilds were localized enough that social forces could keep them accountable to the community. On the other hand, America has adopted the belief that large corporations are only obligated to maximize profit for their shareholders and they are too large and decentralized for social forces to effectively hold them accountable.
- gridlockd 8y ago> I think that the idea may be that guilds had a social/religious obligation to provide for the poor and generally be a positive force in the community. How could a group of people who monopolize on a trade "generally be a positive force in the community"? Just because they "provide for the poor" (on their terms)? > On the other hand, America has adopted the belief that large corporations are only obligated to maximize profit for their shareholders and they are too large and decentralized for social forces to effectively hold them accountable. Those corporations are also obligated to actually pay their employees, who are obligated to pay taxes. What does the state do with all that income? Fund welfare programs and infrastructure. People may believe the those corporations get "all the money", but on the average corporate profits[1] account for far less money than public spending[2]. [1] https://b-i.forbesimg.com/timworstall/files/2013/05/cp_gdp.png https://b-i.forbesimg.com/timworstall/files/2013/05/cp_gdp.p... [2] https://thumbor.forbes.com/thumbor/960x0/https%3A%2F%2Fblogs-images.forbes.com%2Ftimworstall%2Ffiles%2F2015%2F10%2Fsocialwelfare.jpg https://thumbor.forbes.com/thumbor/960x0/https%3A%2F%2Fblogs... Those who have paid attention to history understand that there's a fine balance here. Too much taxation and the economy collapses, making everyone poor. Too little taxation and the infrastructure and social system suffers unnecessarily. Those who understand nothing keep complaining about corporate paper profits and wealth inequality, as if those were the measure for actual welfare.
- vkou 8y ago> 30-fold increase of prosperity of ordinary people And here I thought the 30-fold increase of prosperity of ordinary people came about because we now have ubiquitous access to what, in pre-industrial times, was considered unlimited amounts of energy. Stop producing electricity, stop burning coal, stop pumping oil, and you'll very quickly see prosperity regress to pre-industrial levels, regardless of what economic deity you worship.
- spectaclepiece 8y agoWe can get by without coal (and oil once most cars run on electricity) as long as we embrace nuclear.
- vkou 8y agoI'm not making a claim about our environmental future, I'm making a claim about where our present prosperity comes from. People frequently credit our economic system for uplifting us from pre-industrial squalor. It's like a young millionaire praising a daily exercise regiment, and hot yoga three times a week for his success, and not the fifty million dollar trust fund he inherited at the age of 18. It helps, but it's not the important part.
- spectaclepiece 8y agoAgree with your argument, it was unnecessary to nitpick your choice of examples.
- BurningFrog 8y agoThere is a lot to that of course, but the technology to exploit those energy sources were developed in the era of dawning free enterprise, right in the few countries that led the movement. Not at any other time through thousands of years of civilization or five large continents.
- vkou 8y agoThose countries were in the middle of reaping the economic windfall of a century of colonial theft and exploitation, combined with relative internal stability, all in the context of advancements in metallurgy that took millennia to develop (All the while having large coal reserves... And a shortage of wood, because they've just finished clear-cutting their forests.) For some reason, the industrial revolution did not develop in any other societies over the centuries that shared a similar system of free enterprise with imperial England... Why didn't the various Italian city states industrialize during the Renaissance?