3 ms·
Yep. Everyone and their dog can understand the long-term insidious effects of Walmart using its clout to force suppliers to accept the bare minimum to keep oper
by SilasX 8y ago
Yep. Everyone and their dog can understand the long-term insidious effects of Walmart using its clout to force suppliers to accept the bare minimum to keep operating. Change the topic to governments and pharmaceuticals, and suddenly the practice is harmless and has zero downsides we should care about.
- cptskippy 8y agoNo one said it was harmless but Pharmaceuticals companies are making obscene amounts of money by charging outrageous prices. You're arguing that there's no middle ground and we must either have exploitative drug companies putting profits over people's well beings or an oppressive government putting people's needs over the business's long term viability.
- SilasX 8y ago>No one said it was harmless Virtually every such exposition of the argument says exactly that.
- ptah 8y agoin the case of drug prices it is actually beneficial
- hackeraccount 8y agoWhy limit the practice to pharmaceuticals? In theory the government can be a middle man for any good or service. Why not have the government buy all the cars in country and the parcel them out to people at a fair rate? I think everyone (or most everyone) understands that would be a disaster. Switch the good to pharmaceuticals and suddenly it's reasonable?
- cptskippy 8y agoWhat's the alternative? Keep the status quo?
- ptah 8y agoit is completely different situation. you should use the right tool for the job, not the same for every job
- rayiner 8y agoExercise of monopoly or monopsony power to drive prices away from the efficient level is an economic concept that applies to pretty much every situation where things are bought and sold.
- ptah 8y agothat is a very narrow view of it. monopsony is pretty much the way things are done for drug pricing in every first world country except the US for over 50 years
- rayiner 8y agoOther countries can do it because the U.S. doesn't do it: https://thehill.com/opinion/healthcare/369727-us-drug-prices-higher-than-in-the-rest-of-the-world-heres-why https://thehill.com/opinion/healthcare/369727-us-drug-prices... > Although this question is difficult to answer, several studies suggest that the benefit of lower prices today is offset by the forgone value created by drugs that never reach the market. According to one estimate, if the U.S. were to adopt European-level price controls, the reductions in U.S. prices today would result in 0.7 years lower longevity for future cohorts of Americans and Europeans due to fewer new drugs. This would cost Americans more than $50,000 per person when the value of foregone health is valued. (Author is a professor at Harvard Medical School.)
- munk-a 8y agoUS Pharmaceutical companies have a very high profit margin and spend a significant amount of money on advertising - in addition their research is subsidized or outright paid for by the US government, many of the drugs they produce they have had to invest nothing for research of - including that cash cow insulin. (Commentor works MedTech adjacent)