4 ms·
not sure why the community would see that as a problem If someone is learning martial arts, you might see that as a demanding sport, for tough serious athletes
by michaelt 8y ago
not sure why the community would see that as a problem
If someone is learning martial arts, you might see that as a demanding sport, for tough serious athletes, demanding discipline, hard work and self-control.
Or you might see it as playing at being Bruce Lee. Hiiii-Ya!
Needless to say, the former perspective implies more respect for the people doing it!
But there's not a bright line between 'serious' activities and non-serious ones - and hence, not much a sport can do to choose where on the spectrum they lie.
- close04 8y agoIt depends on the level of skill required to master the sport and the level at which you're performing. Some sports take a lot more skill than others and mastering those demands more respect. And it can be that you're just playing Bruce Lee by throwing your arms and legs all over the place.
- wemdyjreichert 8y agoI'd say there's a bit of a difference between martial arts and a toy pony. I know martial artists who can break a dozen cinder bricks with an elbow; that's a serious pursuit. I'd say there is a serious difference between that and riding a toy stick. This extends to many other sports and activities: you can practice at a serious level or an amateur one. The difference here is that I see no serious level for this. Same thing with comics, which I saw some one else mention earlier. I guess if the kids are having fun, fine. This does seem incredibly weird, but I guess it's between them and their parents. However, I don't understand this demand to be taken seriously. It's a hobby; they do it for fun, and that's fine.
- lmm 8y ago> I know martial artists who can break a dozen cinder bricks with an elbow; that's a serious pursuit. I'd say there is a serious difference between that and riding a toy stick. What difference would that be? Real-world application? No-one hires martial artists for demolition work. They're both recreational activities. Doing them well is difficult enough that your ability can be (and is) assessed competitively. Seems much the same to me (at least, if the competition results are consistent between judges).
- wemdyjreichert 8y agoSelf-defense. Know two other guys who have possibly had their lives (or at any rate, probably hospital visits) saved in street fights and muggings. There are also countless juniors who have been able to fend off bullies. It's also exercise, which has extensive and proven benefits. It also has huge benefits in terms of bone strength and density. So yes, I would say real-world application. Is it recreational in some way? Sure. But again, it has real benefits, while I don't see any in riding a toy stick (aside from enjoyment gained).
- lmm 8y ago> Self-defense. Know two other guys who have possibly had their lives (or at any rate, probably hospital visits) saved in street fights and muggings. There are also countless juniors who have been able to fend off bullies. Some martial arts have some application to self-defense, but I don't think that's the real distinction - people don't seem to treat e.g. Naginata as a less serious martial art even though you'd never use it in practice. And many non-martial-art sports (I mentioned cycling in a parallel thread) are treated with the same seriousness. > It's also exercise, which has extensive and proven benefits. It also has huge benefits in terms of bone strength and density. Aren't those equally true of this hobbyhorse-dressage?
- wemdyjreichert 8y ago> Some martial arts have some application to self-defense, but I don't think that's the real distinction Many of the martial artists whom I know began training for purposes of self-defense. Some began as adults, and some were placed in training by their parents after being bullied. > cycling That's totally out of the scope of this conversation; I made no claims as to the seriousness with which cycling ought to be treated. I think most sports are given too much credence. >> It's also exercise > Aren't those equally true of this hobbyhorse-dressage? No, not from the gif of a "competition" at the top of the article. It does not appear to contain any serious exertion. Most sports involve pushing yourself physically. This does not involve such exertion and improvement. If kids want to do it, that's fine (all though still weird as all getout). But I don't think them saying to not "say they are playing" because it "strips away what we've made" is really reasonable. Kids are playing dress-up; it's fine to remind them it's just dress-up. And it's ridiculous to compare it to real sports.
- whenchamenia 8y agoAs someone who has dabbled in martial arts, breaking blocks is not done by anyone serious. Thoae are all barely above stage clowing to anyone into the art. No offense to your friends, feeling powerful is valid too.
- wemdyjreichert 8y agoI'm not sure in which martial arts you dabbled or on which circuits; could you clarify there? Different martial arts are very different in on what they focus. Some don't really spar, some do. That doesn't make them better or worse, that means they are different styles with different foci.
- ummonk 8y agoOn the other hand there is aikido, which is basically playing at make believe martial art.