3 ms·
As a long time (10+ years) Linux and macOS user, I accept most of the things you say, and macOS is an extremely time efficient platform to do work. However, th
by bayindirh 8y ago
As a long time (10+ years) Linux and macOS user, I accept most of the things you say, and macOS is an extremely time efficient platform to do work.
However, the lack of unifying vision is not an Achilles heel of the open source community. It's the essence of it. I like how any two installations of two distributions are never the same, and this broad ecosystem just works, tumbles, fights and creates new stuff.
I've created a compression algorithm [0] for my graduation project. It was a novel approach, but performed worse due to some technical reasons. One of my professors asked why I didn't compare it to a similar algorithm instead of plain old Zip. I said that our algorithm is never tried before, and it's pretty novel, so we had no equal to compare.
Then, one of my other professors replied to other professor asking the question. "There's no need to find an equal to compare. They did something new and untried. This is research".
Equally, Darling doesn't need to surpass macOS to be useful, because "this is research" too. Maybe they will learn something useful from this endeavor and incorporate it into Linux or their future development career.
This Katamari Damacy nature of GNU, Linux and free software community makes it so powerful and unique. Let Microsoft, Apple and Google have a top-down approach and others play as they feel and everyone improves the world as they wish.
[0]: https://www.academia.edu/20575315/Lossless_Text_Compression_Technique_Using_Syllable_Based_Morphology https://www.academia.edu/20575315/Lossless_Text_Compression_...
- sjwright 8y agoI don't disagree with anything you've said, and I don't think that my post—if read in full—disagrees with it either. The lack of unifying vision in open source can be both an Achilles heel and its most valuable asset. The lack of a community-led ethos in macOS can be be both its Achilles heel and its most valuable asset.
- bayindirh 8y agoHonestly, I missed your last footnote only. Possibly I got distracted by something. My fault. When read in full, we're on the same page. OTOH, I also didn't disagree with you on anything it seems. So, the two comments can be nicely summed up as a look to same lawn from a opposing vantage points, since I use Linux more often than macOS (albeit I have a MacBook Pro that I use pretty regularly). If my tone sounds a bit harsh, sorry for that. English is not my mother tongue. Also, if you can tell me where it's rude(ish), I can work on it.