7 ms·
The main attraction of Apple products is the certainty that, no matter what you do, they cannot be made to do what you would like. The consequence is that you f
by ncmncm 8y ago
The main attraction of Apple products is the certainty that, no matter what you do, they cannot be made to do what you would like. The consequence is that you feel no urge to spend time tinkering to get there, and instead adapt yourself to what it actually does. This reclaims all the time and attention that you would have spent on tinkering.
Since what Apple products do has proven adequate for a large number of people, and you are no less adaptable than they are, you know you can adapt, too.
Having once chosen to adapt to what Apple has chosen to offer, you find it easier each time, until it becomes wholly unconscious. Each time Apple takes away something you had used, you might momentarily balk at the "upgrade", but always acquiesce in the end.
[Edit] So, the appeal of Mac emulation is very limited, because it starts out with tinkering.
- themodelplumber 8y agoI tried the adjustment to the Apple way from 2010 to 2018. By the end of it I realized that "tinkering" has an equivalent in the Apple world and it is called "upgrading." These two terms are almost synonymous in the pain which they will cause. By the end of my journey I had a firm "one major version upgrade per iOS device" rule and a desktop OS upgrade experience that was driving me crazy, because random CAD app wouldn't support the new OS, but another app wouldn't support the mainstream-old OS anymore. I won't say that tinkering is totally productive, but 1) personally my tinkering on Linux has led to technology development and I'm the type of guy who benefits from that anyway, and 2) I believe the pain you leave behind in lost productivity is at least offset by 25% instant upgrade-related stress for each Apple device in your household or sphere of personal work activity. Even just constrained to hardware, the horror stories about new Apple devices alone made me doubt my HW upgrade plans. By itself that was enough to make me wonder if I was about to throw away thousands. Unsurprisingly I felt like there were things Apple could do to make this all better, but like you said, they cannot be made to do what you like :-)
- vaylian 8y agoThanks for putting into words what I had suspected for so long. Apple is really good at identifying what the vast majority of people (aka normal users) want to do with their computer and then they optimize these workflows. But if you want to do something more exotic you are usually out of luck. Talking to Apple enthusiasts is really tough. It's almost as you are speaking a different language. Of course, in the end of the day a computer is just a tool. They are happy with what they can do with their machine and I am happy with my machine. But they have a hard time understanding why I see their system as limiting.
- yoz-y 8y agoMany Mac users come from Linux and Windows (of course there are migrations in other directions too), most developers on MacOS also use Linux daily. So I'd wager most of them understand what you mean, but disagree. Personally I like to tinker and personalise only a subset of tools I use to get things done (iTerm, tmux, vim...) and have good defaults on the rest.
- pjmlp 8y agoOthers, like myself, have done already enough tinkering during our university days and now rather focus on get stuff done.
- VvR-Ox 8y agoExactly. And you don't have to say this and sound arrogant. Our lives, especially with that high work-load we still have to cope with, don't allow us to choose many things to do when not working. If you have family with kids you loose every tiny bit of freedom to "waste your time" on tinkering and get easily annoyed when things just don't work out of the box. I like the possibility to customize everything on linux but I also hate how the linux world can't provide the standardization and clarity I am used to from OSX. How on earth is there still no terminal emulator like iTerm2 on linux????! From linux I miss the possibility to customize everything on OSX. I hate it how Apple allways tries to lock me into it's golden cage and imposes it's way of thinking on me. In 80% of times I can totally agree with the apple way but there is 20% when I could throw that MBP against the wall with full force. Ok I didn't want to start some OSX vs. Linux debate here it's just an example to show the love-hate relationship to both. It's great there is some effort put into connecting these worlds. The way our economy works is the reason we don't have the computers and OSes we really want to have and sadly only the open source world will change this.
- vaylian 8y ago> How on earth is there still no terminal emulator like iTerm2 on linux????! Genuinely curious: What does iTerm2 do better than any other terminal emulator on Linux?
- patrec 8y ago> So, the appeal of Mac emulation is very limited, because it starts out with tinkering. There are countless of utilities for tinkering with you mac setup and the best and most tinker-y terminal for any platform is a mac-only app (iterm2). It's just that macOS starts out with a far high usability level without tinkering and comes with lots of basic stuff working that no amount of tinkering will ever give you with linux (like you can actually find files on your computer, good luck doing that with linux). And of course even if your premise were true, there are plenty of reasons people would like to run macOS apps under linux: - lots of good software is mac only - automated testing with macs is a pain and expensive, doing at least some with linux boxes would be a pretty decent win.
- ncmncm 8y agoThe facts remain that (1) even Free-Software developers rarely tinker with their Macs, (2) what can be achieved by tinkering is extremely limited, and (3) vanishingly few who don't own a Mac have the slightest idea of, or interest in, what MacOS apps they might (someday) be able to run. What would the results of a successful or unsuccessful test mean? Either might be a consequence of the different environment. I have no difficulty locating files. They stay right where I put them. If storage did not keep growing it might bother me that they never fade away. All that said, a few Mac owners, and even some former owners, might have a use for emulation, and I would never begrudge it to them.
- laumars 8y ago> There are countless of utilities for tinkering with you mac setup and the best and most tinker-y terminal for any platform is a mac-only app (iterm2). It's just that macOS starts out with a far high usability level without tinkering and comes with lots of basic stuff working that no amount of tinkering will ever give you with linux I was with you right up until you made the cheap shot at Linux. That was as unnecessary as it was untrue. > (like you can actually find files on your computer, good luck doing that with linux) Linux is no harder to find files on than it is on OS X. They have the same CLI tools, they both has desktop environments that support file indexing and rapid searching (eg Spotlight). And on Linux that all gets installed by default with the desktop environment - just as it does on OS X too. So they really aren't all that different. > lots of good software is mac only I agree. But there is also lots of good software on Linux too. In all my years of running Linux and OS X the only Mac-only application I've missed on other platforms is Logic. But even there, we're talking 15 years ago and Linux has come a long, long way since in terms of the quality of DAWs available on it.
- headsoup 8y agoI disagree entirely with that. I think Apple sold people the idea that what they provide is really cool and 'just works' and that you want to be in their 'ecosystem.' It worked, people bought the allure and then just stopped looking at other solutions because Apple said they don't need to. I think your post highlights exactly that: a buy-in to the brand so strong as to not even try and look elsewhere when issues arise, just adapt and accept.
- ncmncm 8y agoSo, in the end, disagree, or agree? The head spins.
- welly 8y agoDo you really believe that? That people are so incapable of independent thought that they will subservantly obey the wishes and demands of Apple? Come on.
- welly 8y agops. I used to have an iPhone, now I have an Android phone.
- Veen 8y agoHow do you explain people like me that used desktop Linux for years but then moved to Mac? I fully understand the benefits of Linux and MacOS. I compared them and made an informed choice around the time I stopped being a student and started making my living a professional writer. I've got deadlines and word counts and I can't afford to waste time fiddling with my computer. I want to be able to turn it on, even after updates, and start working. But, I also love to tinker and automate, and MacOS gives me a full Unix environment to play with.
- pjmlp 8y agoAmiga, Atari and other 8/16 bit platforms also did just work, it wasn't Apple selling the idea. The IBM PC was the exception here, and it only grew thanks to the mistake of IBM not protecting their BIOS as they thought.
- simonh 8y agoI don't really get this, MacOS is super tinker-y. You can script multi-app work flows with Automator, set up folder actions to magically transmute files (I have one that insta-shrinks the images in PDFs for me and puts them in an output directory), cast magic spells on selected data using custom services, use the full range of Unix commands for text processing. You have Perl and Python right there. The things that are resistant to tinkering in MacOS are the UI and how you do stuff. Those are infinitely flexible in Linux, but heavily standardised on the Mac. However when it comes to getting useful stuff done, the Mac has a wealth of tinker-y toys waiting to do your bidding.
- michaelgrafl 8y agoI think you have proven your parent's point by drawing the line between useful and time wasting tinkering.
- panpanna 8y agoThese whole thread saddens me. The amount of "tinkering" I have done on my Ubuntu PC was limited to changing background and reducing icon size to fit my monitor better. I'm not going to apologise for having better performance and first class containers.
- coldtea 8y ago>The amount of "tinkering" I have done on my Ubuntu PC was limited to changing background and reducing icon size to fit my monitor better. Outliers need not apply.
- simonh 8y agoThere is certainly a fair bit of extremity measuring going on in this thread, and I'm as guilty as anybody. The fact is a default install of MacOS or any of the mainstream Lunux distros is a fine system just as it is.
- sciurus 8y ago> The things that are resistant to tinkering in MacOS are the UI But not completely resistant. For example, there are multiple tiling window managers for os x.
- Sammi 8y agoThis Apple "Upgrade" is an almost perfect example of real world Doublethink as George Orwells defined it in the novel 1984. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doublethink https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doublethink
- AriaMinaei 8y agoI also noted the Orwellian tone. We live in troubling times when the value of tinkering is lost to the tinkerers themselves.
- coldtea 8y agoTinkering was never important to real hackers. It's the script kiddie analogue to hacking.
- coldtea 8y agoNo, it's a real example on "focus on what matters" and dropping support for bike-shedding (all too popular with tinkerers). Many users are not college students discovering the world of UNIX and customization and tinker happy -- they're people that want to get something (not "how the computer works" related) done.
- pluma 8y agoConsidering how many developer-focussed apps were written for macOS first/only because of the massive adoption of macbooks by developers after the rise of iOS apps, this is an extremely narrow perspective. The appeal of Darling isn't bringing macOS to Linux, the appeal is breaking down the walls put up by shortsighted developers who decided not to bother porting the apps they developed for macOS over to a different platform because "every developer I know uses macOS". Linux users who would want something like Darling aren't aspiring to be macOS users, they are Linux users who want/need to use software written by macOS users who didn't put in the effort to port their software.
- pavlov 8y agoAs a Mac user since 2000 and through the initial pains of the OS X transition, this is on the mark. Many old Mac users were very unhappy about the upgrade from Classic to OS X. "File extensions? Non-spatial Finder? A command line? What is this bullshit, and why does it run so slowly on my top of the line 400 MHz Power Mac G4..." But eventually they adapted. At present, Apple is "boiling the frog" on turning Mac into something closer to an iPad Pro with a keyboard (Marzipan brings iOS UI style to desktop; mandatory app notarization prevents running non-approved software; etc.) Despite the grumbles, Mac users will acquiesce here as well and just get on with their work.
- Angostura 8y ago.... ish. I'm a long time Apple user from the Mac SE. The reason I switched to OSX was effectively, I was getting a Unix OS than ran MS Office and came with a really nice suite of built in programmes that 'just worked'. It was the best of both worlds. I'm a tinkerer and even today MacOS still allows me to tinker quite a lot. But there's no requirement to tinker. If I want to actually get work done, I can use it in 'It just works' mode.
- w8rbt 8y agoInsightful comment. I call this 'working on the car more than we drive it'. You see that a lot in tech. It's fine as a hobby, but not for production. You do need both as the tinkering helps us to master concepts and systems and find new, better ways which end-up becoming best practice in the stable, production systems. Just have to known when to tinker and when to not.
- turtlebits 8y agoI disagree, Apple products are popular because they just work (for most people). I was a strict Windows user for a long time, and I remember the days of reinstalling Windows every few weeks or so to get performance back. Microsoft seems to acknowledge this (but not fix!) with the feature of resetting your PC. I stopped using linux when the system completely broke after updates (on a slow connection) and spent way too much time trying to fix it. (This was last year on Ubuntu) When I was younger I'd just deal with them, but now I just use OS X.
- lupinglade 8y agoWhat a bunch of nonsense.