4 ms·
So there are three numbers: the expected expansion based on Planck measurements of a historical value based on cosmic microwave background, red shift of distant
by ncmncm 8y ago
So there are three numbers: the expected expansion based on Planck measurements of a historical value based on cosmic microwave background, red shift of distant supernovas calibrated to nearby Cepheids, and an independent value obtained from LIGO based purely on gravitational waves, which still has uncertainty that encompasses both of the others, but will sharpen in coming years.
The LIGO measurement is not subject to vagaries of electromagnetic effects that could be introducing anomalous redshift, or to possible systematic changes in supernova brightness, such as might be caused by metal concentration of stars decreasing with distance/age.
So, if we just wait, LIGO will give an answer. Possibly, a third answer. If so, we will then have two problems, or maybe three: explaing why the Planck prediction is off, explaining why supernova brightness and/or redshift is off, and maybe even why LIGO is off.
- chopin 8y agoDo you have a citation for the LIGO based derived Hubble constant? I didn't find it mentioned in the article (just CMB and Cepheid derived values).
- ncmncm 8y agoNo, it wasn't in the article, because it wasn't relevant, except as independent confirmation that both are in the ballpark. I just gurgled LIGO and Hubble relation, and up popped https://arxiv.org/pdf/1710.05835.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1710.05835.pdf and 'Dr Stephen Feeney of the Center for Computational Astrophysics at the Flatiron Institute in New York City, “We should be able to detect enough mergers to answer this question within 5-10 years.”'