5 ms·
> If our government provided healthcare, eduction, a real pension program, non-terrible unemployment programs, etc. (as it works in most other developed countri
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> If our government provided healthcare, eduction, a real pension program, non-terrible unemployment programs, etc. (as it works in most other developed countries) it would not matter if you are a gig worker or full-time employee.
The issue with most of these things is that governments, especially the US government, are generally worse at providing things than competitive businesses. For people who actually have health insurance, outcomes in the US system are better than in most other countries, the US higher education system is generally considered one of the best in the world, etc.
The key is not to nationalize services, it's to provide a baseline of support. Pay everyone a UBI. Then if you need healthcare, you have money, go buy healthcare. If you want to go to school, go to school. You don't actually need the government to operate the school, and you especially don't need it telling people what to spend the money on. (See also student loans and home loan interest subsidies and the effect on education and housing costs.)
- DoreenMichele 8y agoUBI is cargo cult finance. It's a broken mental model that will kill the system. Money doesn't have inherent exchange value per se. It's primary value is in reducing friction in trade. Injecting more money into a system without tying it to injecting more goods and services into the system is a known means to fuel inflation.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoA UBI doesn't create money, it transfers it. It's a generic safety net that provides a floor for how low income can go, so that nobody involuntarily goes without food or medicine but you also don't need the government providing services itself or ordering people to spend the money in a particular way. > Injecting more money into a system without tying it to injecting more goods and services into the system is a known means to fuel inflation. Right now people are paying for things on credit. If you give them the money instead of requiring them to borrow it, the only difference is that they don't have to pay interest. But it could cause inflation in specific assets if the stuff the net recipients buy is different than the stuff the net payers would have bought -- which would be amazing. We're currently having a huge problem with central banks not being able to hit their inflation targets even at historically low interest rates. If we had something that could bring inflation up to traditional levels it would be a boon, since it would allow nominal wages to rise which is badly needed since everyone is currently saddled with unprecedented levels of mortgage, student loan and credit card debt and anything that could devalue the debt would be a major benefit.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoIf you give them the money instead of requiring them to borrow it You are probably talking about the government borrowing it instead of individuals. This tends to not end well. The money has to come from somewhere. If it isn't tied to creating new goods and services, then either you are basically printing more or taxing someone for it. Wealth transfer schemes are inevitably unpopular and tend to not work well. Schemes to "soak the rich" tend to get push back from the rich, who generally are in a better than average position to resist being victimized by the system.
- SantalBlush 8y ago>Wealth transfer schemes are inevitably unpopular and tend to not work well. Transfer payments are used as an economic stabilizer along with taxation. They also pool risk. You'll need to back up your assertion since most economists see some benefit to transfer payments, and most developed economies use them.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> You are probably talking about the government borrowing it instead of individuals. This tends to not end well. It tends to end with inflation eroding the debt. Which is exactly what we want in this case, ideally over time rather than all at once, but still. > The money has to come from somewhere. Why can't it come from nowhere? That's where the debt it's replacing came from. Banks don't actually have the money they loan you. They're only required to keep a small fraction of it in reserve. The rest of the money is created from nothing. We're fundamentally in a position that we have to print a lot of money and cause a nontrivial amount of inflation because we already did that throughout the housing crisis and the response to it, allowing the prices of housing, education, healthcare and stocks to enter serious bubble territory. As a result of that either the nominal prices of those things have to come down or nominal wages and the nominal prices of everything else have to go up to reach parity with them. But lowering the nominal prices of those things can't save the people who already paid for them on credit and now hold significant debt as a result, which is nearly everybody. Moreover, reducing nominal major asset prices tends to cause much more economic damage than raising the nominal prices of some other assets, because it causes people to default on underwater mortgages, hoard cash rather than investing it because the currency then appreciates in value, etc. So inflation is good right now and printing the money would be a completely reasonable thing to do in the short term. What happens after that is you pay for it from taxes, the same as the subsidy for [more specific program] would otherwise. But that should be a lot easier afterwards because real wages (and therefore real tax revenues) should be significantly higher than they currently are relative to the cost of necessities like housing, education and healthcare. In other words, the real amount of UBI you would need would decline with the real cost of those necessities. > Wealth transfer schemes are inevitably unpopular and tend to not work well. Then why do we keep passing/expanding rather than repealing various redistributive welfare and assistance programs?
- CuriousSkeptic 8y agoUBI as such doesn’t imply anything regarding the source of the money. My favorite scheme, f.ex, would rely entirely on a geoistic LVT-style dividend. The idea there is basically to capture externalities as rent, so no debt, taxes or money printing involved.
- TheMiller 8y ago> UBI is cargo cult finance. It's a broken mental model that will kill the system. Such dismissiveness is unwarranted. There's a lot of intriguing research on the topic that indicates that it may be a cost-effective replacement for the byzantine social support systems of modern governments, with benefits for both recipients and taxpayers. It only seems like a broken model if you /start/ with an overly simplistic model of the current situation, e.g one that ignores both the existence and desirability of social support systems. Unfortunately much of the research is frustratingly incomplete. Search e.g. for information on Mincome. It also seems like a reasonable transition mechanism, from the market economies that have brought us increasing productivity, to a hoped-for post-scarcity future.
- danmaz74 8y agoThe US health care system is the least efficient of all the developed world, in terms of results vs expense. In many sectors, a competitive market gives the best results. In health care, that's just not the case. The free market isn't the be all, end all solution that free market advocates want people to think it is.
- trentnix 8y agoFirst, US health care is hardly a free market. Second, the free market certainly isn’t a be all, end all solution. Most advocates of free market economics would agree with you. It’s just simply better than any of the other solutions man has dreamed up so far, that’s all.
- danmaz74 8y agoIs the free market the best solution to have an army? Or a judiciary system? It's not. So, it's not better than any other solutions for all problems.
- ernst_klim 8y ago>Is the free market the best solution to have an army? It definitely is. As in "I'm not going to pay for bombing other countries, thanks."
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> The US health care system is the least efficient of all the developed world, in terms of results vs expense. In many sectors, a competitive market gives the best results. In health care, that's just not the case. Interestingly, your example undermines your case, because the US system is also less cost efficient than systems that are more market-oriented than it is. The US healthcare system is uniquely problematic. It's not a markets vs. socialism problem, it's a unique damage that arises from trying to do things at such a scale. Everywhere else in the world it's things the size of individual US states doing healthcare regulation, e.g. a median US state like Oregon has a GDP larger than Portugal or Greece. In the US it happens at the level of the entire union, which screws things up something terrible because it's well past the point that economies of scale give diminishing returns but it grows the public and private bureaucracies so large that they have their own inertia and gravity. If the only thing the US did was repeal all federal healthcare laws and hand the whole thing over to the individual states, it would probably cut costs significantly. And then California could have single payer and New Jersey could require employer-provided coverage and Wyoming could let the market handle it entirely and probably all of them would do better than the feds are currently doing.