3 ms·
> So if you speak to an American consular official, you deserve that conversation to be made public? But if you comment online about file-sharing, you deserve t
by bambax 16y ago
> So if you speak to an American consular official, you deserve that conversation to be made public? But if you comment online about file-sharing, you deserve to remain anonymous?
The difference between my secrets and the secrets of the government is that the government works for me.
The government governs in the name of the people. I am the people. Government employees are my employees.
If my employees keep their actions secret from me, conspire with diplomats from other countries against me and try to push me into waging wars based on false information, then I should be able to find this out and make it public.
> [Wikileaks] are my enemy, and I support any use of state force against them, up to and including lethal force.
You have the right to "support" anything you want, but the US constitution (in theory!) prevents the government from killing individuals without due process (which includes charging them with crimes based on pre-existing laws, and trying them in an open court).
If you don't approve of the US constitution, then what are you fighting for...?
- tzs 16y agoBy your argument, any dealing a citizen has with the government should be fully in the public record, for all other citizens to see. Does that mean you think you should be able to see my income tax return? As far as your employee analogy goes, employees sometimes do need to keep secrets from their employer. For instance, if I tell my lawyer something I expect it to only be shared with other lawyers who are actually working on my case and need to know it. Just because my lawyer is an employee of a firm does not mean that the owners of the firm have any right to secrets I've shared with my lawyer. The notion that government employees are your employees is simply wrong. You are more like a stockholder, not an employer. Companies are not required to tell their stockholders every detail of the operations of the business, for good reason.