3 ms·
Women and women's rights advocates find themselves in a "damned if you do, damned if you don't" situation. Not putting gender in the title fails to celebrate fe
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
Women and women's rights advocates find themselves in a "damned if you do, damned if you don't" situation. Not putting gender in the title fails to celebrate female accomplishments. The student will be assumed male. Putting it in the title inevitably leads to some kind of criticism, often an extremely and unnecessarily ugly criticism.
And it tends to not matter how one frames it when trying to signal pride in female accomplishment. Someone is bound to have an issue with it. People will debate endlessly whether "female" or "woman" is the worst, most offensive term. Or people will be mad that gender was signaled at all and decry it as "reverse sexism."
Progress in such issues would go better if people would stop having a cow about gender signaling in titles and stop being agressively ugly about it never being perfect enough.
- belorn 8y agoSwedish national news has a initiative where gender is avoided in articles unless it is directly relevant. The goal is to avoid creating a exaggerated view of gendered roles. If 80% of the police is men and a person see two stories which both include male police, a reader might conclude that all police is 100% male. If one out of five articles have a female police you only reach the subset of readers that happen to catch those articles. With no gender you reach all your audience. I would very much like to see a similar policy on HN. Attaching gender to articles inhibit progress. The fastest progress is the one that goes unnoticed and simply is.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI don't know what the best approach is. I would like to think that downplaying gender helps, but minorities find it hard to find good role models, people "like them" that they can identify with, etc. Actively downplaying gender and officially excluding gender signaling in headlines seems to make it all the harder for women to find things they can relate to. I honestly don't know what the best path forward is. I do know that excess criticism of minority signals often actively shits all over expressions of pride and attempts to connect while nominally pretending to be righteous indignation on the part of mistreated underdogs.