10 ms·
Lambda School wants to teach nursing
- hhs 8y agoThis is interesting. There’s also a projection of physician shortage in the years to come. This is both for primary and specialty doctors, and I’m curious if there will be innovative ways to work around this, too; this was released a few days ago here: https://news.aamc.org/press-releases/article/2019-workforce-projections-update/ https://news.aamc.org/press-releases/article/2019-workforce-....
- jseliger 8y agoMy understanding is that the big problems are 1. existing credentialing bodies and 2. the AMA, which wants to restrict entry into the profession and chiefly does so through the residency system. The physician shortage is a bug to the larger society but a feature to existing doctors, who wish to charge patients more and raise their own salaries. But see also https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/08/upshot/a-doctor-shortage-lets-take-a-closer-look.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/08/upshot/a-doctor-shortage-....
- hhs 8y agoThat’s a good way to think about this, it has a unique problem on that level.
- phren0logy 8y agoHi, I'm a doc. Just wanted to add a few corrections: The AMA (American Medical Association) has nothing to do with residency slots. Residency slots are funded by CMS. I am in a shortage speciality, and we have been pushing for more residency slots for a long time. While there are probably some physicians who are self-interested enough to oppose this, I think it's unfair to characterize them as even a significant minority. Even if you think of physicians as ruthlessly self-interested, this still wouldn't serve us as the shortage has largely led to the influx of people with a small fraction of the clinical training (such as nurse practitioners) taking roles traditionally filled by doctors. Interestingly, they are not generally held to the same standard of care, so I'd hardly call that a boon to patients, either.
- hhs 8y agoThanks for adding your views, this is useful. On the AAMC site, there's also a piece called "GME Funding and Its Role in Addressing the Physician Shortage" that talks about the point you rightly make about pushing for more residency slots. It's here: https://news.aamc.org/for-the-media/article/gme-funding-doctor-shortage/ https://news.aamc.org/for-the-media/article/gme-funding-doct.... On the residency point, it adds: "As part of the multi-pronged approach to alleviating the doctor shortage we also need additional federal support to produce about 3,750 more doctors a year by lifting the cap on federally funded residency training positions. Teaching hospitals are operating 10,000 residency positions without Medicare support, but cuts to Medicare and other clinical reimbursements jeopardize the ability of teaching hospitals to cross-subsidize with clinical revenue these positions. The AAMC strongly supports bipartisan GME legislation introduced in both the House of Representatives and the Senate, the Resident Physician Shortage Reduction Act of 2019 (H.R. 1763, S. 348), which takes an important step towards alleviating the physician shortage by gradually providing 15,000 Medicare-supported GME residency positions over a five-year period. However, legislation alone will not relieve the doctor shortage. In addition, the AAMC supports non-GME incentives and programs, including Conrad 30, the National Health Service Corps (NHSC) and Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF), and Title VII/VIII, which are used to recruit a diverse workforce and encourage physicians to practice in shortage specialties and underserved communities."
- klipt 8y agoThere are tons of highly qualified doctors in other developed countries (EU, Australia, etc) who could earn more in the US, what stops them from practicing here if we have a shortage?
- sigstoat 8y agothey're not licensed to practice medicine in the US. and last i checked they can't transfer their licenses easily, or at all.
- planetburgess 8y agoThey might also prefer to work in a better medical system.
- Cass 8y agoIf you want a fully qualified GP-track resident, there's probably no way to compress the learning process much further down than the four years of American med school. German med school takes six and a half years to teach the same amount of knowledge, and that's already a brutally challenging course of study. (At least it was to me, a reasonable driven straight-A student.) Looking at the American med students I know, getting through med school in four years seems to require giving up all semblance of a private life and driving yourself to the edge of exhaustion/over the edge into a mental break-down. I don't think there's a way to do it in three years or even less. That said, there might be a market for specialists with less training than that. There's no real reason to make e.g. an aspiring orthopedic surgeon sit through the entirety of med school, including all the dermatology/pediatrics/gynecology etc stuff. But as another commenter mentioned, you'll have a hard time getting the regulatory bodies to accept your "eight months to orthopedic surgery" students as fully qualified doctors
- klipt 8y ago> German med school takes six and a half years to teach the same amount of knowledge I think the difference is that many students enter German (and other non-US) med schools immediately after high school, while US med schools only accept students who already have a 4 year undergrad degree. So in reality US medical training takes 8 years (4 years of pre-med undergrad, 4 years med school) which makes the 6 years look relatively efficient. Also those non-US doctors graduate with substantially less debt.
- jseliger 8y agoGood: https://jakeseliger.com/2019/03/13/the-college-bribery-scandal-vs-lambda-school https://jakeseliger.com/2019/03/13/the-college-bribery-scand.... It seems that higher-ed reform is not going to come from within; it must start from outside the current system.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- username223 8y ago> The firm devotes about a third of its time and resources to finding jobs for its graduates, an unusually high share. Another third goes to recruiting students and the rest to teaching. So, 2/3 of what they're paid (presumably after Austen Allred's and the VCs' take), is marketing, leaving the leftovers to pay for actual instructors. If I end up in the hospital, I want a nurse with an actual education, not "nursing boot camp."
- azhenley 8y agoHow much of a university's budget goes to actual teaching?
- austenallred 8y agoThat’s actually not how it breaks down, I told the reporter I segment the company into three sections in my mind, he asked which is more important, and I said they all have to work.
- username223 8y agoThen the reporter seriously misled me about what you said, and I apologize. I'm curious about the real breakdown between marketing to students and hospitals, overhead and executive pay, and instructor pay, but I can understand if you don't want to reveal that.
- austenallred 8y agoRight now our marketing budget rounds to zero. We have a growth team that is mostly focused on making sure the admissions funnel runs smoothly, and get about 1,000 organic applications/week. We have ~80 full-time employees and about 200 part-time. 40 of the full-time and all 200 part-time are dedicated to teaching/career coaching.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 8y ago
- seancoleman 8y agoThis is ironic. My girlfriend, a nurse of 10+ years, got accepted to the Lambda School web dev track and is starting at the end of May, to get out of nursing.
- rovyko 8y agoOh is this the one with the website posted a few weeks back?
- seancoleman 8y agoIt sure is! She applied, got accepted and finished all the pre-coursework.
- austenallred 8y agoThe end goal of Lambda School is to be somewhat of an economic clearing house. Move people from where they are to where they want to be quickly, cheaply, and taking care of the entire stack at no risk to the student. So this is actually in line with where we want to be in the future.
- RoboTeddy 8y agoWhat if someone wants to go somewhere where they most likely won't be paid much? (e.g. art, music) Can Lambda School extend there?
- austenallred 8y agoYes, but would be more expensive (a higher percentage of income), although loans are a higher percentage as well.
- ngngngng 8y agoI'm torn on Lambda. On one hand, it seems far superior to traditional higher education, since the schools success depends on the success of the students. At the same time, profit sharing is a terrible financial decision. When compared with other bootcamps, it's basically a bet against yourself. You're willing to risk tens of thousands of dollars more money for some risk insurance. I have such a hard time accepting that people can't just teach themselves things using free online resources. It's been shown in many studies that self directed learning doesn't work, but it worked for me. And I can't stand the idea of smart people paying thousands to learn things they could learn for free.
- austenallred 8y agoIf people can self learn they will. I think doing so is much, much more difficult than others pretend like it is. Given that you could earn the entire cost of Lambda School (at the cap - the most expensive) in about three months of engineering time, it’s a rational decision even if you just speed up the process.
- naveen99 8y agoDoes lambda school come with a .edu email address for students ?
- austenallred 8y agoNo, Lambda School is not an accredited school.
- codingdave 8y agoPerhaps you should look into getting it? Accreditation does exist for vocational schools, and you'd go a long ways towards alleviating the concerns of potential students if you pursued it: http://www.accsc.org/Accreditation/Standards-of-Accreditation.aspx http://www.accsc.org/Accreditation/Standards-of-Accreditatio...
- Eridrus 8y ago> But Ms McRae is also concerned that programmes like Lambda School, though well-meaning, risk undermining existing educational institutions by offering a quicker route to work. If only. We all know the majority of what we learned in school was not useful. We should be striving to cut out the wasteful education that only serves as a signaling arms race https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/01/whats-college-good-for/546590/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/01/whats-c...
- jacobobryant 8y agoDon't know why this was downvoted. Having gone through higher ed, I think "undermining existing educational institutions" is a great thing. Now if we could just get rid of the standard hierarchical corporate structure...
- Double_a_92 8y agoAverage people are already generally pretty ignorant... Removing even basic general knowledge from society, is not going to do anything good. We tend to underestimate that because we (engineers / people on HN) mostly happen to have a good education and interest in general knowledge.
- Eridrus 8y agoImproving general knowledge and ability is an admirable goal. But education is pretty bad at it.
- notbob 8y agoI am skeptical that these income sharing agreements are so great. Especially in software. Lambda School has a 9 month program that takes a 17% cut of your salary for the first 24 months of employment with a cap at $30,000. Which many students in software will hit, especially in high COL areas. It's worth noting that this is more expensive than many/most universities, which charge less than $30,000 per year (9 months of instruction) even at the sticker price (which no one actually pays). In fact, I wonder whether bootcamps are even cheaper than the full cost of university. The average student loan debt upon graduation for all US university students is $29,400 (again, for four years of college education with access to both applied and fundamental courses across many different majors vs. a 9 month boot camp focused on a particular skill set). To be concrete: by taking out a loan for what lambda school costs, you could double major in both nursing and CS at a state U for about the same amount of post-graduation debt as you would have at bootcamps. Or CS and Econ. Or CS and Accounting. Or CS and Mechanical Engineering. In states that still invest in higher ed, you'll end up paying less (even with interest) than you'd pay lambda school. There's a natural experiment on this question at Purdue, where there's an apples-for-apples comparison and loans are almost always cheaper than the income sharing agreement. To me, these income sharing agreements and bootcamps seem like not great deals when you look at instruction time per dollar. And also when you look at the longitudinal durability of the skill-set that's being taught. They have a place in the market for sure, but they aren't the panacea to expensive education. They're not even cost-competitive. They're just a different point in the design space of educational programs that extract as much of the added value of their product as possible.
- azhenley 8y agoThe comments in this thread also don’t account for internships. In CS you can make 20-30k in a summer and it is common to do multiple over your college career.
- TheSpiciestDev 8y agoWhile I can't disagree about other programs being less expensive, how much is it worth to students knowing that the program is incentivized to get them hired because _the program won't get paid unless the student get well hired after_? It's a priceless feature that every student would value differently... maybe that's worth a few thousand more?
- RonnieDipple 8y agoLambda school is a blessing for those of us born into unfortunate circumstances with limited time, money and an urgent need to support a family and hopefully pull them out of poverty. I start in May wish me luck
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- TheSpiciestDev 8y agoGood luck!.. I've referred two people to Lambda who start later next month. They're both excited to start and I'm looking forward to hearing how their experience is before I go all-out and refer more people - it's a program that has a structure and philosophy that I can easily agree with.
- Ronnie_Dipple 8y agoLambda seems to be changing a lot of lives.
- technics256 8y agoGood luck! Things might get hard or seem confusing at times. I still feel that way after years of programming experience. You'll get through it and enjoy the benefits!
- Ronnie_Dipple 8y agoThank you!
- chriselles 8y agoI’m definitely a big believer in Lambda School. I believe it aligns the interests of: 1)student 2)school 3)employer Far better than the existing conventional university model in teaching tangible trade skills. Lambda School can and will adapt to the ever changing needs of employers far faster than universities because Lambda School’s very existence depends on it. However, does the same apply to regulated and licensed “guilds” like nursing, medicine, dentistry, etc? Will “guild” like protectionism of their profession impede efforts in this direction? Lambda School already seems to be making enemies understandably in the traditional university computer engineering and upfront paid bootcamp sectors. Will it make enemies with professional regulatory bodies who may be biased to prefer higher education hurdles and fewer licensed practitioners to protect their income?
- austenallred 8y agoLambda School has to play by the rules of regulatory bodies. It makes it more difficult to be innovative but makes sense in a field line nursing.
- austenallred 8y ago“But Ms McRae is also concerned that programmes like Lambda School, though well-meaning, risk undermining existing educational institutions by offering a quicker route to work.”
- Reedx 8y agoNetflix, though well-meaning, risks undermining existing video rental companies by offering a quicker way to watch movies.
- nickwalton00 8y ago...so it's threatening because it's better haha.
- awwstn 8y agoI love Lambda's concept. I think aligning the interests of the school with the interests of the student are a fantastic evolution, and committing to only charge students for payback in the case that they have a positive outcome is great too. That said, the "only pay us back if you get a good job" commitment seems like lip service as long as the cutoff is $50K (for software dev at least). Lambda school's team is super vocal on Twitter and regularly shares stories of students who walk away making 3-4x what they made previously...if the program genuinely believes it can consistently graduate students who can earn $80-$150K in the market, then it should align its business model to that. The median salary for a software engineer in the US is $100K. The current Lambda promise is "you only have to pay us back if you earn half the nationwide median salary in the 5 years following our program"...this does not strike me as a very bold commitment to the quality of the program. To be very clear: I've seen successes of Lambda students and I believe that they have created a model that graduates students who are competitive in this job market. So, I'm not saying that Lambda is bad. On the contrary: I'm saying Lambda is excellent and they should be bolstered by that excellence to take a stance with a less conservative income share agreement. From their site: > Instead of paying tuition, students can agree to pay a percentage of their income after they're employed, and only if they're making more than $50k per year.
- austenallred 8y agoMost of our students are in rural areas where $50k is actually really good money (though this is changing). There’s not really an existing legal framework to say “if you make x in this kind of city or y in this kind of city.” Certainly, in San Francisco, $50k isn’t a win. Luckily our median salary there is well into the six figures. Lambda School’s income share agreement is also (to my knowledge) the only in the industry that is industry-specific. If you end up as a bartender making $60k we make $0. Most 3 month schools are 15% for 3 yrs with a $40k min. Lambda School is 9 months, 17% for 2 yrs with a $50k min and a cap. So our agreement is actually very aggressive as is, and will become more aggressive over time.
- nickpsecurity 8y agoConsider using a base amount modified by cost of living, esp locational, with a formula that adapts when it changes. Buffer does this for their transparent salary calculations: https://open.buffer.com/transparent-salaries/ https://open.buffer.com/transparent-salaries/ Btw, love what you're doing. It might have helped me back when I was in a rural area. We didn't have Internet, though. So, would've been whatever I could do at libraries during narrow windows of computer use. These days it's McDonalds' Wifi for lots of folks. Do factor that into your offerings somehow if you don't already. Good luck LS! Looks like awesome stuff you all are doing.
- qwerty456127 8y agoI want to learn nursing online.
- MispelledToyota 8y agoDuring my time at Lambda School, seeing people's quick arguments against it have drastically lowered my priors on how correct "hot takes" are likely to be in general. Sort of like reading a newspaper article about your area of expertise for the first time, and realizing how many inaccuracies all newspaper articles must have. There are places for skepticism but the actual critiques made are shockingly wide of the mark in my opinion as someone who found the value proposition compelling.
- austenallred 8y agoHow is Lambda School going for you?
- MispelledToyota 8y agoI graduated two weeks ago and got a job offer, and am overjoyed by the fact. I think if I asked myself at the beginning, what's the most you can hope for in going to Lambda School, my expectations were met by the education quality and the follow-through from the outcomes team. It's not perfect but the incentive structure forces constant improvement in the factors that matter most for getting us hired. People point out it's not a CS degree and they're right. But the staff manages to teach concrete skills to get students hired, and the CS, data structures, algorithms stuff in the curriculum is taught well enough and with enough enthusiasm that it gives students the basis to be conversant with CS concepts and continue growing forward. It might not work for everyone; some people are going to struggle to become programmers. But Lambda is trying their hardest to make it work for as many people as they can, and their heart is in the right place. And it is structured so if it doesn't work for a student their downside is hedged. Due to the $50k/industry-specific cutoff for repayment, the downside of going to Lambda but not making a career transition will be least harmful to the least advantaged students.
- austenallred 8y agoWhat was the worst part of Lambda? What are we really bad at?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dj_gitmo 8y ago> If Lambda can turn a profit by offering people a stab at a decent job, that would be a fine lesson in capitalism. I'm not so sure. The solution might not be to train more nurses, but to retain the exiting nurses. Nurses have a really high turnover rate in the U.S. The problem is nursing is demanding work and it often requires long hours. > Nurses who work more than 12 hours in a single shift and more than 40 hours a week are likely to leave the nursing workforce within a year. Overtime for nurses should not be commonplace. Instead, hospitals and other healthcare organizations should reduce the length of shifts and the number of hours in a workweek. Hospital administrators should not push nurses into working extra hours. https://rnbsnonline.unm.edu/articles/high-cost-of-nurse-turnover.aspx https://rnbsnonline.unm.edu/articles/high-cost-of-nurse-turn... > A study by Compdata Surveys of 11,000 healthcare employers with more than 11 million employees found the average turnover in healthcare jobs in 2017 was 20.6%, up from 15.6% in 2010, putting healthcare’s turnover second only to hospitality’s. https://www.beckershospitalreview.com/finance/will-2018-be-the-year-healthcare-addresses-its-turnover-problem.html https://www.beckershospitalreview.com/finance/will-2018-be-t... > Turnover rates also varied significantly across countries with the highest rate reported in New Zealand (44·3%) followed by the US (26·8%), Canada (19·9%) and Australia (15·1%). https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/jan.12483 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/jan.12483 This might be a lesson in capitalism, but maybe not the lesson that The Economists thinks.
- PorterDuff 8y agoI wonder if it's cheating to sign up for Lambda School if you have no intention of getting a job.
- quickthrower2 8y agoIs it ethical? Sounds like a similar question to the person on HN who signed up for a credit card just to transfer money 100 times a year and collect the cashback.
- neilv 8y ago(I don't know about Lambda School specifically; just speaking of fields here.) Any talk of transferring anything cultural from current software development practice to somewhere else important... makes me nervous, by default. Right now, we have huge problems in software development practice, with both design&implementation quality, and ethics. You don't want your medical device or bridge developed in any way like the majority of software right now. You don't want your ER nurse to be smug about how smart they are, while they do shoddy work with fad tools and halfwitted cargo cult processes. You don't want your doctor or lawyer selling you out to 'analytics', for starters, like almost every dotcom startup does. As startups try to bring the greatness of Webrogramming to other areas, are they going to suddenly say, "Oh, but this is actually an important area, unlike the information infrastructure of humanity, so this one we'll do with more responsibility than obviously we have been."
- austenallred 8y agoLambda School isn’t really software; we spent the first 18 months writing little to no code while we focused on building a world class school. Now, of course, we’re using software to scale everything and data science to measure and optimize everything, but the core engine is a really great school and instructional design we created from the ground up, not code.
- neilv 8y agoI wish you the best of luck in doing this well. The profession of nursing is live-critical important, and incredibly demanding.
- menzoic 8y agoOP was speaking less about software and more about tech startup culture. Theranos comes to mind. Shoddy MVPs work well for consumer software but are dangerous in the medical field where the results could be life or death. The question is how can existing processes help/hurt a transition to medical field or will it require a radically different approach that doesn't gain from existing expertise (or at least without thorough consideration).
- WC3w6pXxgGd 8y agoI LOVE this! The healthcare industry NEEDS competition.
- gopher2 8y agoIsn't the mindset in medicine totally different from software engineering as far as being self-taught? I'm surprised that they don't think jobs want you to have a degree from an accredited school vs a bootcamp. Or that lambda school thinks they won't?
- CapnCrunchie 8y agoWho's to say that the nursing side of Lambda won't be accredited?
- austenallred 8y agoThe nursing portion of lambda school would definitely be accredited and licensed
- gopher2 8y agoAhh, gotcha. Thanks for clarifying! Makes sense then - I think I misinterpreted something in the article.
- sandGorgon 8y agoCurious to know - is this going to be checklist centric ? There was a recent post on how a simple thing like checklists can really cut infection and death rate by half or something. And there were startups that attempted to do this at the doctor level but failed to be able to drive change. Would you be the GitHub of nursing - drive change from bottom up. Build checklist creation and adherence at the nurses level ?