5 ms·
>they all told me that without these jobs, they would have nothing. There are two things going on here that makes this more complicated that meets the eye. For
by whatshisface 8y ago
>they all told me that without these jobs, they would have nothing.
There are two things going on here that makes this more complicated that meets the eye. For one, as you have pointed out, lowering the price of labor increases the number of things people would be willing to hire someone to do, thereby increasing the number of jobs. However, it's also true that by removing the protections for one specific form of labor but not all, gig economy companies will have a competitive advantage over classical employment companies and put them out of business. So, the gig economy is reducing the number of "classical" jobs.
These effects point in opposite directions, and without being able to put numbers on them there's no way judge which wins out. Measured in terms of "money paid to low-skill workers," the reduction in everybody's wages might or might not be offset by the increased number of jobs, an increase which has been attenuated by the gig economy replacing some of the old economy.
- patrickaljord 8y agoThere's another way to see this, worker protections were invented to put low skilled people out of work (historically, people of color). https://www.forbes.com/sites/carriesheffield/2014/04/29/on-the-historically-racist-motivations-behind-minimum-wage/#4914f8f211bb https://www.forbes.com/sites/carriesheffield/2014/04/29/on-t...
- deogeo 8y agoCountries other than the US have minimum wage laws. Or do you want to imply we have to choose between worker protections and diversity?
- nostrademons 8y agoIt's possible for different countries to adopt the same policy for different reasons. Many countries get around diversity issues by not having diversity.
- patrickaljord 8y agoRead the article, it's not just the US, South Africa too. And I know it was the same in France and many European countries to prevent low skilled immigrants from getting jobs. My point is, worker protections almost by definition prevent low skilled workers from getting jobs because they impose additional costs that low skilled workers are the first to pay by losing job opportunities. In the economy, any additional cost has to be paid by someone eventually, guess who that usually is.
- js2 8y agoSo let the free market sort it out in a race to the bottom? Should workers be able to unionize to demand better from their employers?
- patrickaljord 8y agoOnly 4% of people are paid minimum wage, everyone else is paid above http://poverty.ucdavis.edu/faq/what-are-characteristics-minimum-wage-workers http://poverty.ucdavis.edu/faq/what-are-characteristics-mini... so even if there really was a "race to the bottom" it would only affect those 4% and then most people would refuse to work for a salary that is so ridiculously low that staying at home would be more beneficial. The free market is the best (or less worse) system at giving people a wage as high as possible compared to socialism. Now, we're talking very low skilled people who can't seem to get a job anywhere, in this case, increasing barrier to entry only makes things worse. Given that most jobs require skills, most jobs are paid above minimum wage thanks to free market competition so no race to the bottom would happen in most case and even then the market would fix a limit (ie no one would accept your offer if it's too low, same reason no one in SV would accept an offer below $100k ;). > Should workers be able to unionize to demand better from their employers? Absolutely, there can't be a free market without freedom of association.
- fzeroracer 8y agoIn your argument to reduce worker protections you seem to ignore the contradictory stance of increased unionization with lower worker protections. Unions by definition will increase the number of protections for workers and increase the costs of labor. Personally I take an opposite stance: the problem with the free market is that it has to optimize for infinite growth. It doesn't matter if you make profit, you have to make the most profit or you're a failure. Which means removing insurance for workers, minimizing wages, maximizing unpaid overtime etc. The free market is fundamentally at odds with workers and that's why companies employ lobbying and union busting behavior.
- batterseapower 8y agoFor ridesharing apps, at least, it seems clear that the gig economy has grown the total market and hence the number of workers needed to serve this market. Before Uber entered New York there were ~500k cab trips per day: now, yellow cabs only serve 250k trips but 700k trips are performed by ridesharers [1]. The negative effect on employment is about 3x smaller than the positive one. [1] https://toddwschneider.com/dashboards/nyc-taxi-ridehailing-uber-lyft-data/ https://toddwschneider.com/dashboards/nyc-taxi-ridehailing-u...
- bonzini 8y agoThose 700k trips are operating at a loss, so the numbers are not representative of the effect of gig economy.
- karussell 8y agoPlease do not confuse ridesharing with ridehailing although the companies like Lyft und Uber invest a lot to blur the line. > Before Uber entered New York there were ~500k cab trips per day This is not a good argument as Uber & Lyft are not yet making profit and in general you cannot compare both numbers as ridehailing grabs trips from public transit: https://sf.curbed.com/2018/7/27/17622178/uber-lyft-cause-traffic-streets-congestion-bruce-schaller-tnc-report https://sf.curbed.com/2018/7/27/17622178/uber-lyft-cause-tra... https://www.businessinsider.de/uber-lyft-having-devastating-effect-on-public-transportation-study-2019-1?op=1&r=US&IR=T https://www.businessinsider.de/uber-lyft-having-devastating-... Not to talk about the negative effects of their growth: http://www.schallerconsult.com/rideservices/automobility.htm http://www.schallerconsult.com/rideservices/automobility.htm
- Mirioron 8y ago>So, the gig economy is reducing the number of "classical" jobs. Sure, but the gig economy started from displacing jobs that were caught in regulatory capture. Most of the people that the earlier post talked about wouldn't be able to get a job as a taxi driver due to regulations. I think that, so far, the gig economy isn't pushing heavily into areas that aren't suffering from regulatory capture.