3 ms·
Apart from the initial cost construction and maintenance. Are there cost of Fusion in terms of cost/W? Or do we get Free, limitless Energy? Wouldn't the first
by ksec 8y ago
Apart from the initial cost construction and maintenance. Are there cost of Fusion in terms of cost/W? Or do we get Free, limitless Energy?
Wouldn't the first country achieve this be in huge / leap forward advantage? Especially for a country like China with lots of Production and Exports.
- maxxxxx 8y agoRunning a fusion reactor will still cost significant money. It's a very complex machine.
- bjelkeman-again 8y agoAnd it can’t be built everywhere where energy is needed, due the its complexity.
- amluto 8y agoI assume you mean cost/J or cost/MWh. Construction and maintenance will be most of that. Most credible fusion reactor designs product a lot of neutrons, and neutrons get absorbed by most materials and degrade them. (And turn some materials radioactive — avoiding long term radioactivity is an important design considerations.) There will also be staffing costs, fuel costs (small, but still — deuterium and tritium aren’t free), and even costs associated with obtaining cooling water. The big benefits of fusion over fission, as I see it, are that the fuels are safe and plentiful, the byproducts are harmless (if neutron activation is well managed), and the reactor itself isn’t full of extremely dangerous materials. If you turn a fusion reactor off, it’s off, and there’s no risk that it accidentally keeps reacting.
- jmpman 8y agoDoes it also reduce proliferation concerns?
- mandelken 8y agoYou can not make a bomb with fusion materials alone. Hydronuclear bombs use fission materials (uranium, plutonium) to start the fusion reaction. However, maybe a fusion reactor may be used for fission bomb research, but I'm not sure how.
- matt2000 8y agoLooks like fuel costs are really low, but maintenance and replacement component cost might be pretty significant: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0360544218305395#sec5 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S036054421...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 8y agoIt will have a renewables-like cost structure in that it will be really expensive to build, with a finite lifetime, and modest operational costs. No doubt some time in the first few years there will be some unforseen new kinds of maintenance requirements and failure modes to discover.
- pfdietz 8y agoIt will be much more expensive than renewables, so saying it has a "renewable-like cost structure" is not accurate. Given complexity and high material stresses, fusion reactors will also likely have very high operating costs. DT reactors, in particular, will require replacement of major structural elements every few years due to neutron damage.
- pfdietz 8y agoIf the gross fusion power output of ITER were converted to electricity at 40% efficiency, and you ignored the power needed to run the reactor, and also ignored the cost of the breeding blanket, turbines, and generators (which ITER doesn't have) then the capital cost would be about $100/W(e). In contrast, the cost of installed utility scale PV is around $1/W.