3 ms·
> First most obvious, how come do pilots trust a system that has these layers of manual security checks with their lives. And second, can't it all be automated?
by gumby 8y ago
> First most obvious, how come do pilots trust a system that has these layers of manual security checks with their lives. And second, can't it all be automated?
Conveniently the word "deviance" has multiple meanings, two of which apply here.
The article uses deviance in the sense of "deviation from the behavioral norm" (where that norm is a external process). I completely agree with your assessment that these processes can become cumbersome and a barrier to doing work (at most big companies the process becomes the point and dominates actually getting work done). Automation can go a long way to improving that, both in reducing cynicism and letting people spend their time on the stuff that actually moves the company forward.
However the manual checks in aviation also serve to find unexpected deviation in the shape or performance of the device. The reason the first officer walks around the aircraft is not for exercise but because she may see something "out of the ordinary" for which no test exists -- something that should be straight looks subtly out of kilter, indicating that, say, a bolt on the wheel has come loose and under load the wheel tilts slightly. This kind if check is harder to find in software which uses many fewer humans intuitions, which is why we have code stylebook and code reviews.
- jacquesm 8y agoPool of hydraulic fluid near the landing gear wheels is one example of such an out of the ordinary thing for which no test exists. Presumably the hydraulics would still work for take-off, a wheel assembly might end up not being stowed properly or it might refuse to descend on landing. The example in the article is an interesting one because to an outsider it clearly looks bonkers and yet, to an experienced insider it might look workable.