17 ms·
Interesting... I've only ever heard of brain drain used in an international context. Which is where the US comes out as a winner, as we're gaining from all the
by crazygringo 8y ago
Interesting... I've only ever heard of brain drain used in an international context. Which is where the US comes out as a winner, as we're gaining from all the highly educated Chinese and Indians who come here to work and start companies.
I actually find the concept rather odd to use domestically, because it's generally used to show a contrast between a country paying for your college education, and then you reaping the benefits in a different, richer country -- which can seem unfair.
But in the US, students 1) generally pay for their own college education, and 2) often go to college in a state different from where they grew up and different from where they'll settle down later. So it doesn't seem to have any "unfair" aspect.
I mean, complaining about brain drain domestically feels like complaining about free trade domestically... it doesn't make sense to me. People have the freedom to move to areas of better economic opportunity and that's a good thing in a dynamic, ever-changing country like America. Complaining about brain drain domestically really just sounds like wishing more people lived in the country instead of in big cities... no thanks.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_capital_flight#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_capital_flight#United_St...
- btrettel 8y agoTuition for in-state residents is often subsidized and can be considerably lower than tuition for residents of other US states.
- greeneggs 8y agoFor example, in California, UC tuition is ~$14,000/year and the state subsidizes $12,098/year per student. https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2018/08/21/report-asks-whether-university-california-funding-nearing-tipping-point https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2018/08/21/report-asks-w...
- durkie 8y agoGeorgia is an interesting outlier here: they introduced the HOPE scholarship in the 1990s to allow any in-state (already lived there for at least a year) student free tuition at a state school as long as they maintained a 3.0 GPA, all funded by the state lottery. And you have some pretty good schools to choose from here: University of Georgia, Georgia Tech, and Georgia State (which has improved a lot in the past 10 years). There are plenty of fair criticisms that can be leveled against the HOPE scholarship, but it seemed clear to me that it would reduce brain drain in the state, simply because students could get a high quality education at almost no cost. But these data show that the drain ratio increased from 1990 to 2010. So this is a situation where students aren't paying for their education, are going to school in the state where they likely grew up, and then are still leaving.
- Xcelerate 8y ago> students aren't paying for their education, are going to school in the state where they likely grew up, and then are still leaving This was me. I grew up in Georgia and went to Georgia Tech on the HOPE scholarship, but there just aren't many tech jobs in the area (despite the fact that GT has one of the top ranked CS programs). I moved to the Bay Area a year ago. If Georgia would incentivize the tech industry like it has with filmmaking recently, I bet a lot more people would stay.
- kbrwn 8y agoIt seems like most of the incentives are tax waivers. Georgia also has lots of land for films to work with. Do you think it would work for tech? I'm not sure if Atlanta has the clout to bring skilled engineers from NYC/SF
- durkie 8y agoIt's about to be me too. GT grad and likely moving to Bay area soon.
- landryraccoon 8y agoThe problem is that local governments and communities acting in their own self interest will rationally underfund education. Let's say that hypothetically all new science and engineering jobs are all in ScienceVille. In that case, any local government that doesn't receive some direct tax benefit from taxes collected in SV has negative incentive to teach their students anything about Science, since those students will just leave (after their education has been invested in by the local government) and move to SV to get a job. Those local government are now incentivized to teach their kids anything else (like religion and manual labor) since even if they can only do manual labor at least they're going to stay in their hometown. Now there is a difference of incentives for the individual States verses the Nation. The Nation would prefer to have lots more engineers and skilled tech workers. The States would prefer to keep their best and their brightest, and if that means they are underutilized that's still a local maximum for the individual State. Naturally, this is great for SV, but horrible for the rest of the nation. In this scenario, the entirely imaginary, hypothetical "SV" has to either give something back to incentivize the rest of the nation to keep teaching Science and Engineering, or the rest of the country continually subsidizes SV through education which is unsustainable.
- cageface 8y agoJapan has an interesting approach to this problem. I don’t remember the details but they have some mechanism to funnel tax revenues from big urban areas to the smaller cities that provide a lot of their educated workforce.
- C4K3 8y agoHometown tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hometown_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hometown_tax Its implementation is flawed though, citizens can freely pick any city even if they have no relation to it, and cities are allowed to give gifts to citizens who choose the city, resulting in cities competing to offer the best kickbacks.