4 ms·
As others have said if your idea is straightforward to implement and easy to grok then likely it would be independently "discovered" and implemented regardless
by InclinedPlane 16y ago
As others have said if your idea is straightforward to implement and easy to grok then likely it would be independently "discovered" and implemented regardless of whether you told anyone else. Nobody had to tell the world to make mp3 players or automobiles, they were obvious ideas that many people had and implemented at about the same time.
If you have a truly novel idea then you'll often have trouble getting people to accept it, and even if they do if they were to implement it they would get the details so wrong that they wouldn't steal your thunder.
Imagine one of the google founders telling everyone else how google was going to work. Even if other sites had simplified their search landing and results pages, even if they had used page rank, etc. they still wouldn't have reproduced google search. It required the coordination of several disparate disciplines from computer science (map reduce / parallel computing / pagerank) to system administration (sharding / commodity hardware / unique data center operations) to user interface design (response time / uncluttered interface) to business sense (contextual, unobtrusive advertising) to get that right, and it's the careful balance and details of every single element that led to the success of google search.
Or you can look at mp3 players again. An obvious idea that everybody had. By the time apple entered the market it was saturated, but they executed better than everyone else and dominated the market.
- biznickman 16y agoGreat point ... sounds like the main conclusion is that easy to replicate businesses would have already been developed. However I would also argue that there are plenty of instances where you think to yourself "Why didn't I think of that?" Then again, even in those instances execution is key. So is there really ever an instance which justifies not sharing your idea?