3 ms·
One possibly is because they want to make sure the redacted sections are really redacted. You can do a web search and discover that others have tried to redact
by sohkamyung 8y ago
One possibly is because they want to make sure the redacted sections are really redacted. You can do a web search and discover that others have tried to redact sections of PDF documents, only to later discover that people can uncover the redacted sections via software tools.
Scanning a redacted document is the simplest way of making sure redacted sections stay redacted as there is no underlying information to reveal.
- rossenberg79 8y agoYou nailed it. Aside from that anyone who is serious about search is going to run it through an OCR and get the raw text anyway. Why bother doing more work?
- lostlogin 8y agoOffering a plain text file with the odd “[redacted text]” alongside a formatted PDF is hardly onerous. That said, there are numerous instances of governments releasing a .doc or similar and someone opening it and doing a few presses of ‘undo’.
- rossenberg79 8y agoThere’s just no reason to. Someone will fuck it up, and it will not have been worth the effort anyway.
- ALittleLight 8y agoReleasing the plain text is all that's needed. I fail to see how redacting by overwriting the relevant text is at all reversible - e.g. replace every redacted word with five X's. Replace multiple redactions with ten X's. That actually seems more secure than what's currently done, where you can guess at the words by their length.
- WrtCdEvrydy 8y agoTrust me, people have failed... and we've fucked it up in the past. The easiest way is to use a PDF redactor, print it and rescan it.
- wahern 8y ago> Releasing the plain text is all that's needed. I doubt Mueller's team wrote the report in plain text. They probably used Microsoft Word and exported a PDF document. When I'm president, all government agencies will be forced to use LaTeX. Then we can have both plaintext source, PDFs with actual text, and PDFs that don't leak redacted material.
- caseysoftware 8y agoLaTeX? That will effectively prevent most government agencies from writing reports.. oh, that was your goal, wasn't it? Well played.
- i_grow_beans 8y agoAnd I suppose they'll be published in GovtHub, so that anyone can fork them and add their annotations. I'd vote for you, but I'm not a citizen.
- antt 8y agoContext is much better for documents: http://www.berenddeboer.net/tex/LaTeX2ConTeXt.pdf http://www.berenddeboer.net/tex/LaTeX2ConTeXt.pdf