4 ms·
> But jerf, what are US dollars backed by I agree with you almost 100%, just wanted to add that no current Government/State can back the nominal monetary mass
by paganel 8y ago
> But jerf, what are US dollars backed by
I agree with you almost 100%, just wanted to add that no current Government/State can back the nominal monetary mass flowing through its economy with real money, no matter the amount of taxes they're collecting. The reason being that the nominal monetary mass it's pretty big (to use an euphemism) compared to the real money flowing through the real economy.
For example in 2008 the CDS market alone was at some point "valued" at close to $36 trillion [1], while for comparison the US GDP back then I'd say was around $14-15 trillion (give or take a few trillion). Yeas, I know the CDS market back then was a financial abomination, and I do know that a lot of those $36 trillion were probably money counted twice or thrice or even more, but the idea remains. And that's just one market.
What indeed still keeps this whole house of cards still standing, what keeps any financial system standing, is trust. And, as you very well put it, once you have the power to put people in jail (or launch inter-continental ballistic missiles) you kind of have a lot of trust by default. But there are moments when no matter how powerful you are you still manage to lose that trust, see the USSR post 1989 or the Spanish Empire during and after the rule of Philip II [2], that's when things turn nasty:
> Charles V had left his son Philip with a debt of about 36 million ducats and an annual deficit of 1 million ducats. This debt caused Phillip II to default on loans in 1557, 1560, 1575, and 1596 (including debt to Poland, known as Neapolitan sums). Lenders had no power over the King and could not force him to repay his loans. These defaults were just the beginning of Spain's economic troubles as its kings would default six more times in the next 65 years.[9] Aside from reducing state revenues for overseas expeditions, the domestic policies of Philip II further burdened the Spanish kingdoms and would, in the following century, contribute to its decline, as maintained by some historians.[10]
[1] https://www.bis.org/publ/qtrpdf/r_qt1806/images/graph-1.jpg https://www.bis.org/publ/qtrpdf/r_qt1806/images/graph-1.jpg
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philip_II_of_Spain#Economy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philip_II_of_Spain#Economy
- panarky 8y agoIt's a zombie idea that fiat currencies are somehow "backed" by tax collection, or the military, or the "legal tender" text on the banknote. No matter how many times we go through the refutation, zombie ideas like this just never die. Money is purely a social construct. It only has value because people collectively find it useful. There is no backing.
- tim333 8y agoI'm not convinced it's a zombie. Name a currency that's existed a few decades and does not have backing from any of those.
- chipotle_coyote 8y agoI think the point being made is that the exchange rates of any currency -- whether from currency A to currency B, or currency B to "hot dog, fries and soda" -- are essentially set by shared belief, not by some kind of intrinsic value, no matter what the currency is ostensibly backed by. The idea that currency needs to be backed by anything in the sense it's being used here (e.g., a tether backed by a dollar, or a dollar backed by a fixed amount of metal) is a convenient fiction that requires trusting all the entities explicitly or implicitly involved in the transaction. I'm aware bitcoin and other blockchain-based "currency" tries to expunge the need for trust, but in practice it seems like most of them succeed more in expunging accountability. The argument that state-issued currencies have value because they're the only currency you can use to pay taxes back to the state is true in some sense, but the value is still essentially arbitrary and the trust is still required. (e.g., if I owe money come April 15th, I have to trust my bank, Visa, and TurboTax, probably, even before it gets to the IRS).
- johnrgrace 8y agoThe one exception would be the Canadian Tire dollar, it existed for 40 years with only the backing of a major retailer. I've read a few academic economics papers on the Canadian Tire dollar because it's an exception.
- tim333 8y agoAlthough Wikipedia has "but is not considered a private currency" for that. But you are backing up the point that there isn't much that's existed a while that isn't backed by something. The other thing I thought of as a well known non backed currency was literally monopoly money. Though that "can also be used as a derisive term to refer to money not really worth anything" It'll be interesting to see how the cryptos work out. I'm optimistic that bitcoin will still be valuable in decades to come due to scarcity and fame. Bit like Van Goghs and that kind of stuff.
- somedudetbh 8y ago> For example in 2008 the CDS market alone was at some point "valued" at close to $36 trillion [1], while for comparison the US GDP back then I'd say was around $14-15 trillion People say this all the time, but regardless of whether or not the CDS market was or wasn't a shitshow at the time, comparing the outstanding notional to GDP is meaningless. At the time, the CDS market worked like most derivatives markets: you face a small set of players and you are constantly offsetting existing transactions and subjecting them to netting rules on a master isda. So like, let's say Foocorp has 100m bonds out there. I want to buy protection on 1m of this (basically, I want to buy default insurance). You agree to sell this to me. Ok, there's 1m in CDS contracts' notional value outstanding. Now, our views, other risks, whatever changes. Maybe I sell the bonds, and holding this CDS is too risky for me now because it's just a naked short of bonds I'm not long. Maybe you buy a bunch of these bonds, and now you're not only facing the default risk of the bonds but paying the default insurance to me. So you decide to buy another CDS offsetting your existing one. I'm also trying to flatten out here so I sell a CDS offsetting my existing one. Now (mutatis mutandis) we're both at 0 CDS risk. We each have entered into 2 swaps, they're directly cancelling. But the total notional? Now it's 2m. Contracts expire, so the number doesn't strictly go up, but given how the products are bought and sold, it mostly does. It would be like looking at the stock market not in terms of the market cap of all the companies, but as the dollar value of all the trades made in a certain time period. It's not that this number is meaningless, it's just that it does nothing to explain how much is "at risk". Of course in reality this is all much more complicated, but the basic principle holds. Anyway, I know this isn't your main point.