6 ms·
Looking at Uber, WeWork, JustEat etc., I get the feeling there's a growing gap between what we were brought up to believe about entrepreneurship and innovation
by rchaud 8y ago
Looking at Uber, WeWork, JustEat etc., I get the feeling there's a growing gap between what we were brought up to believe about entrepreneurship and innovation vs. what the reality is.
We're all familiar with the '>50% of small businesses fail' stat (not the real number) and that we should be toiling and not taking a salary for years until we break even, i.e. reach a point where we're no longer losing money on every project/sale. If you aren't able to achieve this, your pricing, product-market fit, etc. have failed, because the all-knowing, all-equilibrium-izing market has spoken.
Every politician out there shows reverence for the 'small businessperson' taking risks and bringing jobs and tax revenue into their communities. But once in office, the people they meet with are Travis Kalachian and others, people who cannot make a profit, but are excellent at convincing rich investors that they should make Travis a millionaire.
The reality is that a VC-backed company can simply outprice any competitor, and if it's not enough, can lobby city hall to change the laws to favour them. And this cash spigot can stay on for years, as long as you can show you're gaining customers every quarter. If you're a big enough play, you can move your whole HQ to a low-tax friendly country and administer local operations from there.
The jobs that are created by this are right around minimum-wage level, so how is this supposed to create wealth for anybody except the shareholders who got in early with cheap valuations?
- JimboOmega 8y agoThe question (with Uber in particular) is that if this business model really covers up a huge ponzi scheme. Before the last decade (or even 5 years?) the amount of money some of these companies have been raising would have been unheard of and required an IPO. But if you can keep finding ever bigger investors to give you ever more money... It's a really weird reality, because typically the worst kind of place to start a company is one with huge barriers to entry that requires a ton of money to get started. Yet that seems to have done quite well recently. Squashing minimum wage service providers seems to be merely a side effect... these companies can't really make money EVEN WHEN they ignore regulations and exploit their not-technically-employees.
- Traster 8y agoI think that's a really interesting concept. People think Uber will reach a scale where either it can use automation to reduce costs or jack up prices. It may well be the other way around - as it matures regulations catch up and the loopholes it was using to keep costs down disappear and their costs slowly increase instead.
- jameslevy 8y agoPlaces like NYC already show this in practice.
- an_account_name 8y agoCan you elaborate? I don't have any context on this other than taking a Lyft in NYC once.
- ancientworldnow 8y agoNYC introduced fees for ride sharing with destinations or pickups in Manhattan to reduce congestion. They also added fees to guarantee a reasonable minimum wage for the drivers of the ride sharing app. The difference in price between a cab and a uber/lyft is relatively small. Convenience seems to be the primary driver for which people use (cabs in Manhattan frequently because of ubiquity, apps in other boroughs).
- greenyoda 8y agoNYC also imposed a cap on the number of ride sharing vehicles that could be operated. Uber is suing to try to overturn it: https://www.consumeraffairs.com/news/uber-suing-new-york-city-over-cap-on-ride-sharing-drivers-021819.html https://www.consumeraffairs.com/news/uber-suing-new-york-cit...
- losteric 8y agoOr that terrible customer experiences which are currently "exceptions to the rule" end up becoming the norm at whatever they pay drivers/charge customers... there are only so many good drivers and customers/contractors burned by bad experiences will not come back to Uber's platform.
- munificent 8y ago> how is this supposed to create wealth for anybody except the shareholders who got in early with cheap valuations? Spoiler alert: It's not. The primary goal of a VC-backup startup is a positive return to its VC backers. Everything else is a necessary evil to attain that primary goal.
- danieltillett 8y agoNow for the million dollar question - how is this different to a ponzi scheme?
- 55555 8y agoIt isn't JUST a ponzi scheme, but to some degree it sure seems like it is in part a ponzi scheme. Public investors pay back VCs and the entreprenuer and then get shafted. Actually, let's work through the Wikipedia definition line by line. > A Ponzi scheme ... is a form of fraud that lures investors and pays profits to earlier investors with funds from more recent investors.[2] One distinction that could be made is that the entreprenuer isn't actually paying investors back himself. Rather the investors are finding new investors and re-selling their shares up the river. > The scheme leads victims to believe that profits are coming from product sales or other means, and they remain unaware that other investors are the source of funds. In a very literal sense, when you invest in Uber's Series A and then sell your shares on an exchange after IPO, you are aware that your profits are coming from other investors. However, I think in a pretty meaningful sense people believe the value of the company has increased due to 'product sales or other means'. It seems like a Ponzi-like startup is not illegal because it's not as deliberately deceptive nor is it schemed by a single party/person, but rather it's more the creation of the entire market and what is really causing the profits/payouts is more up-for-debate. (I should have used the legal definition though, not Wiki.)
- plankers 8y agoSo... you're saying that the entire market is currently churning out legal ponzi schemes? Or is it that the entire market is itself currently a ponzi scheme? Either way, I get the distinct impression that I've seen this movie before and I didn't like the ending.
- anthonypasq 8y ago>The reality is that a VC-backed company can simply outprice any competitor this assumes bad ideas get enough vc funding to do what uber is doing. they dont.
- EpicEng 8y agoElizabeth Holmes would like to have a word
- joncrane 8y agoDon't forget the other group of people who benefit: the users of the app.
- cc439 8y agoHow much of that benefit is purely short-term though? In a hypothetical world where Uber and Lyft's current pathway to profitability never pans out, what are the ramifications. The most obvious one is that their fares will increase by 25-50% depending on the market, pricing them well above the legacy taxi services that existed before the arrival of these VC-backed companies. The second most obvious ramification is that many of those legacy taxi services have been run entirely out of business in smaller markets. My home county of 1m+ people is now down to 1 shady taxi service with a handful of ancient, beat up Crown Vics (last produced in 2011) and they only hang on due to the incredibly low standards for taxi regulation in our region. If Uber and Lyft fail or become far less useful due to cost increases, there are significant barriers to entry for a new, clean, and professional taxi service to enter the market as they don't get to play by VC rules and have to start a highly capital intensive (for a small business) operation by conventional rules while only being able to attract a customer base entirely through conventional means of marketing, and all at a very small cost advantage versus the ride sharing giants.
- stanleydrew 8y agoI don't really understand the point you're making. Why do small taxi companies have any more right to exist than Uber/Lyft? Or what exactly are they better at than Uber/Lyft that would justify keeping them around? Any driver who was formerly driving for a small taxi company could simply drive for Uber/Lyft. So what is the benefit of having management be local vs centralized?
- dmix 8y agoBecause they make money and they are being all corporatey in their big corporation buildings! Local artisnal petite bourgeoisie businesses only available to middle class people living in downtown urban areas are the only moral form of capitalism! That and when you get tired of the city and decide to start a farm in rural Oregon.
- _red 8y agoThats an excellent question. The real answer lies in 2 things: (a) Fiat money, and thus (b) Artificially low interest rates. As long as the money printers, keep printing, and also keep interest rates at 0%, then all sorts of market distortions will continually be produced as the dream of some return is better than the promise of none.
- matchagaucho 8y agoThis is really just about the dynamics of mobile hailing and logistics. Of course it's cheaper than actually calling a Taxi dispatcher, verbally providing a pickup location, and paying cash. But how much cheaper? Uber, Lyft, Grab and others are in the business of figuring out those margins... and riders will pay rate increases as supply and demand equalizes.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- napier 8y agoYou've nailed their single differentiating unique selling point.
- cududa 8y agoNot really. Before Uber I’d say ~50% of the drivers I ordered never showed up. Missed tons of flights this way
- mpweiher 8y ago> cheaper than actually calling a Taxi dispatcher But we have apps for hailing Taxis...? These do all the automated hailing, tracking the taxi for pickup (got my anxiety levels down quite a bit, I've had taxis not come for important trips), as well as payment and ratings (optional).
- robertAngst 8y ago> payment and ratings Underrated, never felt cheated out of a lyft or uber. I've even tipped.
- fwip 8y agoYou should be tipping nearly every single time you take Uber/Lyft/taxi.
- swlkr 8y agoOne way to combat this as a small business is to be in it for the long haul, like pinboard
- idlewords 8y agoThe current VC-funded startup economy manages to combine the worst vices of central planning (capricious allocation of resources) with laissez-faire capitalism (impoverishment of those not at the top). It really is a terrible failure pattern.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoMost 'small businesses' are not startups. Far from it. They are shops, restaurants, contractors, accountants. Even most 'big companies' are just small one's that grew into something. Starbucks, H&M, IKEA. They were never the kind of 'entrepreneurial' in the Valley/Startup sense. It's why VC/Valley is so focused on tech because there are inherent multipliers. Uber and WeWork are providing a value add. Both of them have upped the game in some way. Yes - the funding bubble distorts everything miserably but that doesn't take away from the fact that people want cheap and fast rides, and they want cool places to work.