4 ms·
This article is probably too nuanced to be perceptible to HN readers. Ultimately, though, it comes down to a principled, "who are you calling cis?" If your wor
by ncmncm 8y ago
This article is probably too nuanced to be perceptible to HN readers.
Ultimately, though, it comes down to a principled, "who are you calling cis?" If your worldview depends on distinguishing yourself from two uniform "cis-gendered" populations, you are doing the same violence to each cis person that "they", collectively, are doing to you.
What makes it nuanced is that, collectively, "they" are, but you are not collective enough to do it back, wholesale, and nobody, particularly, is one of "them". Meanwhile, doing it back, individually, is just abuse for being a more cissy than you.
The only person who can legitimately put someone in a box is that person, whether the box is queer, female, male, or what-have-you. Even those so deluded as to try to keep to a box deserve, anyway, as much respect as they offer, and probably a little more because everybody has bad days.
But we don't know, for most people, how boxed they are, or how much respect they accord others, without more context than we usually get.
- Jemm 8y agoNumerous studies show that humans have the propensity to view other humans as non humans and that this propensity happens with as little stimuli as seeing someone riding a bicycle. You can imagine how people who do not conform to gender norms are seen as less than human. People who do not experience this dehumanization are fundamentally not equipped to understand the situation. Thus saying that 'cis' persons are experiencing 'violence' is stunningly absurd. If anything, cis people are the ones in boxes based on societies discrimination against anything that does not conform.
- ncmncm 8y agoEveryone experiences dehumanization at times -- as you note yourself, riding a bicycle can suffice to provoke it. Either being treated as "other" is violence, or it's not -- who you are does not determine whether you get to complain of it. Everyone acknowledges that many of the people you are calling "cis" tend to keep to the same boxes as you have put them in with your own comment. Not all do, though, including the author and me, and I doubt she would relish you putting her in one any more than I do.
- not-really 8y agoSo, the amount of people that would find the word “cis” to be an insult is vanishingly small. So small that what might be considered nuance in this context is beyond the scope of what defines the word nuance. The reason it’s as small a group of people as it is, is because first, you’d have encounter someone trans. There are few trans people one might happen upon, outside of dense urban cores. To say one in a thousand is padding the density distributed across the suburban population. Second, you’d have to locate a trans individual advertising (or attempting to advertise) a clearly determined gender of some kind. Third, you’d have to interact with this person. Fourth, you’d have antagonize them. More often than not, inviting problems for yourself. Fifth, after introducing conflict, you’d have to know that “cis” is viewed as a counter-slur by in-group trans people. Sixth, you’d have to interpret the context of the usage as not an abbreviation for sister. Seventh, you’d have to be a gender that doesn’t fit the premise of being referred to as a sister. Eighth, you’d have to clear these previous requirements and care about the insult that was just used against you. Ninth, for the burn of the insult to really stick, you’d have to be outnumbered by those also recognizing “cis” as a slur. Tenth, and finally the most punishing moment of the supposedly insulting counter-slur, you’d need at least one peer of your own in-group to turn against you and side with the individual using the counter-slur of “cis” against you. There is, exceeding a five-nines level of probability, near certainty that for most people that ever hear the word “cis” pronounced by a live human being standing within earshot, and used in anger, no situation ever reaches 8. When used in anger against those self identifying as male, most have a hard stop at 5. And five just leaves the victim slightly confused and dismissive. So the situation, as described, teeters on the brink of fantasy. For most trans people hoarding the word “cis” in their arsenal of concepts, they will never get to use to its intended effect it in a situation that matters. Even now, on the internet there is a six sigma certainty that among the sevens IRL, very nearly none will cross over to an eighth degree “cis” target. So, to sum up, the word “cis” pretty much doesn’t have any impact, for all the effort impressed upon it.