4 ms·
Dark Matter Detector Records One of the Rarest Events Known to Science
- le-mark 8y agoThanks to the XENON1T dark matter detector lodged under the Gran Sasso mountains of Italy, scientists have recorded one of the rarest events to ever be detected: a special type of radioactive decay in xenon-124. It's an amazing feat, because the decay of this isotope is extremely, extremely slow. In fact, xenon-124 has a half-life of 1.8 x 10 to the power 22 years – roughly one trillion times longer than the age of the Universe. Does that qualify as impossible odds?
- qzw 8y agoDredging up memories from high school chem: not actually impossible odds. Half-life means the time it takes for half of the atoms out of a given quantity to decay. There are 6.02E23 atoms per mole, and about 8 moles per kg for xenon. So with a large enough quality of xenon-124, some decay event should happen within a reasonable timeframe. Of course it’s still a tremendous technical feat to actually setup and detect such an event.
- Benjamin_Dobell 8y agoI think the article just did a poor job of portraying the rarity of the event. This article links to a Gizmodo article[1] which does a better job of explaining that they had 3.2 tonnes xenon-124 and many occurrences: > After 214 days of observing (177 days of usable data), the researchers’ analysis revealed approximately 126 two-neutrino double electron capture events. [1] https://gizmodo.com/dark-matter-detector-makes-incredible-neutrino-observat-1834270148 https://gizmodo.com/dark-matter-detector-makes-incredible-ne...
- ianai 8y agoIndeed, larger samples will observe higher rarity events/outcomes.
- iamgopal 8y agoIt's probability, not rule I think.
- gus_massa 8y ago(I'll repost one of my comments in a similar thread, with a few minor changes.) If you have only one xenon atom in a box, to have a 50% chance that to see that it decayed you should wait a "1.8 x 10^22 years—or about a trillion times the age of the Universe". If you have two atoms in a box, you must wait approximately half of the time to have a 50% chance to see the decay. (It's not exactly one half, there are some technical details here, but one half is a good approximation.) They have 2 tons of xenon. I'm not sure if 1 ton = 1000kg or 907 kg, but it doesn't change the result too much. I'm also not sure about the isotope of Xenon they are using, so I'll use 131 as the atom mass, but it doesn't change the result too much. With 2 tons you have 2 x 907 * 1000 / 131 x 6.02x10^23 = 8E28 xenon atoms, so you expect to have a few decays per hour (if I did the calculations correctly). I'm not sure if they can detect the 100% of the decays and the noise level, so it probably takes a longer time to detect a good signal.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- the8472 8y agoThe decay in question is from xenon-124, so they're probably using a natural isotope mix which will also contain those quasi-stable ones.
- gus_massa 8y agoWikipedia says that the natural abundance of Xenon-124 is 0.095% = 1/1000. Adding that correction I get a few decays per day that is more similar to the data reported in other commit that is 126 events in 177 days. Edit: I think I'm missing a ln_e(2) in the calculation, but it's only a 30% more or 30% less. It's not a huge change in the result.
- tibyat 8y agoarticle says “1,300 kilograms (2,866 pounds) of xenon isotope” not sure if that was intentional..
- eps 8y agoFor something this exceedingly, impossibly rare I’d expect an in-depth discussion of how this is NOT an instrument mistake or a mis-interpretation of the measurements. There appears to be none of that.
- ddavis 8y agoIf you read the paper I’m sure you’ll find the information you’re looking for. These types of experiments spend decades understanding all potential background events and trying to limit them.
- ianai 8y agoThat’s also one of the harder things to summarize or bring to a lay audience.
- SiempreViernes 8y agoIt's a 4.4 sigma detection, so not a discovery by particle physics standards. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-019-1124-4 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-019-1124-4 I've heard suggestions that the result is more of a curiosity than of fundamental importance, and that this is why they get to publish a uncertain result in nature.
- zaroth 8y ago4.4 sigma ... uncertain result. You partical physicists are a funny bunch!
- computerex 8y agoNeeds to be 5 sigma
- SiempreViernes 8y agoThe famous 750 GeV bump of 2016 reached a maximum significance of 4.4 before dropping down as more data was added. Particle physics has a lot of events, so locally improbable things get likely when considering the totality of the data sets.
- madengr 8y agoWow, 2800 pounds of Xenon, at $120/gram, is about $150M. Hope they don’t have leaks. I thought these detectors used dry cleaning fluid.
- magicalhippo 8y agoSNO has some $300M worth of heavy water in its neutrino detector. They manage to get it on loan for one dollar[1]. I know DEAP uses argon[2], for example. IIRC the move to these more exotic fluids are due to the need to suppress the background noise. [1]: Slide 10, https://indico.cern.ch/event/661324/attachments/1511564/2373279/CERN_Colloquium_McDonald_Final_1.pdf https://indico.cern.ch/event/661324/attachments/1511564/2373... [2]: http://deap3600.ca/ http://deap3600.ca/
- Herrin 8y agoI worked on a different xenon-based experiment[1] for my PhD. We were looking for similar rare decays to learn about neutrinos. Our observation of double beta decay of xenon 136 used to be the record for rarest decay. Xenon has some very nice properties as a particle detector for rare events: 1. For one thing, it's a noble element, and so it can be purified very well to reduce background decays of other elements. 2. It's also a very heavy atom, and so it's self-shielding from external radiation. The core of the detector is shielded very well from radiation coming from the outside, so any signal you see there is most likely from decays of xenon or from things like dark matter WIMPs that don't interact much with matter. 3. It is a natural scintillator[2]. It gives off light when an interaction or decay ionizes the xenon atoms. That lets you actually detect the event, and by collecting the scintillation light, and the electrons from the ionization, you can get a decent measurement of the energy of the event. 4. It's recyclable. The XENON1T experiment follows the XENON100 experiment. The 100 kg from XENON100 were reused in XENON1T, and the tonne from XENON1T will be reused in future experiments. So the cost gets amortized. $120/g sounds on the expensive side. The price is always changing based on supply and demand. One manufacturer deciding to use xenon in some process, or finding a way to replace xenon with argon, can swing the price by an order of magnitude. As for leaks, I can say on our experiment we took the possibility very seriously. The entire xenon gas system was made of ultra-high-vacuum plumbing, and we helium leak checked every connection. When the xenon was outside the experiment in bottles, we had sniffers around the bottles to make sure they weren't leaking. We also had emergency systems in place if we needed to recover the xenon, including a "balloon of last resort" that would've captured the xenon in the event of a catastrophic failure. [1] https://www-project.slac.stanford.edu/exo/ https://www-project.slac.stanford.edu/exo/ [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scintillator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scintillator
- zw123456 8y agoThis is, I am sure, a dumb question, but I read this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XENON https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XENON and I just don't know enough to completely understand the concept, but my dumb question is how do they know the event they saw was a spontaneous decay and not caused by a WIMP or whatever Dark Matter is? If it is such a rare event, how do we know that it wasn't a dark matter particle that caused it but the reaction was different than anticipated ? Can anyone take on a ELI5 here ?
- lisper 8y agoIt's not quite as rare as the article makes it out to be. It's not like they by chance happened to detect a single event that only happens every few trillion years. They had a TON (actually three tons) of xenon. Decay events happened every few days, and they collected over 100 of them. Those events have a particular "signature" that allows them to be distinguished from other kinds of events. Even then, they needed to apply statistical methods to compute the odds that the data they were seeing was real and not from random chance, and the result was that the odds were not quite high enough to qualify as a discovery by the usual standards. Details are in the original paper, which is pretty accessible: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1904.11002.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1904.11002.pdf
- lisper 8y agoArstechnica has a much better summary: https://arstechnica.com/science/2019/04/dark-matter-detector-identifies-extraordinarily-rare-radioactive-decay/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2019/04/dark-matter-detector... But the best source is the original paper, which is quite readable even for a non-expert: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1904.11002.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1904.11002.pdf
- voodoochilo 8y agoI doubt that. Too improbable.