3 ms·
> There was a time when cities built their own transit! I think working for a government used to be an attractive option. No it'd be extremely hard to justify
by chrisseaton 8y ago
> There was a time when cities built their own transit!
I think working for a government used to be an attractive option. No it'd be extremely hard to justify accepting a government salary for the same job you could be doing for the contractor for literally 3x the money and far better working conditions.
- sokoloff 8y agoTo be honest, I'd have to be paid more to work within a government system than for a private employer to put up with governmental BS and lower job mobility.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoIf you're at a point where the money isn't as important as stability it could be worth it. As a close relative of mine who was a lifelong state bureaucrat put it "you have to rape a kid to be fired but you'll keep your pension unless you video tape it" which based on other things that happened in his department over the years is an exaggeration but not a big one. I'd definitely consider working for the government after my house is paid off.
- sokoloff 8y agoFunny you mention that. Once money is no longer an issue, I'd consider going to work for a university. Many of the same benefits (and drawbacks). A few years ago, I seriously considered working for EdX as I believe in the mission, but all the EdX positions that were open were MIT employees (amazing benefits, fixed [and uncompetitive] salary structure) and we had two young kids at home so it wasn't the right time to consider that.
- saiya-jin 8y agoDarn that's sad. Once money is not a primary issue, I would much prefer working 80%, or 60%, whatever compared to just gaining more stability. Pushing papers, playing politics, losing touch with progress in real world (affecting employability), that's a bad direction in any age.
- chrisseaton 8y agoI don't know... having the threat of having a pension removed sounds like yet another terrible thing about working for the government. My private sector pension is my property, in a managed fund. The company can't do anything to it.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoThe implication was that if your pension is removed it's a non-issue because the state is providing you food and shelter on their own terms.
- chrisseaton 8y ago> you'll keep your pension unless... In the government you can lose your pension. In the private sector you can't. In both cases you have state benefits. How's that a benefit of being in government?
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoBy "on their own terms" I meant prison. Like if you do something bad enough to lose your pension it's because you did something so bad that you're going to jail for the rest of your life.
- chrisseaton 8y agoI still don't get it. Even if I go to prison I don't lose my private sector pension. Government pensions are worse because they have the option of removing them. They can't do that in private sector because it's not part of any contract or company control - it's a trust.
- pnutjam 8y agonot all pensions are judgement proof
- radmuzom 8y agoIn all large companies I have worked (>10K employees), the level of bureaucracy is similar to the government and decision making is really slow. In my experience, "private is more efficient" is a myth and primarily driven by ideological reasons.
- badpun 8y agoHave you worked for the government? I have (as an external contractor) and the level of bureucracy and waste was on a entirely different level than at even the most inefficient private company (a large bank) that I've worked for.
- achenatx 8y agoWe are contractors that identify the most valuable features for the least amount of money. We have worked with two state agencies and learned that entire philosophy is moot in a government agency because they dont care about the value of features and they dont care about saving money. It was incredibly depressing and so we generally try not to work with government agencies.
- Frondo 8y agoI used to work for a business that sold a software platform to both government buyers and large private companies, and we saw absolutely no difference in inefficiency, waste, and fiefdom-building. Those things are all absolutely a matter of organizational size, almost to the exclusion of everything else (including public/private distinctions). Some of our most frustrating clients were the massive private sector companies that would kick around a proposal for six months, call meeting after meeting, and deal with an ever-changing cast of stakeholders who needed to sign off on this round. At least in government there was less flux in who we dealt with over time.
- badpun 8y agoThree points: 1. Government is orders of magnitude larger than the biggest companies, and, whats' worse, the inefficiencies scale (my guess) exponentially and not linearly. 2. Government assumes democratic oversight, which is way more costly and time intensive to implement than the rule of the iron fist of the shareholders via board of a company. 3. A lot of the ways the government functions is passed as laws. If a private business needs to do a major change of strategy, say was the case with Tesla recently where they decided to get rid of the dealerships, they can implement it very quickly - whereas in government, an operational decision of this magnitude (say the IRS deciding to close local branches), would probably require changing many laws - which involves political bargaining and just general queue to get the new law passed in the parliament. BTW this is true even for much smaller stuff, like the template of the forms for tax returns - they cannot be changed willy-nilly, but need a new law to be passed (usually at a lower level than parliament, but still). Imagine facebook needing to go through some internal legislation process every time they change a form on their website - so much for "move fast and break things".