4 ms·
> The people who invented the tech (US/Europe/Japan) optimised it for consumers around them. I must confess that it grinds my gears too when people rail agains
by taneq 8y ago
> The people who invented the tech (US/Europe/Japan) optimised it for consumers around them.
I must confess that it grinds my gears too when people rail against makers for being 'selfish' or discriminatory when the things they make end up best suited for people like them.
You could even see such a accusations as implicitly insinuating that the non-catered-to groups are somehow less capable of innovating their own more suitable alternatives.
- kbutler 8y ago"Take up the White Man’s burden— And reap his old reward: The blame of those ye better The hate of those ye guard—" Rudyard Kipling The dominant culture will get blamed for either not doing enough or for doing too much, so you have to do what you can, and what you feel is right, accept useful feedback, and realize you can't please all the people all the time. This seems to have touched a nerve, which is not unexpected. Examples: - colonial powers are criticized both for exporting agricultural technologies westernizing other countries and for not exporting enough - Hollywood is criticized both for cultural imperialism and for not including enough diversity as well as for cultural appropriation - foreign aid is insufficient/creates dependency/empowers corrupt governments/is colonialism/... - tourism is exploitation but no tourism is isolationist, crippling to the economies, ... etc. Any action (including inaction) is likely to be criticized, so you've just got to do your best, and try to improve as you learn.
- neonate 8y ago> touched a nerve, which is not unexpected With this you've confessed to trolling. I mean, the White Man’s Burden? Come on.
- kbutler 8y agoThe Kipling reference shows that the issues with technology raised in the thread are merely new aspects of an old dilemma. What is my responsibility to share something I value? That could be culture, technology, religion, defense, ways of raising children, marriage age, purifying water, sanitation, etc. Where does "sharing" and "helping" become "imperialism" and "patronizing"? Where does not sharing become negligence? What level of customization for varying physical/cultural needs/preferences is required? We make our best choices but may get criticized by others who choose differently, and will likely be judged harshly by future commentators, just like Kipling is now.
- taneq 8y agoPosting a viewpoint, sincerely held, which you know will be unpopular, is not trolling. They seem to believe what they're saying.
- neonate 8y ago> They seem to believe what they're saying Most trolls do.