2 ms·

So, you are implying these are my responses even though I never actually wrote them? How is that different from telling me I did not supply citations?

• jodrellblank 8y ago
  You asked me where I think you didn't address certain points. As you didn't address them, I have no text from you to copy or refer to, I can only point around the area where you didn't talk, to show that it exists. When you say "work to get smarter instead", that says the problem is a lack of work and a lack of "smart", and therefore that people are ill because they're dumb. It follows from what you said, even though you did not write those words out. So yes, I imply that your responses are your responses. How is that different from telling me I did not supply citations? I don't want to read citations, I mentioned them as one example of what "addressing a point" could look like, so that the absence of any of these possible things supports that you didn't address them.
  • baxtr 8y ago
    I asked questions. I never thought about supplying citations when asking questions. I get the feeling you read lots of judgement into my question. My intention was to create a discussion around the question. Anyway, I guess there is little value in discussing further. Thank you for explaining your reaction. Definitely food for thought