3 ms·
Tether functions as sort of the reserve currency of crypto. Many exchanges don't even offer fiat money or banking connections - to use them, you have to send B
by nostrademons 8y ago
Tether functions as sort of the reserve currency of crypto. Many exchanges don't even offer fiat money or banking connections - to use them, you have to send Bitcoin in from another exchange or a personal wallet, then you can convert it into Tether or other altcoins. People who are "getting out of crypto" by selling Bitcoins because they think the price is gonna drop oftentimes are actually buying Tethers. When 80% of crypto trading is denominated in your currency, there isn't really a bottom to fall to.
To actually exit Tether, most of these people would have to buy Bitcoins or another cryptocurrency accepted by most exchanges, register for the account verification processes there (every exchange that handles fiat money has the same KYC procedures as banks, i.e. take a picture of yourself and your driver's license and wait a couple days while an employee manually verifies it), transfer your Bitcoin to the other exchange, sell it to USD, and then move it out to a bank account. That takes time and a lot of hassle. We'd expect to see a rise in the price of BTC at USDT-based exchanges as Tether holders need to convert to Bitcoin to get out, along with a fall in BTC at fiat exchanges as they sell that Bitcoin. To some extent this is happening (Coinbase Pro's BTC price is almost $100 less than Tether-only exchanges like Binance or Bitfinex), but it's less severe than I would expect from a true run on the bank. Most Tether holders probably figure they'll take their chances because the hassle of getting out is worse than the possibility of losing their investment.
Reserve currencies can go a long time before people finally run for the exits. The US dollar hasn't been backed by anything since 1971 and is still ticking strong.
- eunoia 8y ago> We'd expect to see a rise in the price of BTC at USDT-based exchanges as Tether holders need to convert to Bitcoin to get out, along with a fall in BTC at fiat exchanges as they sell that Bitcoin. To some extent this is happening (Coinbase Pro's BTC price is almost $100 less than Tether-only exchanges like Binance or Bitfinex), but it's less severe than I would expect from a true run on the bank. The small spread is very interesting. I would also expect it to be much higher. Tether seems to be pegged at $1.00 on Bitfinex but trading (increasingly) below that on Kraken [1]. Do you know of a better free resource for monitoring the situation by chance? No stake, just curious. [1] https://www.cryptocompare.com/coins/usdt/markets/USD https://www.cryptocompare.com/coins/usdt/markets/USD
- nostrademons 8y agoBitfinex reports their prices in USD but I'm pretty sure that's bullshit. It's like saying "Each Tether is worth $1 because we say so." The Kraken price is much more accurate. I suspect the price is holding up because most holders of Tether don't consider this a big problem. Either they believe that the NY AG will find that there are adequate reserves backing Tether after all, or they believe the reserves don't matter at this stage and other holders of Tether will continue to believe it's worth a dollar. Comments on this HN thread seem to support that. It's unlikely to change unless some exchanges go under entirely, and authorities in the U.S. don't really have the jurisdiction to do this. I've been following coinmarketcap.com and openmarketcap.com, and also have a Coinbase Pro account that I'm using to track the Coinbase price (which actually diverged pretty significantly from the CMC prices this afternoon...must be a time lag). I don't have enough invested in crypto to get particularly emotionally attached either way.
- bhouston 8y agoThis is much worse than not having reserves. In reserve banking there may be insufficient liquidity to handle a significant withdraw event but theoretically the money in the bank balances, it is just not liquid because it is lent out. The situation with tether is much much worse. About 30% of the money invested in tether is gone and unlikly to come back. The books do not balance, it is not a timing issue, it isn't a liquity issue tether or bitfinex is insolvent. This is important to realize, tether or bitfinex is insolvent/bankrupt if that 850m is truly gone. It is covering up this with loans between related parties, but the legality of those loans is probably questionable at best but bitfinex and tether are intertwined such that they likely have shared liabilities legally. Someone is bankrupt right now. Maybe both. The fact that tether or bitfinex isn't dropping or outright dead confuses the hell out of me. Is it so critical to crypto now and so central that even if it is involvement we have to believe in it or the sake of this whole market? This market isn't rational or I must be missing something.
- nostrademons 8y agoI think a lot of people who have accounts at USDT-only exchanges may not realize this affects them. Tether has been marketed as a replacement for the dollar and a safe place to park your wealth when you are "out of the market" in cryptocurrency. Because it's not viewed as a crypto or speculative asset in itself, people might see the headlines but not make the connection that potentially all their assets on a USDT exchange are at risk of becoming inaccessible. Also, unattended arbitrage bots might end up equalizing the price now but becoming major bag-holders later. Right now, the spread between the Coinbase & Bitfinex BTC prices is > $300. The logical response of an arbitrage bot is to buy Bitcoin on Coinbase (spending USD) and sell it on Bitfinex (receiving USDT); they provide the Bitcoin liquidity that people who want out of Tether need. This creates a counterflow of BTC from Coinbase to Bitfinex, spending down their dollar reserves at Coinbase and accumulating a Tether hoard at Bitfinex. If the bottom falls out of Tether, their accumulated profits (and any capital invested) becomes worthless.
- abakker 8y ago>The US dollar hasn't been backed by anything since 1971 and is still ticking strong. I think you might be overstating. The US dollar is not backed by an asset because it is an asset. At this point, the dollar is backed by the government, the government's authority, its military power, and the future value of its debt. That is not gold, but it is not nothing either.
- nostrademons 8y agoBy the same token, cryptocurrencies are backed by the computing networks underlying them, the potential future usage of these computing networks, and by your ability to buy guns, drugs, and hacks with them. This is also not gold (although you can buy gold-backed cryptocurrency: see Digix), but not nothing either. That's why cryptocurrency evangelists harp on adoption and new use-cases: the value of any currency is primarily set by what you can spend it on. Right now you can spend Bitcoin on a lot fewer things than US Dollars, but your personal profit potential from holding a currency derives from the rate of increase in adoption, not its current level, and Bitcoin has a lot of room to grow while the dollar has virtually none. Tether intrinsically has none of these, but because of its adoption by many exchanges, it's convertible into other currencies that have more intrinsic value. So as long as it remains convertible, it will continue to have value.
- marvinalone 8y agoUSD is backed (among other things) by the government accepting taxes in it. If you don't pay, they will come to your house with guns and take you away. This creates a demand for USD that is completely unlike any demand for crypto.
- nostrademons 8y ago...the same way that Bitcoin could, in theory, be backed by hired goons (or drones) that come to your house with guns and take you away. It wouldn't surprise me if that's how people in the underground Bitcoin economy (drugs, gambling, sex trafficking, arms dealing) actually operate, though I try to stay away from those peoples so I wouldn't actually know. There is certainly a difference in degree - the U.S. military is orders of magnitude more powerful than whatever goons you can hire with Bitcoin - but not a difference in kind.
- dmurray 8y agoThis is a fascinating view of things. It's not totally incongruous that Tether could just be worth approximately 1 USD indefinitely, "by convention" or in the same way that Bitcoin has value.
- iav 8y agoUS government has the power to tax the entire US economy, providing financial backing to the US dollar. This is why fiat currencies weaken with their national economies, and vice versa
- novok 8y agoI really want to underline this. This is the real power of fiat currency, the ability of a government to tax people in it's region. And tax means the ability to force people to give the governmental organization a portion of their productive economic activity.
- nostrademons 8y agoPeople always point this out. The astute ones point out the other half of this - the power to tax is based on the military's ability to compel payment. One other way to look at this is physical security being a service - a fundamental one - being procured by your tax dollars. This is actually mentioned explicitly in the first sentence of the U.S. Constitution: "We the people...to insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defense...do ordain and establish this Constitution." By being a citizen of the United States and complying with its tax laws, you enlist the full force of the U.S. military in securing your rights. You could easily imagine someone offering to provide military services for Bitcoin. Depending on how they wield these military services, this could range from welcome to highly inadvisable; if it turns out they are in opposition to the interests of more powerful militaries (i.e. the U.S, or other major nations), they could quickly find out just how powerful the U.S. military is.
- dillon20 8y agoThis is the weakest theory I've read yet; people aren't exiting tether because it's too inconvenient. Forgetting that they would've already gone through the KYC process when they entered the crypto market, and there's little hassle in a market sell-order and withdrawal request. The only inconvenience is the time the bank withdrawal would take to process, which isn't necessary unless your plan is to exit the market entirely, as exchanges are covered by FDIC insurance.
- nostrademons 8y agoMany of the non-fiat exchanges don't do KYC. I've signed up to a bunch (and was able to trade, subject to certain volume limits) with just a burner email address and Google Voice number.