2 ms·
No - I am arguing that the only way not to have selection bias is by doing a randomized survey - it is the very definition of selection bias. If andbberger wish
by BeetleB 8y ago
No - I am arguing that the only way not to have selection bias is by doing a randomized survey - it is the very definition of selection bias. If andbberger wishes to make a nice, nuanced argument, I encourage him/her to do so. However, if instead (s)he wishes to provide two word answers, (s)he should expect push back.
Furthermore, I highly doubt andbberger has done a randomized study, and thus the accusation of selection bias applies equally to him/her. Saying things like "perhaps you should talk to more poor people" is simply dismissive, and unjustifiably assumes that someone who is disagreeing with him/her hasn't talked to enough poor people or that the other person suffers from selection bias, and not him/herself.
Look at the whole thread: andbberger's comments are short, lacking any citations, sarcastic, accusatory ("middlebrow dismissal", not talking to poor people, talking to the wrong poor people).
Contrast with HN guidelines:
>Be kind. Don't be snarky. Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive.
(Two word responses don't help).
>Assume good faith.
(Implying people of being ignorant of the conditions of the poor doesn't help).
>Please don't post shallow dismissals
("Selection bias")
So no, I'm not commenting here to argue whether the conditions of the poor constitutes a sky falling. I'm commenting to counter low quality statements.