6 ms·
Except that having a child is an optional activity that you choose to do, whereas going to work is (usually) required. Ideally that work doesn't include period
by kelnos 8y ago
Except that having a child is an optional activity that you choose to do, whereas going to work is (usually) required. Ideally that work doesn't include periods of extreme overwork, and lucky people are sometimes able to walk away from jobs that do, but many people just have to do it in order to put food on the table.
- beart 8y ago> Except that having a child is an optional activity that you choose to do I get what you are saying, but this is not a universal truth. Life gets complicated.
- jolmg 8y agoFor the vast majority, life doesn't get that complicated. I think even 5% of the population being forced into parenthood is too much of an exaggeration.
- kelnos 8y agoThe last time I was reading on this topic, around 10% of kids are actually unwanted -- that is, one or both parents did not want to ever have kids, or did not want to have more kids. Most kids are planned to some degree. For the remainder that aren't, the couple does want to have kids at some point, but they didn't plan to have kids at that particular time. Regardless, children are optional, full stop. There are certainly reasons why people who don't plan to have kids end up having them anyway, but that doesn't change the fact that it's an optional activity.
- sidlls 8y agoWork is optional. There are plenty of people who get by without it. Doesn't mean they're doing well or healthy. And for society to continue to function having children is actually not optional.
- jolmg 8y ago> Work is optional. There are plenty of people who get by without it. Doesn't mean they're doing well or healthy. Except if you don't have a kid, you have better chances of staying well and healthy. That's the whole point. That's what is meant with parenthood being optional and work not. > And for society to continue to function having children is actually not optional. With the rate at which world population is increasing[1], I think the opposite is true. It wasn't that long ago that we reached a world population of 7 billion. Now, we're apparently more than halfway to 8 billion. How in the world can the earth support so many of us? Yesterday, there was a post here that talked about the absolutely brutal conditions that we're raising livestock in[2]. We wouldn't need to be so god damn efficient in working livestock if we didn't have so many mouths to feed. [1] http://www.worldometers.info/world-population/ http://www.worldometers.info/world-population/ [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19743006 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19743006
- rootusrootus 8y agoWell, if everyone stopped having kids effective immediately, we could have the population issue solved very quickly. Along with all our other problems, too, after a few decades of suffering.
- gilleain 8y ago7 billion, not trillion
- jolmg 8y ago:P Thanks. Fun Fact I learned from that link: Supposedly, we'll be reaching our first trillion sometime between 2050 and 2060. That's actually pretty close.
- perl4ever 8y agoIf the world population is 7 billion now and will be 1,000 billion around 2055, then by my math (142.9^(1/36)) that's a growth rate of 14.8% a year. Since the current growth rate is (based on the first few hits on Google) a little over 1%, I wonder why someone would expect it to go up that drastically. Especially with global warming and everything.
- rdm_blackhole 8y agoThat's only if our current economic model stays the same. At the moment most developed countries rely on immigration to create growth by adding more consumers. However, it is changing, as the world develops, fewer people are born and within a century our population growth will flatten and our global population will even decline to the 2000's level. Children should not be made just to keep society going. That's quite a selfish reason to have a child, to be honest.
- Robotbeat 8y agoThat’s the opposite of selfish.
- rdm_blackhole 8y agoDo you care to elaborate?
- Robotbeat 8y agoDoing something that’s essential to society but which requires enormous amount of individual sacrifice and cost. Voluntarily.
- rdm_blackhole 8y agoAnd That's where we disagree. Having kids is not essential to society. Actually, society would be better off if we just maintained our current population level and learned to live with the resources at hand instead or ever expanding and depleting the ocean, the underground and the forests until there is nothing left. If you consider having kids as an individual sacrifice, then maybe you are having kids for the wrong reasons. People should not be forced to have kids to perpetuate society or because its good for the economy or because the government( of any country) says we should.
- intuitionist 8y agoYou realize that in order to maintain our current population level, people still have to have kids, right?
- kelnos 8y ago> Work is optional. There are plenty of people who get by without it. You must live in a very different world than most people do if that's the norm among your peer group. > And for society to continue to function having children is actually not optional. At a macro level, sure (though a slow, steady reduction in population over the next few generations might do the planet some good), but on the individual level, it's absolutely optional.
- rexpop 8y agoHaving a child is optional for individuals, but not for society, and so it's really only "pseudo-optional" for individuals: there is some distributed portion of requirement on everyone.
- johnm1019 8y agoI wish there was more discussion about how society should recognize and handle this. Much of modern society is orthogonal to parenting and raising children, I would love to see it addressed more in the public discourse -- maybe even "disrupted" by tech so we can be thrice better parents, citizens, and workers.
- sjg007 8y agoI mean, I see government having a role here. Both in developing pro child development resources and policies. Europe is way ahead of the US for example. Some US states are way better than others as well.
- munk-a 8y agoNobody should be forced to work 75 hrs to put food on the table, it's dehumanizing and we, as a society, have enough wealth to make sure everyone can live a minimally enjoyable life.
- kelnos 8y agoNot sure where you're reading that in what I said.
- DoreenMichele 8y agohaving a child is ...optional A high percentage of children are not planned. They are a natural consequence of sex, which Mother Nature sneakily designed to be desirable in its own right, whether people wanted babies or not. Most of human sexual morality seems to be rooted in this inconvenient, annoying fact of life.
- kelnos 8y agoAccidents happen, sure. Education, availability, and consistent use of contraception is nowhere near where it should be (and even where it is, it's not foolproof). And when contraception fails, access to abortion can be difficult depending on local regulation, and many people have an aversion to that option for various reasons. But none of that changes the fact that having a child is indeed optional.