3 ms·
> The front-page links that say whether comments are present or not would simply be replaced with the word 'discuss' Please do not do this. This makes HN far l
by JoshTriplett 8y ago
> The front-page links that say whether comments are present or not would simply be replaced with the word 'discuss'
Please do not do this. This makes HN far less convenient to browse.
I regularly use the "N comments" information to find discussions worth reading. This has nothing to do with "being seen", it has to do with quickly finding interesting comments. The front-page screenshot you show completely removes that signal.
For a similar example, consider how many email clients show you, without opening the mail, when it was sent and whether it has an attachment. This information helps with prioritization and processing, particularly when you have many emails. Comment counts, and to some degree story scores, serve a similar function, for people who are never going to read every story on even one viewing of the front page.
I go to HN, I open a few stories and comment sections in tabs based on a combination of title, comments, and score, then close the front page and start reading.
This isn't similar to the removal of scores from comments. For those, users were already on a page full of comments, comments themselves are relatively short and shown inline, and even without scores they're still reasonably sorted by some HN-internal metric of interestingness, making it possible to just read downwards and stop when your expected value of further comments doesn't seem worth the time of continuing.
Removing comment counts and scores from stories, on the other hand, makes the front page far less usable.
To look at this from another perspective: consider the myriad stories and discussions here on HN, about Facebook and Twitter and similar trying desperately to get their users to read content they don't want to read. "Let's stop sorting timelines reverse-chronological. Let's show random things from people you don't follow. Let's make it impossible to figure out where you left off. Let's make it so when you refresh (or click-then-go-back) you get completely different content and can't find the tweet you just saw a moment ago." No, stop, don't.
- crawfordcomeaux 8y agoWould you be willing to try it for a day or a week? If so, why? If not, why not?
- sgillen 8y agoI think the comment more than answers your question.
- crawfordcomeaux 8y agoThe comment does not say whether or not they may be amenable to, say, stepping away from the screen when they'd normally be on HN. Nor does it explicit say no amount of time is acceptable nor why.
- JoshTriplett 8y agoNo, I'm not interested in HN being less usable and less convenient. I value being able to quickly get interesting news and discussion on HN, and making that less optimized would not be welcome.
- intended 8y agoBut that would be part of the point - a barrier to interrupt the ‘addictive’ aspect of a website.
- whatshisface 8y agoShould the experience of everyone be degraded to help the subset of people that are especially susceptible to addiction?
- Can_Not 8y agoBut I use that information to make my limited time on this site more efficient.
- JoshTriplett 8y agoIf you make HN less usable, people will certainly spend less time on it. That argues for an option, similar to the noprocrast options, not a site-wide change.