3 ms·
What a defeatist article! In spite of the fact that I believe that western style democracy does not work all over the world (see the alternative democratic mode
by maxklein 16y ago
What a defeatist article! In spite of the fact that I believe that western style democracy does not work all over the world (see the alternative democratic models of singapore and botswana as counter examples), there has to be a clear method to remove people abusing power.
I believe the best method that would work in many African countries, particular the decentralised tribes of the Niger-Congo A language group, would be a system of consensus selections of locally organised 'leaders'. One man, one vote does not work for such societies. Rather, the local leaders who are chosen by traditional methods should represent the people who choose them. The western system of senators and delegates results in people who do not represent any group being selected to represent groups.
Historical leadership structures in African societies should be adapted to work in a modern concept. Trying to force the european model on non-european societies has caused a lot of trouble all over the world - the illusion that this will ever work should finally be abandoned.
- JoachimSchipper 16y agoDo you propose one vote per tribe or village? In that case, what's a "tribe"? If it's one vote per person in the tribe, what's the practical difference?
- sophacles 16y agoPerhaps we could set up a system where "tribes" each get n votes based on existence in one governing body, and each of a tribe's villages gets a vote in a different governing body. Then both have to agree before a final decision is enacted. Tribes and villages would be responsible for their own internal politics, and how to assign voting rights.
- maxklein 16y agoI propose that places are encouraged to pre-negotiate their candidate and have a legal way to offer up a single candidate, instead of the full choice being available.